Atlantic Inn

Would never stay there again.

Atlantic Inn is located exactly next to the Long Island RailRoad route, so it's impossible to sleep there. At first, our room looked out to the LIRR, and every time a train passed, it felt like a tornado was approaching. We asked to change the room for the next nights, but even though the windows looked out on the opposite side, we could still hear the LIRR noise pretty clearly. Also, the room was not very clean when we moved in. The location around the hotel is quite scary, the subway is about a 10-minute walk away, but the surroundings do not look very safe. I would never stay there again.

Only if you no other options...

Location: -It look like a bad area to me. We had a alarm one morning at 8h am maybe 5-6 police car and 2 ambulances where there. One of the hotel client have been arrested in front of us... -You have a train in front of your window. It makes a lot of noise. -Distance from Manhattan is good but a taxi would be very expensive. Metro line A will get you to Manhattan in around 20-30min. -Nothing interresting is close surrounding. Cleanliness: -The hotel is clean and the rooms are also clean. -They did not clean our rooms ather the first night. The guy at reception told me you need to ask to clean the room when you leave the hotel.

Very Scary -- Avoid

Little did we know this hotel is in one of the worst areas in the country, let alone New York. You have to walk three blocks of ghettoness before you get to the hotel. (And we live in DC, so we're much more immune to the urban-vibe than others.) There is an above ground subway right in front of the hotel that wakes you up every 30 minutes at night. This is the worst hotel ever, please spend $20 more and save yourself the trouble.

Guest did not leave a comment.

Only for those who work the night shift

I would not suggest any person stay at this hotel unless they work the night shift on an hourly basis. Then one would feel comfortable there.

Shady

The staff was not around nor were they helpful with questions or when something was needed or wrong in the room. Not to mention the room was not cleaned everyday.

3 stars?

Three stars is misleading when the heighborhood is unsafe to walk in and the noise from the elevated train across the street rumbles through the room at regular intervals.

Adequate for a brief stop over

This hotel was built relatively recently so the physical plant is in good condition, and the room was clean. It's located on a busy street with an elevated commuter train so noise level is higher than the already noisy New York City. It's close to the subway. My room was poorly planned with no closet space. I was provided with 2 bath towels (no hand towels or face towels). Only one opportunity for maid services is provided because they are short on staff.

Slightly Misrepresented!

Beautifully remodeled, however... no closets (no place to hang anything, period.) Special note to families: this location rents *BY THE HOUR* Might bring up some interesting child/parent discussions!

Bad location. Room is a cage. Extremely noisy.

Don't stay there.

too much for to little

the rooms were very small parking was limited much to pricey

"Needs Improvement"

They need to pay a close attention to the condition of the sheets, pillows cases and towels they put in the hotel room. I was really disappointed of the way things are. For exemple, the sheet in my room had a big hole and the pillow case had a "fresh red make up" on it. After so many complaints to the person responsible at the front desk, they finally sent a concierge to change them, but not before half an hour or more; but later I realized that one of the "face cloth" in the bath room was completely dirty. For the price that they charged me, it was a total waste.