Skip to main content.

Hotels in Fishers Island, New York

Search & Compare Fishers Island Hotels

Save more with Secret Prices

Get instant savings with Secret Prices

  • Pay now or later on most rooms
  • Free cancellation on most rooms
  • Price Guarantee

Best hotels in Fishers Island

Fishers Island overview

If you're looking for a new favorite getaway, look no further than Fishers Island. Fishers Island might not have well-known attractions within the city, but you won't need to venture far to find top places to visit like Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea. You can take some time to discover the surrounding area and sights like Morgan Point Light and Avery Point Light.

Where to stay in Fishers Island

Whether you plan to stay for a night or a week, Fishers Island has the right hotel for you. You can shop as many as 228 deals for Fishers Island accommodations on, some with discounts of up to 43%. Our room prices start at 34 USD per night and below you'll find the number of hotels by star rating in Fishers Island as well as in the surrounding area:
  • • 3 5-star hotels from 179 USD per night
  • • 48 4-star hotels from 129 USD per night
  • • 81 3-star hotels from 76 USD per night
  • • 36 2-star hotels from 45 USD per night

What to see around Fishers Island

Here are some recommended places to see in the surrounding area:
  • • Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea (6.1 mi/9.9 km from the city center)
  • • Morgan Point Light (3 mi/4.8 km from the city center)
  • • Avery Point Light (5.1 mi/8.2 km from the city center)
  • • Bluff Point State Park (5.3 mi/8.6 km from the city center)
  • • Stonington's Old Lighthouse Museum (5.5 mi/8.8 km from the city center)

When to visit Fishers Island

Do you want to know the ideal time of year to visit? Here are the seasonal norms to help with your planning:

Seasonal temperature averages
  • • January-March: 52°F day, 22°F night
  • • April-June: 79°F day, 36°F night
  • • July-September: 82°F day, 51°F night
  • • October-December: 68°F day, 24°F night
Seasonal rainfall averages
  • • January-March: 12.52 inches
  • • April-June: 12.28 inches
  • • July-September: 12.09 inches
  • • October-December: 12.95 inches