Gatsby Mansion Inn

I stayed in the Gatsby Mansion in 2005 and really liked it, but things seem to have changed since then. The hotel is now bigger and although it says on its walls that it's a bed and breakfast - you might not get breakfast. I booked through Hotels.com and they told me that if i had booked through the hotel's site, breakfast would have been included. […] Overall, the room was clean, the location is perfect (across the street from the clipper, walking distance to all sights). The service was ok, not great. Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Beautiful property, conveniently located. The property had just changed hands so it's hard to tell what will be improved. The restaurant was closed for remodeling and there was no desk clerk. We didn't see another person, guest or staff, the entire weekend. So it was like having our own private mansion.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Great location, friendly staff, good restaurant, close to downtown and port. Only problem would be a lot of stairs to the room if you have trouble climbing the old mansion stairs.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Note that we stayed in the Judges building, not the main Gatsby building, but you don't get to choose when booking (or I didn't anyway...) They had to change our room because our reserved room hadn't been cleaned (it was 8pm!)... the room was fine, but I was expecting more from a Victorian mansion. The bed was not good. Every move produced a loud creak, […] and the mattress was average to poor. Four-poster beds don't matter if you can't sleep. Two antique chairs in the room didn't make up for the feeling that it just wasn't a comfy place for us to hang out and spend time. Thank heaven the weather was gorgeous that weekend and we didn't have to spend a lot of time in the room. The onsite restaurant was average-to-high priced, with decent food (not great), but we only had the one breakfast there, so maybe not a fair judgment. However, I enjoyed the omelet I had down the street at the Days Inn more than the Gatsby's... Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

The perfect location to see the inner harbor of Victoria and sit on the beautiful porch an dine.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Dirty, rundown, and back-breaking bed with the cheapest linens possible. Horrible!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

We stayed in the Judges house, carpets and floors are old and worn. The bath/shower solution left the user with no place for soap or shampoo, except outside the shower on a shelf, the shower curtain was so long that it plugged the drain and the user had to stand on the curtain. The LOCATION WAS FABULOUS Check which room you are assigned to before you […] accept, our room had not outside air available in August Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

This guest did not leave a comment.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

This guest did not leave a comment.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

This is an excellent hotel if you are looking for a historic, antique location right at the center of Victoria harbor. If you prefer more modern amenities you may want to reconsider. The room can get very warm in the summer and there was no air conditioner and no proper way to prop open the window. The room was beautiful though and it had a lovely turn-of-the-century […] feel. It is not right for everyone but it has a great niche. Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

This guest did not leave a comment.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

This guest did not leave a comment.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

After all the mixed reviews, I was skeptical of what I would find. It was unfounded. It was like stepping back in time with the waste-coated walls, the trayed ceilings, the old wrought iron bed...totally romantic and just lovely, relaxing experience. The personnel were genuinely friendly and helpful. Our high tea in the hotel restaurant was just what […] we wanted...and at a far less price than competitors nearby in the Empress. We will go back there gladly in future Victoria excursions. Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

There is a difference between the Gatsby Mansion (heritage building) and the Gatsby Mansion Inn (hotel). The photos we saw online were of the hotel, not the actual mansion so we were supprised at the room initially. Due to low occupancy in the mansion, they upgraded our room for free and we had an amazing view of the harbour from the deluxe suite on […] the top floor. I agree with some of the other comments that the place seems deserted. We came down for breakfast and there was not a single person around. We had to ask the cleaning staff where the breakfast was being served (it was in the hotel section). Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Judges house needs a good clean up and it would be nice to have clearer directions to hotel services. There are several buildings with little information regarding location of restaurant, etc.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

A beautiful room in grand turn-of the century style. Service at the Inn was exceptional with the expection that we did not recieve housekeeping services even though we requested it specifically with the front desk. The room is beautifully and tastefully decorated. Guests should note that in in this room there was no shower (which should have been identifed […] prior to booking) only a tub. Internet was also very slow - understandable in a grand old building like that but if it were necessary for business then you'd be out of luck. Location is perfect - steps away from all there is to see and do in the Inner Harbour. Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Hotel looks nice from the outside. That's it. Room was absolutely frigid upon arrival. No staff to be found except in restaurant. Old squeaky bed. Awful sleep. Antique furnished does not mean old and busted. Awful bathroom. Poor state of repair and comfort. Towel rack broken, dangerously slippery flooring.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

A great place get away from the daily grind!!

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

The hotel has an excellent ambiance. We loved the high ceilings and the location and the breakfasts were great, especially the Sunday brunch. The rooms are rustic but they work well. With so much to see and do in Victoria, who needs to spend time in a room! The bed was comfy. The gal at the front desk and in the restaurant was so accommodating and nice. […] I would go there again. Read more

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

The Gatsby, Victoria is a small 19th century building with a unique old world character. If you are looking for something a bit different this is the place for you. The rooms are old fashioned but charming, the standard of service is excellent and the restaurant well worth exploring. The harbour and shops are a short walk away.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

Location is great and the hotel is nice, but would have expected more for the price. The bed was very comfy but the room was looking a bit tired, old carpet, needed a lick of paint, etc. Bathroom needed a serious update.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review

we chose the gatsby because it is a heritage building/hotel located in the heart of victoria, minutes from the inner harbour and next to the parliament buildings. it is a beautiful historical old place, refurbished nicely. we had a lovely breakfast in the sunroom in the morning. staff were very helpful and pleasant. overall a great getaway.

Genuine Hotels.com guest review