All hotels in Islandia, New York, United States of America
1 room, 2 adults
Sorry, you can’t collect Hotels.com® Rewards nights here

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia

3.5 stars3.5 stars
3635 Express Dr NIslandiaNY11749United States of America, 800-491-6126
Excellent4.2 / 5
Room
Room needs to be improved
Location
Great location
Service
Fantastic service
Bar and Beverages
Bar is awesome
165See all 165 Hotels.com reviews
From 752 reviewsTripAdvisor Traveller Rating

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia

Hotel Info: 866-539-8117

  • Standard Room

Recent reviews

Excellent 4.2 /5 from 165 reviews

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia
Good3.0 / 5
Poor location, maintenance, cleanliness & service
The room felt very aged and dated. Peeling wallpaper, massive spiderweb in the corner over the bed. Housekeeping skipped over servicing our room so we had to request extra towels. There also seemed to be too many functions going on (4 weddings, 2 reunions and a college football team staying there!!!) as there was drunken screaming up and down the hallways all weekend.....one drunk woman even crashed through the center of the revolving door to have a cigarette. On the whole, I would not recommend this hotel and it definitely was not worth the price paid. A Days Inn would have been better.
2 night family trip
Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia
Outstanding5.0 / 5
Convenient and Comfortable Hotel
The property is older (I actually stayed there in the 90s), so it definitely looks it, but it's in good condition. The room was spacious and comfortable. We were on the top floor and it was very quiet. The staff was excellent. They were so accommodating and helpful. We asked for a crib and it was brought straight to the room. Room service was tasty with a good menu, and it was fast. There is breakfast offered for a fee downstairs. They have a buffet of all the popular breakfast foods as well as a waffle station. It was great to eat right downstairs in a comfortable environment and the food was good! There is a pool, but we only stayed one night, so we didn't see it. Check in and check out was easy! All in all, we very much enjoyed our stay and would stay again. I must say once more that I was extremely impressed by their staff. They were truly excellent.
1 night family trip
Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia
Outstanding5.0 / 5
Great venue for events
Clean, classy hotel - what you expect from Marriott.
1 night trip with friends
Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia
Excellent4.0 / 5
Was put on a floor where there was a wedding party -was very noisy other then that was very pleased
3 night family trip
Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia
Outstanding5.0 / 5
Fabulous Customer Service
The service at the bar/restaurant was spectacular! Yvonne, Mel and Neal were absolutely fantastic. Our party of 14 could not have been happier with their attentiveness and service.
1 night trip with friends

See all reviews

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino, Islandia

Is the description of this hotel not correct? Tell us