If you obtain a lower rate after booking, please call us first. See Customer Care for details.
Find Nearby Properties

mm/dd/yyyy

mm/dd/yyyy

0

0
Adults (ages 19+)
Children (ages 0 - 18)
Room 1









New Sheridan Hotel, Telluride, CO

New Sheridan Hotel

Star rating: 3.5 of 5
231 W. Colorado Ave.
Telluride, CO, 81435
866-539-0036
Average Rating
4.7
Recommend
91%
11 Guest Reviews

from $149.00

Lowest avg. nightly rate

This rate first available on Sunday, Nov 29

Select a Room & Rate Price Match Guarantee

Review Details for New Sheridan Hotel:

  • 91% Recommend
  • 4.7 Average Rating
  • 11 Guest Reviews
Hotel Service
4.5
Hotel Condition
4.7
Room Comfort
4.5
Room Cleanliness
4.9

Nothing is more important than the opinions of our guests.

Post a Review Review FAQs

Average Rating by Reason for Trip:

Select the reason for trip to view only those reviews

All Trip Types
(11 ratings)
Average Rating 4.7 of 5
Business
(0 ratings)
Average Rating 0.0 of 5
Romance
(3 ratings)
Average Rating 5.0 of 5
Family
(2 ratings)
Average Rating 5.0 of 5
With Friends
(2 ratings)
Average Rating 4.5 of 5
All Others
(4 ratings)
Average Rating 4.5 of 5

Filter Individual Reviews By:

Sort Reviews by:

Next Next Page 1 of 1 Previous Previous
Trip Type: Family Review 1 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great historic hotel

Recently renovated rooms, while a little small are more than adequate for two people and are very well done and the attention to detail is outstanding. The remodeled bathrooms even have heated floors. Note that the hotel does provide parking but it is on the local streets through the use of a parking permit. During off-season I had no problem parking. Great restaurant and bars.

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 2 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
High-end hotel right downtwon Telluride, walking distance to everything

Hotel has been beautifully retored, rooms are superbly decorated with high-end linens, fixtures and furniture. Hotel also has two bar areas - once inside the main lobby and one right next door as wells as a chop house restaurant with outside and inside seating. Only problem was with the Room with a View. On a summer night after the bars let out and the streets filled with people who tend to be loud and smokers. Since the hotel doesn't have A/C in the room, we left the window open and were awoken to a smokey room and loud people outside. We shut the window, but we could still hear everyone in the streets. I would stay here again, but will request a non-view room, something a little more quieter.

 
Trip Type: Romance Review 3 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Exceptional hotel for the money

The New Sheridan Hotel in Telluride was wonderful. All of the rooms have recently been renovated and all now have private baths. The decor was gorgeous, the service impeccable. And all for a price comparable to the chain hotels. There is no question, if we go to Telluride again, we will stay at the New Sheridan. I highly recommend it.

 
Trip Type: Romance Review 4 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great Stay!

This hotel has everything you would need and more. The location was central, the staff was very friendly and the rooms, albeit on the smaller side, were designed for maximum use of space(plenty for two people). I mean ,come on heated bathroom floors!!!!! awesome. We ate twice in the hotel restaurant and the food and service were outstanding! We would definitely go back and highly recommend it. The only issue would be: ask for a room away from the stairs as you could hear the noise from the bar area slightly where we were located.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 5 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Fantastic hotel

The room was exceptional great view of the town and the montain. Very clean and the resturant is top notch.

 

Not Recommended

Trip Type: Not Provided Review 6 of 11
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
nice hotel ,priced a little high

Hotel was nice and clean. Parking was a challange.

 
Trip Type: With Friends Review 7 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Fantastic Value - Amazing Location

The New Sheridan was so much fun!! We booked through hotels.com and, unfortunately, the dates got mixed up. The guy at the front desk fixed our situation immediately (even though it was 11pm at night). We were supposed to have a room w/ a shared bathroom, and ended up with a private bath for the same rate. We both went into the shared bath a few times, and decided that even if we had our original room, the stay would have been just as fantastic. The bar downstairs was so much fun, and the noise was not nearly the problem that others have reported (and we were there during the comedy fest). Definitely check out the hot-tubs on the roof and the fresh baked cookies at the front desk! The ski lockers and location of the hotel made getting to lift 8 or the gondola a two minute trip. Definitely highly recommended!

 
Trip Type: Family Review 8 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Romance Review 9 of 11
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
A truly beautiful hotel experience

My significant other and I stayed at the New Sheridan during a weekend vacation in Telluride and, I have to say, this hotel really exceeded our expectations. The room was beautiful, the bed incredibly comfortable, and the service top notch (especially that hot breakfast - yum!). Sitting right on Telluride's main street, the New Sheridan put right in the middle of everything - restaurants, shopping, outdoor activities. This sense of being in the center of it all - yet still having a great deal of comfort and privacy - really contributed to our overall experience in Telluride. Overall, I have no complaints about my stay at the New Sheridan - this hotel really made our trip, and we will definitely know where to stay next time we are in Telluride (which will hopefully be soon!).

 
Trip Type: With Friends Review 10 of 11
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 11 of 11
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
2.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
 
Next Next Page 1 of 1 Previous Previous

Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect hotels.com's position. Neither hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews.