|
This call is free. 24 hours a day, 7 days a week |
||
Fairfield by Marriott Napa American Canyon - American Canyon 38.17577, -122.25401
3800 Broadway St, American Canyon, CA, 94503 United States
Need help? Our experts can call you
Guest review summary
- 4.4 Average rating: All Trip Types
- 97% Recommended
- 87 Reviews
- 4.5 Hotel Service
- 4.7 Room Comfort
- 4.7 Hotel Condition
- 4.7 Room Cleanliness
Average rating by Guest Trip Type
Select a trip type to see only those reviews
| Trip type | Number of reviews | Average rating |
|---|---|---|
| All Trip Types | (87) | 4.4 |
| Business | (10) | 4.5 |
| Romance | (15) | 4.1 |
| Family | (12) | 4.8 |
| With Friends | (16) | 4.2 |
| All Others | (34) | 4.5 |
Why book with us?
- Hotels.com doesn't charge cancellation fees
- We're just a phone call away: 800-2-HOTELS (800-246-8357)
Amenities
Services
- Coffee in lobby
- Complimentary breakfast
- Complimentary newspapers in lobby
- Fitness facilities
- Laundry facilities
- Parking (free)
- Safe-deposit box - front desk
- Spa tub
Business & Event
- 24-hour front desk
- Audio-visual equipment
- Business center
- Conference room(s)
- Dry cleaning/laundry service
- Meeting rooms (small groups)
Accessibility Features
This hotel does not offer any accessibility features. Please select a different hotel if you are interested in booking a room with accessibility features.
Rooms (all rooms include)
- Air conditioning
- Cable/satellite television channels
- Cable television service
- Climate control
- Clock radio
- Coffee/tea maker
- Complimentary toiletries
- Complimentary weekday newspaper
- Cribs (infant beds) available
- Electronic/magnetic keys
- Free local calls
- Hair dryer
- High-speed Internet access
- Housekeeping (daily)
- Internet access (complimentary)
- Iron/ironing board
- Microwave
- Refrigerator
- Rollaway beds
- Satellite television service
- Separate sitting area
- Shower/tub combination
- Sofa bed
- Voice mail
- Wake-up calls
- Window opens
General
- Air-conditioned public areas;
- Elevator/lift;
- Fireplace in lobby;
- Number of floors: 3;
- Number of rooms: 80;
- Patio;
- Swimming pool - outdoor;
- Wireless (high-speed) Internet access - complimentary
| Check-in time is | 3 PM |
| Check-out time is | Noon |
| Pets not allowed |
Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on hotel policy.
Photo identification and credit card or cash deposit are required at check-in for incidental charges.
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges. Special requests cannot be guaranteed.
Know before you go
This hotel is entirely smoke-free. This hotel has a smoke-free policy.
Recreation
The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.
- Golfing nearby
- Hiking/biking trails nearby
- Horse riding/rental nearby
- Swimming on site
Guestrooms Guestrooms
Standard room two queens
Two queen beds. Separate sitting area with sofa bed. Complimentary high-speed Internet access. Telephone with voice mail and free local calls. Cable/satellite TV. Complimentary weekday newspaper. Microwave, refrigerator, and coffee/tea maker. Hair dryer and complimentary toiletries. Air conditioning. Window opens.
All rooms include All rooms include- Air conditioning
- Cable/satellite television channels
- Cable television service
- Climate control
- Clock radio
- Coffee/tea maker
- Complimentary toiletries
- Complimentary weekday newspaper
- Cribs (infant beds) available
- Electronic/magnetic keys
- Free local calls
- Hair dryer
- High-speed Internet access
- Housekeeping (daily)
- Internet access (complimentary)
- Iron/ironing board
- Microwave
- Refrigerator
- Rollaway beds
- Satellite television service
- Separate sitting area
- Shower/tub combination
- Sofa bed
- Voice mail
- Wake-up calls
- Window opens
Standard room with king bed
One king bed. Separate sitting area with sofa bed. Complimentary high-speed Internet access. Telephone with voice mail and free local calls. Cable/satellite TV. Complimentary weekday newspaper. Microwave, refrigerator, and coffee/tea maker. Hair dryer and complimentary toiletries. Air conditioning. Window opens.
All rooms include Accessibility featuresTerms & conditions
Photo identification and credit card or cash deposit are required at check-in for incidental charges.
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges. Special requests cannot be guaranteed. Prices shown exclude taxes and fees unless otherwise stated.
