If you obtain a lower rate after booking, please call us first. See Customer Care for details.
Find Nearby Properties

mm/dd/yyyy

mm/dd/yyyy

0

0
Adults (ages 19+)
Children (ages 0 - 18)
Room 1









Salisbury Hotel, New York, NY

Salisbury Hotel

Star rating: 2.5 of 5
123 W 57th St
New York, NY, 10019
866-539-0036
Average Rating
4.4
Recommend
95%
711 Guest Reviews

from $279.00

Lowest avg. nightly rate

This rate first available on Sunday, Nov 29

Select a Room & Rate Price Match Guarantee

Review Details for Salisbury Hotel:

  • 95% Recommend
  • 4.4 Average Rating
  • 711 Guest Reviews
Hotel Service
4.4
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.3
Room Cleanliness
4.5

Nothing is more important than the opinions of our guests.

Post a Review Review FAQs

Average Rating by Reason for Trip:

Select the reason for trip to view only those reviews

All Trip Types
(711 ratings)
Average Rating 4.4 of 5
Business
(98 ratings)
Average Rating 4.2 of 5
Romance
(55 ratings)
Average Rating 4.6 of 5
Family
(205 ratings)
Average Rating 4.5 of 5
With Friends
(154 ratings)
Average Rating 4.6 of 5
All Others
(199 ratings)
Average Rating 4.3 of 5

Filter Individual Reviews By:

Sort Reviews by:

Next Next Page 1 of 50 Previous Previous
Trip Type: With Friends Review 1 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Business Review 2 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 

Not Recommended

Trip Type: Business Review 3 of 741
Overall Rating
3.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
2.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
2.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great Location and Price, but So Smelly

The Salisbury Hotel was a great location - walking distance to shops, attractions, Central Park. The staff were nice and helpful. Drawbacks - room very musty, smelled like smoke, even though there was a nonsmoking sign. The closet smelled terrible. Elevator did not work for a bit, which meant walking down more than ten flights. Overall, mixed review, but given how expensive hotels are in NY, this was a good deal, I guess.

 
Trip Type: Business Review 4 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Outstanding, older hotel

This is the second time in the past year I have stayed at the Salisbury Hotel through Hotels.com. Both times I have thoroughly enjoyed it. It is a very comfortable hotel that while a tad "worn" in places, is nonetheless EXTREMELY comfortable, clean, nicely staffed and situated in a vibrant neighborhood. Each time, I was upgraded to a large, well-equipped suite, an amazing value for the price. The only drawback is that rooms on the street side are noisy.....but earplugs can help that. I always look for this hotel on Hotel.com's website when booking a room, and am disappointed when it is not available for the dates I travel.

 
Trip Type: Business Review 5 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Excellent location with large, clean rooms. Great for the money.

I loved it.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 6 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
great for the money

This is a older hotel but in a good location for walking and discovering museums,Times Square, Central Park etc. Plan to spend some time.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 7 of 741
Overall Rating
3.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Breakfast woes

The room is just fine, bed comfy, everything clean. A breakfast voucher is slipped under the door, you go to the 3rd floor and find out it's $6 per person. After scalding my tongue on the first sip of coffee (in a paper cup), I left without eating any of the sugary donuts or bagels, without cream cheese. It's NY, how could there not be cream cheese with the bagels? Otherwise, it was fine.

 
Trip Type: Business Review 8 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Overnight Stay Review 9 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
3.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great hotel

The location of this hotel is outstanding without being one of the priciest hotels in NYC. It is walking distance to Broadway, Central park and shopping The lobby was disappointing but the rooms were fine.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 10 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great room for the money

The hotel is older but is kept up very well. We found everything very comfortable and suitable for a weekend in New York. The front desk and concierge were very helpful.

 

Not Recommended

Trip Type: With Friends Review 11 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
3.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Business Review 12 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Well Kept Secert

The Salisbury Hotel experiance was great. I was unsure of what I was getting when I booked it,since the price was so great. I did not expect a very "great" hotel. But is an outstanding Hotel. I was given a choice of room location..noesy Street or quiet back..I took quiet. Room much large than expected, for a 2 double room. Large closet, Kitenet area with fridge, mircowave and coffepot. Bathroom very satisfactory. Bedroom had 2 double beds,2 easy chairs, a desk and chair,and a large dresser. It was located within easy walking distance to many attractions and transprtation : subway,buses, and cabs. I felt very safe at night walking around the neighborhood. I will definatly stay their again and recommend it to friends

 
Trip Type: Business Review 13 of 741
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 14 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Big Bang for the Buck

The hotel is not for those who stay at the usual chain hotels -not expensively renovated. It does provide everything you require in large rooms that are spotless. The location is great.

 
Trip Type: Overnight Stay Review 15 of 741
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great hotel!

The reception staff were quite pleasant, the room was clean and comfortable and the bellman were helpful and nice throughout my stay.

 
 
Next Next Page 1 of 50 Previous Previous

Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect hotels.com's position. Neither hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews.