Properties are selected based on real traveler reviews and popularity among guests who’ve booked a night in Mayville on Hotels.com. These Mayville hotels consistently deliver on quality, location and traveler experience. Last updated on November 17, 2026.
Price: $83 nightly, $94 total, Nov 29 - Nov 30, Total with taxes and fees
Located near Lake Erie, this family-friendly hotel offers an indoor pool, lazy river, and complimentary water park access. Enjoy the hot tub and sauna after visiting nearby Creek Park, then retreat to rooms with convenient refrigerators and microwaves.
Price: $119 nightly, $134 total, Nov 19 - Nov 20, Total with taxes and fees
Unwind at this Mayville motel near Chautauqua Lake, where the indoor pool invites year-round swimming. After exploring nearby attractions like the Chautauqua Belle Steamboat, relax in the hot tub while enjoying free breakfast, WiFi, and parking.
This historic hotel sits within a 10-minute walk of Chautauqua Lake and Institution. Guests can enjoy the on-site restaurant, bar, free WiFi, and complimentary parking. The 24-hour front desk and attentive staff ensure a comfortable stay near the Amphitheater.
Price: $111 nightly, $125 total, Nov 26 - Nov 27, Total with taxes and fees
Escape to Peek'n Peak Resort with direct access to downhill slopes. Enjoy 6 restaurants, tennis courts, and a golf course after hitting the snow. Fellow travelers praise the pool and helpful staff at this Clymer getaway near Wilderness Lodge.
Price: $89 nightly (Step into lakeside luxury at this Celoron retreat featuring both indoor and seasonal outdoor pools. Just minutes from Lucille Ball Memorial Park and Northwest Arena, this hotel offers 2 bars/lounges, restaurant dining, and fitness facilities. Guests praise the friendly staff and convenient free WiFi and parking.), $100 total, Dec 1 - Dec 2, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $49 nightly, $55 total, Nov 22 - Nov 23, Total with taxes and fees
Tucked between Lake Erie and Chautauqua Lake, this welcoming Westfield motel offers clean, comfortable rooms with free WiFi. Explore nearby McClurg Museum and Vetter Vineyards Winery, then return to enjoy complimentary parking and attentive staff assistance.
Price: $89 nightly (Quiet and comfortable rooms at this centrally located hotel provide easy access to the National Comedy Center and Northwest Arena. Enjoy free breakfast, an indoor pool, and 24-hour fitness center after a day of sightseeing.), $101 total, Nov 22 - Nov 23, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $96 nightly (Unwind at this quiet lakeside spot with Pearl City Hops restaurant and 24-hour fitness center. Just minutes from the National Comedy Center, this hotel offers comfortable stays with free parking and attentive staff.), $109 total, Dec 13 - Dec 14, Total with taxes and fees
Minutes from two picturesque lakes, this modest motel offers 24-hour service with complimentary WiFi and parking. McClurg Museum and Grape Discovery Center are nearby attractions worth exploring during your countryside getaway.
Price: $103 nightly (This business-friendly Jamestown hotel offers free WiFi and parking, plus a 24-hour fitness center. Take a swim in the indoor pool year-round. Located near Roger Tory Peterson Institute, with helpful staff ready to enhance your stay.), $116 total, Dec 16 - Dec 17, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $117 nightly, $132 total, Dec 19 - Dec 20, Total with taxes and fees
Quaint retreat minutes from Lake Erie featuring a welcoming restaurant and stylish bar/lounge. Enjoy complimentary breakfast, WiFi, and parking while exploring nearby Darwin R. Barker Historical Museum and Fredonia Opera House.
Price: $106 nightly, $120 total, Dec 1 - Dec 2, Total with taxes and fees
Wake up to a complimentary buffet breakfast at this Jamestown hotel near Roger Tory Peterson Institute. The fitness center, free WiFi, and parking complement your stay while the attentive staff ensures comfort during your adventure.
Price: $169 nightly, $191 total, Dec 17 - Dec 18, Total with taxes and fees
Discover this charming motel with direct access to Lake Erie and a seasonal outdoor pool. Free WiFi and parking enhance your stay while exploring nearby Presque Isle Wine Cellars. The helpful staff ensures a memorable lakeside retreat in Harborcreek.
Price: $79 nightly (Steps from Chautauqua Lake, this hotel offers quiet rooms, a 24-hour gym, and restaurant with bar options. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, and breakfast in a convenient spot near local attractions and shopping destinations.), $90 total, Dec 17 - Dec 18, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $75 nightly (Wake to sweeping Lake Erie vistas at this waterfront hotel, where peaceful surroundings and scenic beauty create unforgettable sunsets. Enjoy the 24-hour fitness center, complimentary breakfast, and easy walks to nearby restaurants and Dunkirk attractions.), $85 total, Dec 10 - Dec 11, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $68 nightly (Wake up to a complimentary buffet breakfast at this quiet Dunkirk retreat. Just 5 minutes from Lake Erie and close to SUNY Fredonia, this hotel offers free WiFi and parking. Nearby restaurants and the Rockefeller Arts Center provide convenient entertainment options.), $77 total, Dec 17 - Dec 18, Total with taxes and fees
Price: $144 nightly, $163 total, Dec 1 - Dec 2, Total with taxes and fees
Unwind at this traveler-favorite hotel offering an indoor pool for year-round swimming. Free perks include continental breakfast, WiFi, and parking. Minutes from Rockefeller Arts Center with easy access to local dining and attractions.
Price: $91 nightly, $103 total, Nov 19 - Nov 20, Total with taxes and fees
Escape to this inviting hotel near Mead Park, where cozy rooms welcome you after a day of exploration. Unwind at the bar with a drink, maintain your routine at the fitness center, and enjoy free perks like breakfast, WiFi, and parking.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
If you’re after a show while in the center of Chautauqua, you might want to get tickets at Chautauqua Amphitheater. If you want to experience more of the culture Chautauqua has to offer, head to Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua Belle Steamboat, and Chautauqua Lake.
Chautauqua Belle Steamboat is 0.9 mi (1.4 km) from central Mayville, why not stop by during your stay. If you have fun at Chautauqua Belle Steamboat, you'll love Midway State Park and Chautauqua Bookstore, both located nearby.
Chautauqua Bookstore is in the heart of Mayville, so why not stop by during your stay. If you have fun at Chautauqua Bookstore, you'll love Chautauqua Belle Steamboat, located nearby.
Address: 7592 East Route 20, Westfield, NY, 14787, US
Location: Westfield
Star rating: 2/5
Guest rating: 8.6/10 (663 reviews)
Review: The Theater Motel was built in a different era and shows its wear and tear. When I arrived the host and her very cheerful toddler greeted me. The bed was new, the room, linens and bathroom were clean. The room had a slight musty smell but well within expectations. Many chain hotels could take a hint from these hosts’ efforts in providing a pleasant experience. They are working towards improvements and deserve the support of budget minded travelers., by Steve, September 30, 2015, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Review: More Handicap parking closer to entrance would be nicer. The staff saw me struggling to walk with my cane so a employee ran over with a wheel chair and took me all the way to our room and said we can keep it till we check out. She also went back and found the foot pads for the chair which made it easier to elevate the legs. Also I checked the second day of our stay and asked if I could take the chair with us to see some family in the area and he checked and said ok which was a great help as I..., by GREGORY, July 14, 2023, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Address: 2811 North Main Street, Jamestown, NY, 14701, US
Location: Jamestown
Star rating: 2.5/5
Guest rating: 9.2/10 (882 reviews)
Review: We had the pleasure of staying in this hotel on two separate occasions this past July. It was so wonderful on our first trip; there was no question where we'd stay when we returned to Jamestown. You can still smell the "newness" of the hotel in each room. The rooms had impressive new furnishings and were very spacious - we booked a double bed room and suite with a sofa bed, microwave, and small bar sink. The beds were super comfy and the bathrooms were immaculately clean. Free breakfast in the..., by BlessedMamaof3, August 4, 2015, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Review: Room was clean and quiet. Walkable to the Cherry Lounge for beer and wings. Easy free parking.Overall very satisfied., by Monty, December 24, 2023, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Review: Everything was perfect! The only thing is that there is no elevators but you do not have to walk up that many stairs. Little difficult with cooler but overall not too bad. No other complaints, love Peek'n Peak!, by Laura, July 14, 2025, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Address: 30 Lake Shore Dr E, Dunkirk, NY, 14048, US
Location: Dunkirk
Star rating: 2.5/5
Guest rating: 7.6/10 (1001 reviews)
Review: It was a good stay. Staff are pleasant and have a desire to serve. A new brewery is on its way. The included breakfast was complete…hot upscale continental. Shout out to banquet server Karen O., by Norman, July 6, 2022, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Address: 3912 Vineyard Drive, Dunkirk, NY, 14048, US
Location: Dunkirk
Star rating: 2.5/5
Guest rating: 7.8/10 (1001 reviews)
Review: My son attends SUNY Fredonia we have stayed here several times to attend events at the college. Always happy with the room and the service!, by Dale, May 3, 2017, rated 10/10 Exceptional
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a hotel room cost in Mayville?
You can find top hotels in Mayville from $55 with options to suit your budget and needs. If you're looking for an affordable hotel in Mayville that meets all of your requirements, just sort hotels by "Price: low to high" after applying your filters when searching on Hotels.com.
How can I find deals and earn rewards at Mayville hotels?
Discover great deals on Mayville hotel stays with Hotels.com. Take a look at hotel prices mid-week or during the low season as to find those off-peak deals. And make sure to check out our last-minute deals on Mayville hotels.
Can I book Mayville hotels with free cancellation?
To book a refundable Mayville hotel on Hotels.com, just filter hotels by "Property cancellation options" and select "Fully refundable property". Many hotels offer free cancellation, so you can receive a refund if you need to cancel. Some hotels do require cancelling more than 24 hours before check-in, so double-check your booking beforehand.
What are some top pet-friendly hotels in Mayville?
Our travelers' favorite pet-friendly hotels in Mayville include:
Athenaeum Hotel: A hotel with a guest rating of 8.6 out of 10
You can also use the "Amenities" filter in your search on Hotels.com and check "Pet friendly" to discover more pet-friendly hotels in Mayville.
What are some of the best Mayville hotels with free parking?
If you're driving, a great Mayville hotel with free parking is a bonus. Our travelers' favorites include:
Athenaeum Hotel: A hotel with an average guest rating of 8.6 out of 10
If you're looking for hotels in central Mayville, check out Athenaeum Hotel. Travelers love Athenaeum Hotel for its location, as well as the restaurant, bar/lounge and free parking this hotel offers.
Find out more about Mayville
Discover Mayville: Where Lakeside Serenity Meets Academic Inspiration
Nestled along the shores of Chautauqua Lake, Mayville, New York, is a charming escape that beautifully blends natural beauty with small-town allure. This serene destination invites visitors to explore the scenic Mayville Lakeside Park, perfect for leisurely strolls, picnics, and breathtaking sunset views. Nature enthusiasts can enjoy boating, fishing, and hiking in the surrounding areas. With its quaint shops, local eateries, and the nearby Chautauqua Institution, Mayville offers a unique cultural experience. Whether you seek relaxation or adventure, Mayville is a delightful retreat that captures the essence of lakeside living.
Discover great hotels near Mayville
Mayville, New York, offers a variety of accommodations suitable for travelers, including cozy inns, charming bed and breakfasts, and comfortable hotels. Room rates vary based on the season and demand, providing options for different budgets. Explore different properties to find the perfect stay in this picturesque region. Here are some of the best hotels near Mayville that our travelers love:
Theater Motel: Theater Motel is a budget-friendly motel that offers exceptional comfort and convenience for leisure travelers. With a guest rating of 8.6 out of 10, this hotel features entertainment options like multiple televisions in rooms, ensuring a cozy stay. Guests appreciate the spotless accommodations and friendly service, highlighting the hotel's safe neighborhood and easy parking. The combination of competitive pricing and a comfortable atmosphere makes Theater Motel an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable and enjoyable experience in Mayville.
Holiday Motel Westfield: Holiday Motel Westfield is a charming budget-friendly motel that caters to travelers looking for a pet-friendly experience. Offering accommodations that allow pets, this property ensures a welcoming atmosphere for all guests. With a focus on comfort, Holiday Motel Westfield features essential amenities to make your stay enjoyable. The inviting environment and accommodating policies create a warm retreat for leisure travelers who wish to explore Mayville with their furry companions.
Southern Comfort Inn of Lily Dale NY: Southern Comfort Inn of Lily Dale NY is a delightful guesthouse designed for leisure travelers seeking a distinctive experience. This property boasts a variety of entertainment options, including smart televisions with streaming services, making it easy to unwind after a day of exploration. The thoughtful design and inviting atmosphere invite guests to relax in style. With a focus on comfort and modern amenities, Southern Comfort Inn of Lily Dale NY provides an enjoyable getaway for those looking to immerse themselves in the charm of Mayville.
Where to stay in and around Mayville
When visiting Mayville, New York, great areas to stay include Bemus Point, Chautauqua, and Westfield. Bemus Point offers scenic lake views and charming attractions, while Chautauqua is perfect for golf enthusiasts and cultural events. Westfield is known for its wineries and boutique shops. For first-time visitors, Chautauqua is the best choice, providing a unique blend of recreation and culture.
Chautauqua: Chautauqua is a charming destination perfect for those who appreciate culture and relaxation. Nestled on the shores of Chautauqua Lake, it offers a unique blend of natural beauty and artistic experiences. The Chautauqua Institution hosts a renowned summer program featuring lectures, concerts, and performances, making it a vibrant hub of activity. Golf enthusiasts will enjoy the nearby golf courses, which provide scenic views and a relaxing atmosphere. Plus, you can spend leisurely days exploring the lakeside parks or indulging in various water sports.
Bemus Point: This picturesque village on the shores of Chautauqua Lake is ideal for travelers looking to unwind by the water. Bemus Point boasts stunning lake views and a laid-back atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for boating and fishing. The local parks and walking trails are great for leisurely strolls, while the quaint shops and cafes provide a cozy place to relax. Don't miss the chance to catch a sunset over the lake, as it offers a breathtaking backdrop for your stay.
Westfield: Westfield is known for its beautiful wineries and charming downtown area, making it a delightful choice for wine lovers and those seeking a peaceful getaway. The local wineries offer tours and tastings, showcasing the region's incredible vineyards. Strolling through the downtown area, you'll find unique boutiques and artisan shops that reflect the community's character. Westfield also hosts various seasonal events, providing visitors with a taste of local culture and hospitality.
Things to do in and around Mayville
Nestled beside a shimmering lake and surrounded by rolling hills, Mayville invites travelers to bask in its natural beauty. Enjoy leisurely days of boating and sunbathing on pristine beaches, or tackle scenic hiking trails that wind through lush forests. With opportunities for golfing and catching live theater performances, there's something for everyone to enjoy in this charming lakeside town.
Lily Dale Spiritual Center – Discover the serene atmosphere of Lily Dale Spiritual Center, a historic monument that invites exploration. This unique destination is known for its spiritual practices and stunning surroundings, making it a great spot to unwind and reflect.
Lily Dale Assembly – Engage in educational experiences at the Lily Dale Assembly, where workshops and lectures on spirituality and personal growth take center stage. This place offers a chance to learn from knowledgeable speakers and participate in enriching discussions.
Chautauqua Belle Steamboat – Hop aboard the Chautauqua Belle Steamboat for a delightful cruise on Lake Chautauqua. Enjoy scenic views while learning about the rich history of the region from the friendly crew. It's a charming way to experience the beauty of the lake.
Whitney Bay – Spend some time at Whitney Bay, a beautiful bay perfect for a leisurely stroll or a picnic. The tranquil waters and stunning views make it an ideal spot to relax and enjoy nature.
Long Point on Lake Chautauqua State Park – Venture to Long Point on Lake Chautauqua State Park, where you can explore hiking trails, enjoy fishing, or simply soak in the breathtaking views of the lake. This national state park is great for outdoor enthusiasts looking to connect with nature.
5 tips for savvy savings when booking a hotel in Mayville
Book for the cheapest times: The most affordable time to visit Mayville is during January, March, and November, when hotel prices are lower. To fully experience the city's key landmarks, cultural sites, and historical attractions, it's best to plan for at least a 2 to 3-day stay. This budget-friendly trip allows you to explore attractions such as the local golf courses, scenic lakes, and the university, while also enjoying the vibrant theater scene and dining options. Visiting during these months could provide great value for money, as prices may drop even further.
Instant discounts. Rewards for later: Save up to 20% instantly on hundreds of thousands of properties with Member Discounts. Then earn rewards on eligible stays to use on future trips. Book once, win twice, get instant discounts and rewards. Join for free.
Score last-minute deals on Hotels.com: Last-minute travel doesn't mean last-minute stress. Hotels.com's Last-Minute Deals offer discounted rates close to your travel date, so the later you leave it, the more you could save. Turn on push notifications and you'll be the first to know when deals drop for Mayville.
Book with confidence, not guesswork: Prices in Mayville shift with the season, local events, and how far out you book — but you don't have to guess. Hotels.com shows you the full price upfront with no surprises at checkout, and our price tracker tells you whether your dates are above or below average. So if you're flexible, you can shift your trip by a day or two to avoid peak season prices, compare prices and know you're getting a good deal before you commit.
Think beyond the city center: Central hotels may come with a central price tag. A well-connected neighborhood a little further out may cut your hotel bill and can often give you a more local experience. Use Hotels.com's map view to find the sweet spot between location and value, and filter by price to see what's available across Mayville.
Best time to go to Mayville
Mayville experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 26.4°F (-3.1°C), while July is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 70.3°F (21.3°C). October are usually the wettest months. June to August are the peak travel months in Mayville, attracting a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, accompanied by light rainfall. On the other hand, October to December tend to be quieter times to visit, marked by light rainfall and mostly cloudy conditions.