Area map
A short guide to American Canyon
American Canyon sits at the southern entrance to Napa Valley, between Vallejo and Napa. Vineyards on the rolling hills foretell the world-class wineries to the north. Largely residential, the city also attracts winemaking industries such as cooperages and cork producers. To the south, Vallejo has its own attractions, such as Six Flags Discovery Kingdom theme park and a foot ferry to San Francisco.
see all hotels in American CanyonNearby Activities & Points of Interest
0.5 - 1.0 mi
- Downtown American Canyon - 1200 yards
1.0 - 3.0 mi
- Six Flags Discovery Kingdom - 2.8 miles
3.0+ mi
- Napa Valley Airport (APC) - 3.0 miles
- Downtown Vallejo - 5.2 miles
- Napa Symphony - 5.8 miles
- Artesa Winery - 8.5 miles
- Downtown Napa - 8.6 miles
- Napa Opera House - 8.7 miles
- Oxbow Public Market - 8.8 miles
- Copia: The American Center for Wine, Food & the Arts - 8.9 miles
- Westwood Hills Park - 9.4 miles
- Novato Gnoss Field (NOT) - 17 miles
- Concord Buchanan Field (CCR) - 17 miles
- Sausalito Commodore Center Heliport (JMC) - 25 miles
- San Francisco China Basin Heliport (JCC) - 29 miles
- Oakland Convention Center Heliport (JCE) - 32 miles
- Oakland Intl. Airport (OAK) - 32 miles
- Santa Rosa Sonoma County Airport (STS) - 38 miles
- San Francisco Intl. Airport (SFO) - 39 miles
- Livermore Municipal (LVK) - 41 miles
- Sacramento Executive Airport (SAC) - 47 miles
Reviews
Filter by:
-
All (87)
- Recommended (84)
- Not recommended (3)
- <Previous
- Page 1 of 2
- Next>
"Great spot to stay outside Napa"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Nov 4, 2009
The Fairfield by Marriott Nappa American Canyon was just what we wanted in a hotel. It's close to Napa, reasonably priced accommodations & breakfast included. Our room (king w/ sofa bed) was actually spacious and the bathroomwas very adequate too. Our roomwasaway from the elevator & was quiet. Breakfast offered several options - cereal, waffles, breakfast burrito, bagels & danish. Something for everyone. The staff was pleasant and check out went smoothly. I would definitely reccommend this hotel.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great room for the money"
Reviewed by Candice of Reno on Nov 4, 2009
Very clean and comfortable. Not many restaurants in the area, so that was a little dissapointing. There was plenty of fast food, but we were looking for a sit down place and there was only one within 7-8 miles. Would stay again. Rooms were big and clean, nice layout. And the price was very reasonable.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"big room, great price, nice hotel"
Reviewed by PAULA of VALLEJO on Oct 28, 2009
We stay at this location alot. Love the customer service and the rooms. The price's are always good.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Oct 14, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"Exceptional value"
Reviewed by Ellen of Arkansas City on Oct 11, 2009
We were visiting Napa and this hotel is on the southern fringe. Staff was helpful, accomodations were far above the average for the price.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great Service"
Reviewed by Bernie of Seaside on Sep 23, 2009
They were very helpful to my wife and I in helping us map out a tour of Napa and the service was superb.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Napa Valley Hotel"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Sep 17, 2009
good, clean, comfortable hotel, recommended if visiting the Napa Valley
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 3.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"Good for the Money"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Sep 16, 2009
The room was fine. It was clean & spacious and the bathroom was better than expected given the price. The mattress was rather disappointing... medicore at best. Overall, I would do it again if I needed an inexpensive place to stay.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 3.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Sep 9, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 3.0 Room Cleanliness
"good room for the money"
Reviewed by Kathie of HVL on Sep 9, 2009
The room was very clean, bed, comfortable and expanded breakfast was very good.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"a nice and cozy place"
Reviewed by Sherman of NYC on Sep 8, 2009
I didn't expect to see a little living room, but it was nice to have it there. The view outside of our window is kind of plain, but the room itself is nice and cozy. Will definitely stay here again if I am gonna be in the area again.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Sep 7, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Sep 1, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great for the money"
Reviewed by Thomas of Santa Fe on Aug 21, 2009
Was the best value at the time!
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"excelent value"
Reviewed by Hugh of Lahaina on Aug 20, 2009
Staff very helpful. Clean and neat. Rooms very large. Breakfast much better than I expected.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Aug 19, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 3.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"great hotel"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Aug 17, 2009
the location is not great but convenient if you plan to go to Napa then to San francisco
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Marriott Napa American Canyon"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Aug 2, 2009
Clean, great complimentary breakfast easy access to freeway, 5 min from Napa
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 29, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by Kelley of Houston on Jul 29, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Reasonable value"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 29, 2009
Everything met my expectations at this hotel.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Good room for the money"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 21, 2009
Clean rooms. Good breakfast.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 16, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 8, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"Perfect for families who want to tour Napa"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 8, 2009
A great, reasonable place to stay for families touring Napa on a budget. The rooms are spacious and equipped with a sink, mini-fridge and microwave. Complimentary continental breakfast. About 20-25 minutes south of napa. Not charming, but practical.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"Fairfield American Canyon"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 7, 2009
Nice accomodations for the $'s, good location for napa and american canyon
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jul 3, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Breakfast"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 26, 2009
Continental breakfast can be improved with different variety every day.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 26, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Wonderful stay"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 25, 2009
Great hotel wonderful staff I would recomend this hotel to anyone.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Hotel Review"
Reviewed by Mark of Fremont on Jun 19, 2009
The hotel was clean, comfortable and just fine. The staff was friendly and helpful. The place was not noisy or anything of the sort. We knew it was a ways outside of napa, the only part that I might consider changing next time, due to the drive back and fourth from wineries to hotel, back to restaurant, then back to hotel, a bit much driving. The breakfast in the morning was fantastic, extensive for a "continental breakfast". Included, cereal, bagels, muffins, waffles, fruit, juice, coffee, tea, danishes and even frozen heat up breakfast sandwiches. Overall, very pleased with this hotel stay.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 3, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Okay place to stay"
Reviewed by Bill of LA on Jun 2, 2009
Positives: Room was comfortable and clean. I was able to arrange my room location before I arrived which was nice. Also I left some clothes in the closet they sent to me for a reasonable fee. Negatives: The walls are a little thin. I could hear our neighbors talking. The continental breakfast station was continuously out of orange juice and the selections were lower quality than I would expect from a division of Marriott. Small changes could make an large improvement.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 3.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 2, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 3.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Jun 2, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 4.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great value and clean environment!"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on May 27, 2009
This hotel exceeded my expectations. The room was spacious, clean and nice. Great hotel for the value which included free parking, internet access, fitness, pool and continental breakfast. Not much to do around here, but it sure made up in value and it was less than 15 minutes drive to downtown Napa.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great room for the money but not in Napa"
Reviewed by Laura of Dallas on May 23, 2009
This hotel was clean and comfortable. However the title of the hotel is misleading with Napa in it. This hotel is not in Napa with about a 15 minute drive. There isn't a place to walk from the hotel as it is located on a busy road.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great Value !!"
Reviewed by Walt of Poulsbo on May 22, 2009
What a pleasant surprise to find a nice, clean, friendly hotel at a very reasonable price in the wine country. Avoid the high rates of Napa and Sonoma and stay here in American Canyon. 3 minutes to Napa and 20 minutes to Sonoma!
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"our 1st anniversary"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on May 21, 2009
My Husband and I went up to Napa for our first anniversary. We where very happy with the service and how hospitable the employees where.We called it our home away from home. ANd for the area was extremely well priced. of course you always hope for a better price but it was much better priced than the surrounding hotels and B&B's
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Poor Service...a big disapointment"
Reviewed by Tony of Modesto on May 20, 2009
When we first arrived we were satisfied with the size and quality of the room. With exception to the dirty carpet...it made the bottom of our feet dirty...the room was pretty clean. The was overshadowed by the rude wake up we experienced the following morning. The hotel put us in the room next their conference room, which houses a church group every Sunday. We awoke to VERY LOUD music very early in the morning. The hotel was not full by any means, and we checked in relatively early. So I was frustrated that the staff had not only not mentioned the church group to us at check in, but didn't think to put us in another room, as the hotel was not booked out. The woman at the front desk was extremely cold and rude when I explained my frustration. Her "oh well" attitude was very disappointing and I expected a little more customer service. They definitely don't go above and beyond here!
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 1.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 3.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on May 16, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Nicely furnished; watch out for housekeeping!"
Reviewed by L of Eureka on May 12, 2009
The room was nicely furnished and very clean. The room was well layed out. Make sure to hang your Do Not Disturb tag as housekeeping started knocking at all of the doors at 8am on a Saturday.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 2.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on May 6, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Well placed for Napa"
Reviewed by Shane of coeur d'Alene on May 5, 2009
Good breakfast, good location for Napa and nice rustic view out the window. It is essential to have a car however as there is nothing much to walk to (semi-rural).
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on May 5, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Great value"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Apr 30, 2009
This hotel is just outside Napa/Sonoma, with the conveniences of a Marriott, yet significantly cheaper than hotels inside wine country.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 4.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Apr 23, 2009
This guest did not leave a comment.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 4.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"A nice "budget" stay"
Reviewed by Magnus of San Jose on Apr 22, 2009
Even though this hotel might not be the best bargain found in the area, it's a really nice one. Fairfield offers breakfast, wireless internet, pool, and a gym included. As always with these hotels the pool isn't the fanciest one, the gym is not the biggest one and the breakfast is certainly limited, but they still offer all of these. I got a room upgrade, so the room was really nice. However, the surroundings, a highway and a railroad aren't that exiciting. Really close and convenient to Napa too, so if you're doing a Napa trip but want to dodge the Napa prices, this might be the hotel for you. Friendly staff and clean rooms.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 4.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Good value"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Apr 17, 2009
Excellent room, excellent value, nice facilities. Breakfast was pretty limited. Would have appreciated yogurt, eggs or something besides cereal, waffles, etc.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
"Good room for the money"
Reviewed by a Hotels.com guest on Apr 16, 2009
New, quit and clean with typical Marriott constancy.
Overall Rating
out of value="5"- 5.0 Hotel Service
- 5.0 Hotel Condition
- 5.0 Room Comfort
- 5.0 Room Cleanliness
- <Previous
- Page 1 of 2
- Next>
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com's position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews