My husband and I stayed at the PSI for 3 nights. The place is beautiful with lots of amenities. The food was excellent. The staff is helpful and friendly. We did have one issue with the room. There were ants in the bathroom. We told housekeeping several times. One spritz of Raid would have solved the problem. The extra quests in our room were still […] crawling about when we left. So check the room carefully. For the price ants should not be included. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Anniversary Get Away"
The staff was wonderful! The breakfast was yummy! The room was lovely, and of course the restaurant is always exceptional!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"tranquil, upscale, peaceful retreat"
From the moment we stepped inside the doors we felt like royalty, every need was met, we never had to ask for a thing...peter shields is an oasis among inns a place to relax and kick back and enjoy.the food and service and cleanliness were amazing...Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Beautiful place to stay!"
Our stay at PSI was wonderful. The restaurant was delicious. The room (room 5) was beautiful and homey! I cannot recommend PSI more. From the outside it is quaint and well kept. From the inside it is warm, friendly and filled with aromas from the world class restaurant. Every employee we encountered was friendly and helpful. If you are in the area, […] stay at PSI. YOU WILL LOVE IT!!' Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Great getaway. We had room #1 which had a king size bed and a very large bathroom. We loved it. The Inn is across the street to the beach entrance which was a bonus. Make sure to eat in the restaurant and you can BYOB. Very enjoyable stay.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. It was great to see the ocean from our comfortable balconyGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Wonderful, amazing, fun, and relaxing. Terrific people. Get down there and have a great time!!!!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Historic Inn with Modern Sensibility"
We enjoyed a three day stay in the very charming Peter Shields Inn. Staff was attentive and accommodating. Food in the PSI restaurant was exceedingly good-- a sophisticated corn soup that was just out of this world! The Inn also obligingly provides bikes and beach equipment with a smile and ready access. Complimentary afternoon wine and cheese a very […] nice touch as well. Room was quite comfortable and well appointed with pillow top mattress and nicer toiletries. All in all, a very nice place to stay that successfully integrates the feel of old time Cape May with modern amenities and décor. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Everyone was very courteous."
Extremely enjoyable experience! Dinner was excellent, room was nice, bed was soft, Staff was great.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Beautiful Inn Overlooking the Ocean"
Lovely inn with private rooms. Nice touches include a daily wine and cheese hour and a hospitality kitchen stocked with beverages, homemade cookies and snacks.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Nice hotel. Convenient to beach. Close to shops."
Hotel was nice. Room was very small. Had to climb 3 flights of stairs. They lost our dinner reservation (which was confirmed before we arrived), and it was for our 30th wedding anniversary. NOT good. They said they could fit us in but we declined. For the money, these few disappointments took away from the experience.Genuine Expedia guest review
Girls night get away in Room number 7 "pink room" on 3rd floor. King size bed, fireplace, remodeled bathroom and dormer room view of the ocean. Snacks, coffee, tea, and soft drinks self serve provided. Beautiful experience. Included wine and cheese from 4:30 - 6:30 pm and breakfast from 8:30 to 10am. Free towels, umbrella and chairs for the beach directly […] across from the inn. All and all worth the money. Tip: dine early on Sunday - Friday from 5 - 6pm and get the pris fix 3 course dinner for $40.00 per person at PSI Zagat rated restaurant. Would stay here again in a heartbeat. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Very nice Inn and WONDERFUL staff!"
Everything was very well done.... breakfast that was yummy, on a porch overlooking the ocean. Beach time all day with chairs and towels, even a bike to take a spin. Wine and cheese @ 4:30pm. The beds were comfortable and the room was adorable. We loved the INN! They even mailed me my bathing suit that I had left behind!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Lovely oceanfront inn"
What a beautiful home overlooking the ocean. Our room was very large, oceanfront, with a very large bath & fireplace. In the hallway, wine & cheese is served every evening. This leads to a second floor balcony. Front porch is full of comfortable wicker furniture. There is also a fine-dining restaurant here, open to the public. Breakfast is included […] for guests only. What a comfortable, classy establishment. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
There are times when you are blessed with the best possible luck selecting a hotel far from home. On our net search we found a couple of larger hotels and lots of B&B's that looked interesting, but most had queen beds. Most were built over a hundred years ago when double beds were the norm. We picked this hotel because it looked interesting and had […] a king.appropriately We were blown away by the elegance of this 100 year old house. It is immaculate and furnished. There are 8 guest rooms. Ours was up the central staircase, on the third floor room facing the ocean with a small, elegantly appointed bathroom. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great place to stay just across from the beach."
We stayed two nights while we were in Cape May for birding. We ate one dinner in the restaurant and it was great. The breakfast each morning was also greatGenuine Expedia guest review
"Beach Front Beauty"
We stayed at this beautifully restored Inn on the beach and were extremely pleased with our room and the personalized service by the staff. It exceeded all our expectations. We had a king size bed and it was the most comfortable mattress I've ever slept on and the bedding was heavenly. Even the bath towels were thick and plus. The food is AMAZING, and […] the wine and cheese served in the late afternoon was a delightful bonus. We will definitely return for a longer stay next time. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I wanted an extra bed or just to add one person for 1 night. I saw that extra bed was $30 per night, but they wanted me to pay $57 per night and she was annoyed why I made a reservation via expedia. She told me not to use expedia because expedia is cheating on them.Genuine Expedia guest review
The best service and hotel we can think of ever having. The staff was friendly efficient and helpful. We were there for New Year's and It was decorated beautifully with balloons and banners. Coffee and snacks were free. And brunch the next day which was superb was also complementary consisted of a sitdown menu and help yourself fresh seafood bar. Far […] more than we expected highly recommended. One final note was the price was so low I felt like I owed them money. RD & LP Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
My husband and I cannot say enough about how wonderful the service is at this hotel. We can't wait to come back. Free wine and cheese in the afternoon, byob restaurant, exceptional breakfast and exceptional staff!!!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Small town, so everything is close"
It was my wife's 75 birthday. The inn was perfect. Beautiful setting. We saw snow on the beach. Each room had independent heating and a fire place. An amazingly comfortable bed and nice bath. We will now go again and again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"PSI is a classy gem"
We had a fantastic stay at the PSI. Everything was just as it is pictured on the website. The bed was really high and super comfortable. I couldn't believe how spotlessly clean our Room 5 was. In the early eveing, I went to the second floor sitting area and peacefully read 3 newspapers, while the pianist played for the dinner guests a floor below. What […] a talented man! Diner service was prtetty quiet, so it didn't disturb us at all. In the morning, Bridgit made us a lovely breakfast, which was included in our room rate. The bikes were just outside the side door and we were free to use them all day. I just loved the way we were treated. I almost thought I was in Europe but everyone was American. There is an elegant but not haughty feel about the place. Classy but not exclusive. We booked our next stay as we were leaving. I returned home feeling like I did something really nice for myself. If you go, please be as considerate of others as our fellow travelers were, and remember to leave the Inn as nice as you found it so others may enjoy it. And remember to tip the staff. Carpe Diem. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Lovely inn with an ocean view, warm and welcoming"
The staff are friendly and accommodating. The lovely parlor has loveseats and two fireside chairs. After touring Cape May on a chilly November day, sitting by the fire and talking with other guests was delightful. The second floor common area has comfy furnishings and a view of the beach. The front porch is delightful for lounging on warmer days. We […] were so pleased with our stay! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Our Anniversary at the Peter Shields Inn"
We chose the Peter Shields Inn as the spot to celebrate our twentieth wedding anniversary. From our arrival throughout our departure, everything was wonderful. Our room was upgraded upon check-in as the Inn was not full for the evening. The location was wonderful-quiet and secluded, yet close to everything we needed. We had wine and cheese at 4:30pm […] and got a chance to talk to interesting people. Following this, we enjoyed a "Prix-Frix" (price-fix) three-course dinner that was absolutely fabulous. The staff, from the owner who greeted us through the restaurants staff, to the hostess (Bridget) who brought us our delicious omelettes and literally walked us to the door when we were leaving were "above-and-beyond". The room was sparkling clean and lavishly decorated. The attention to detail was obvious in each part of our stay. This was our first stay but definitely will not be our last. I highly recommend the Inn and the restaurant to anyone looking for a perfect place to celebrate. We cannot wait to go back again! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Very nice hotel, pleasant, informative staff"
Very relaxing, nice, quiet location very close to the beach......beautiful scenery. The hotel staff was very informative and accommodating and never hesitated to answer questions and/or provide advice; etc.Genuine Expedia guest review
Loved it! Absolutely perfect for what we were looking for. Quiet, clean, good price, Great location!! Great breakfast! Great staff. Will go back!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The people working there were very friendly. The breakfast was wonderful.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
As usual it was fabulous. we were married here 2 yrs. ago and come back every year for our anniversary. it is just perfect. cape may and peter shields go hand and hand. Food is Number one. We appreciate fresh food made with locally grown ingredients. This is a classy place with a bit of old , a bit of new. You wont be disappointedGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Beautiful, Peaceful place to stay."
All the staff member were fantastic. Very helpful with all our questions. Couldn't be any nicer.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Romantic get-away to historic Cape May"
We read about "psi" in South Jersey Magazine. They had one night open and one room, so I grabbed it. We were not disappointed. Our room was charming and the bed was so comfortable; I melted into it. Dinner was a 10 out of 10, my husband and I agreed; very creative and delicious. From rolls to dessert, everything was special. We highly recommend it and […] hope to return each year. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Well Worth It!"
Only thing I didn't like was I could not get the TV to work correctly, but in all fairness we were not there for television! Peter Shields in is beautifully done in the old Cape May tradition. Attention to detail. Gourmet cuisine. Gracious staff. Well located. Perfect atmosphere. Quaint, private, relaxing and as close to the beach as you can get with […] great views of the ocean and beach. Well away from the little "hustle and bussel" that there is in Cape May. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
We spent 3 days....should have stayed longer. Hotel customer service was excellent and the food delicious. Peaceful and very enjoyable stay.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Romantic Inn on the beach"
The Peter Shields Inn was a lovely location for a short get away. The staff ensured that we had everything we could possibly need from beach chairs to towels to a glass of wine after a day of relaxing. We were able to really get away, tune out the world and come back to enjoy our room. I also recommend having dinner at the restaurant as part of your […] stay. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"not a good night's sleep"
The hotel was nice but the room was cramped, the bathroom a joke and the bed extremely uncomfortable. Add that to the restaurant on the ground floor was extremely noisy with dishes banging, loud talk, etc., I would not recommend this extremely pricey place.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We had a fantastic time at the Peter Shields Inn! I would highly recommend it to our family and friends. We want to go back next summer, and wouldn't even consider looking at another bed & breakfast!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"great place to stay"
Great place to stay but very loud when they have a DJ for a wedding. The noise lasts about 2 hours after check in. Enjoyed the relaxing piano music in the evening and the beautiful flower arrangements on the front porch.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
great view great friendly service outstanding dinning telling all our friends.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Such a lowly stay!"
