Skip to main content.

Hotels in Shelter Island, New York

Search & Compare Shelter Island Hotels

Save more with Secret Prices

Get instant savings with Secret Prices

  • Pay now or later on most rooms
  • Free cancellation on most rooms
  • Price Guarantee

Best hotels in Shelter Island

What's Shelter Island Like?

If you're looking to discover somewhere new, look no further than Shelter Island. Whether you're planning to stay for a night or for the week, the area around Shelter Island has accommodations to fit every need. Search for hotels in Shelter Island with by checking our online map. Our map displays the areas and neighborhoods around all Shelter Island hotels so you can see how close you are from landmarks and attractions, and then refine your search within the larger area. The best Shelter Island hotel deals are here with our lowest price guarantee.

Where are the Best Places to Stay in Shelter Island?

Below are the number of accommodations by star rating in Shelter Island and the surrounding area:

  • • 3 5-star accommodations from USD 225 per night
  • • 42 4-star accommodations from USD 139 per night
  • • 74 3-star accommodations from USD 60 per night
  • • 29 2-star accommodations from USD 45 per night

How to Get to Shelter Island

Flights to Shelter Island

  • • East Hampton, NY (HTO), 7.6 mi (12.2 km) from central Shelter Island
  • • Fishers Island, NY (FID-Elizabeth Field), 20 mi (32.2 km) from central Shelter Island
  • • Montauk, NY (MTP), 20.3 mi (32.7 km) from central Shelter Island

Things to See and Do in Shelter Island

What to See in Shelter Island

  • • Sylvester Manor
  • • Mashomack Preserve
  • • Havens House
  • • Wades Beach

Things to Do near Shelter Island:

  • • Shelter Island Historical Society (1 mi/1.5 km from the city center)
  • • Raphael Winery (7.8 mi/12.6 km from the city center)
  • • LongHouse Reserve (8 mi/12.8 km from the city center)
  • • Pindar Vineyards (8.1 mi/13 km from the city center)
  • • Wolffer Estates Vineyard (8.1 mi/13 km from the city center)

When Is the Best Time to Visit Shelter Island?

  • • Hottest months: July, August, June, September (average 80°F)
  • • Coldest months: February, January, December, March (average 20°F)
  • • Rainiest months: April, March, November, and October (average 4.38 inches of rainfall)