My husband and I stayed on June 6, 2013 for one night. Easy check in. Room is adorable, not to old looking, of you know what I mean. Small happy hour at 530, enjoyable. The inn itself is very nice. Great service at breKfast and an easier check out. Oh and the bed is super comfy, we stayed in room 2Genuine Expedia guest review
We stayed one night to attend a wedding Memorial Day weekend. Although we weren't able to book a one-night stay directly through the inn, we were able to do so on Hotels.com. When we checked in, we asked the innkeepers to book us a cab to the wedding, which was at the other end of Cape May. The taxi was running late, so our kind host offered to drive […] us there, which was a lifesaver! We were able to make the wedding just in time! This was beyond excellent service. Our room was clean and cozy. The hospitality suite on the third floor with cold drinks and coffee available 24/7 was an appreciated bonus, as we are very early risers. Aside from having a little trouble finding two outlets to charge our phones, we have no complaints. We definitely would stay again. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
As a short mini-moon, we stayed at PSI for two nights, and the service was excellent. Room 4 had a spacious bathroom and luxurious bed! Absolutely could not have picked a better spot for our getaway after the wedding!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"The Early Mother's Day Cape May Retreat"
My daughter and I spent two nights at The Peter Shields Inn as an early Mother's Day retreat. The inn was extremely welcoming, clean and peaceful. The ocean views were beautiful and the breakfast was delicious! Wine and cheese every afternoon was an added treat! The room was exactly as I would picture a bed and breakfast, clean, crisp and decorated […] with hardwood floors, antiques and fireplace in the room! It also had the modern amenity of a jacuzzi tub in the bathroom! The only negative was that the inn needed some work, some from Hurricane Sandy, and some general maintenance. It was a little pricy, but I guess you get what you pay for! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Simply the Best"
We loved it.....we didn't want to leave. They go above and beyond to make you feel comfortable and relaxed. The rooms are decorated so wonderfully. you simply couldn't ask for a better place to stay. We purchased a gift certificate for our next visit. Don't miss an opportunity to stay here.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great way to celebrate our 60th Anniversary."
It was everything we wished for!! A lovely experience. The Kennedy's.Genuine Expedia guest review
Room 5 is very small with only once chair. Wallpaper makes it seem smaller. Nice lounge area on 2nd floor and first floor. Restaurant very expensive with limited menu. Excellent breakfast and access to beach.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great place to stay"
My husband and I took a little R & R at Peter Sheild's. We are returning guests and love the Bed and Breakfast. The rooms are immaculately clean and tidy. All employees are extremely cordial and can't do enough for you. Bridget is the best! If you need anything all you have to do is ask. The breakfast is great, cooked to order from a small menu and […] we have used the resturant as well. They have a fixed menu, which is excellent. Try the hanger steak... it's to die for. The facility is across the beach in a more quiet area, which is also very nice. My husband and I just love the place. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We stayed here the weekend of April 13 and had a wonderful visit. Room #1 was so comfortable - fireplace, ocean front, comfy bed and huge bath. We ate at the restaurant that night and the food was fantastic. The service both at the B&B and at the restaurant was wonderful - everyone was super friendly and accomodating. Our only suggestion would be to […] restrict access to the communal area outside of rooms 1 and 2 later in the evening. I am 7 months pregnant and was ready to go to bed by 11pm and there was still somewhat of a party going on outside of our room door. A bit frustrating, but could easily be addressed. We did not say anything as we did not want to create an issue, but something for the inn owners to consider moving forward. All in all, a great visit and we highly recommend. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"March weekend at Peter Shields, Cape May, NJ"
Very nice bed and breakfast, however our room was very small. The bathtub was inconvenient for us, since we are retired and had trouble getting in and out of the old fashioned bathtub. Also, there was not enough space to put our toiletries and there was only one outlet in the bathroom to plug in hairdryers, etc., and none in our room itself. No place […] to put a drink or a book on one side of the bed. The brunch was wonderful, but much too much food for us, and even though it was free, because it was so expensive to the public, our gratuity ended up being more than we would have spent on a regular breakfast and tip elsewhere. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"PEACEFUL AND RELAXING!"
WONDERFUL PLACE TO RELAX AND UNWIND. GREAT GETAWAY!Genuine Expedia guest review
Great time wonderful people afternoon wine and cheese was greatGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"A Sonderful Experience"
I absolutely adored this place. Probably the best "away from home" night's sleep I've ever had!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )