Needs renovation, our room, was spacious and ok, but the furniture and the tv were very old. Good thing, the room had a kitchenette, which may be useful for you. I would like a little bit more, for the price I paid. Who cares it is at the last of the Keys.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Perfect getaway for my anniversary..."
I took my wife to this hotel for our anniversary and she loved it. She loved everything about it...the canopy bed, the pool area, and the waterfront sitting area. Even though we stayed only one night, we really enjoyed our stay. On a special occasions like an anniversary it is really relaxing when everything goes just right! Thank you..Genuine Expedia guest review
very nice stay , road construction is a hassle, room were clean and very nice but datedGenuine Expedia guest review
"quiet, but under construction"
north roosevelt was under construction 10/2013. blocking the entrance, making it difficult to navigate once u leave the hotel. pool was closed and so was the hot tub. gorgeous property otherwise. quiet and peaceful except when housekeeping comes by. its like they are carring on and yelling to each other from room to room. way too early (9 a.m.) for […] that behavior.....hotel staff closes at 10p.m. front desk doesnt answer the phone. i didnt feel safe. put the property does have nite security walking around, or shall i say learking!...booked thru expedia and no mention of any of these concerns.... Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Compared to other prices I got a good rate and I was compfi!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Coffee in the morning on the bay"
Arrival was a disaster as road work was being performed right in front of hotel. Getting in the parking lot was a fiasco. I have no idea what happened to the lady in the Vette that was behind me. No way she was getting in. Giant storm seemed to be brewing so we were afraid to go into town the arrival night fearing we would not be able to get back into […] the parking lot if it rained. I thought I had made a huge mistake on this choice. The next morning changed everything for us. Got my coffee and sauntered over to one of the rocking chairs located right on the edge of the bay. Just a serene view. Extremely quiet even though construction still going on out front. Nice pool and room was very clean. Close to downtown but still need to drive. For the price and the quiet, I would definitely choose this hotel again. Once road construction is over it will be easy to enter as it is right on the main road coming into Key West. I will miss my morning coffee on the bay for sure. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
This resort was much better then I thought it would be. It didn't look like much driving past it. But the marina was beautiful. The dolphin safari was great as well.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Decent price but could've been better"
We liked but DIDNT love our stay here. A bit of false advertisement, it said complimentary wifi, however, when we checked in, the only wifi available was in the lobby. The road construction going on also made it difficult getting back to our room.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Relaxing off the beat and path of Duval St."
Last minute reservations for hubby's birthday. Great deal!Genuine Expedia guest review
"This is a romantic hotel"
The hotel is nice and clean. The bed is comfortable and stylish! The lobby is a little far from where we actually stay. I will come back again if I ever travel to Keywest. It worth a 4 star.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Very nice location near ocean"
The place was pleasant, the staff was nice and helpful.Genuine Expedia guest review
"room/staff very welcoming nice pool & tented bed"
Very enjoyable Key West quick trip the resort is clothing optional and we did not know this prior to going down to the pool. Luckily no one went nude or topless :) we had a normal time with nice people!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Spacious and luxury comes under less price!"
Hotel was pretty nice with the price compare to other hotels nearby, all amenities in place! Room is good with some feeling of luxury! But far from Duval street..Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great room except for road construction"
Beautiful room and bed - road construction was badGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice Hotel, pool, spa, beach > road construction"
Pool, Spa, Beach, room very clean, private and quite. comfortable , nice continental breakfast . down side = Ceiling fan broken off blade , safe did not work , 1980's cable / road construction, very poor access , Tiki Bar with no bar. Only a Soda Machine! Nothing but one fast food hamburger place or BBQ & beer only within walking distance, (.25 mile).nothing […] else within (.50 mile) on a road with Heavy Traffic, room service skipped a day on our stay . Like going to an Island. Very nice but if do not bring it with you ? You will not find it there. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Hotel really needs updating.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice older hotel"
We loved the hotel, a little weary at the first drive up, but it turned out to be really nice. It is an older hotel and not terribly close to all the action (but hey its a tiny island). There was a lot of construction on the road right out front and the pictures online need to be updated badly. There is no tiki bar but it is a nice area to sit by the […] bay, quiet and does not face the roads at all! We loved the canopy bed and the room was very clean. Took a cab to Duval street and it was about $10. I highly recommend not driving a car in Key West, rent a bike, plenty of bike paths everywhere and right outside the hotel. Loved being in the clean pool and loved the adults only, very relaxing vacation! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Quaint hotel by the beach"
Love the canapy bed. Room was spacious. Enjoyed the jacuzzi at night. 2 thumbs up from me :)Genuine Expedia guest review
It was a perfect getaway the staff was very friendly and we loved the room very romantic with the sheer drapes over the canopy bedGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Beautiful waterfront setting"
The Banana Bay Resort is a little known spot off of Roosevelt. Looking at the front of the establishment, you would never know the paradise that lies behind it. Staff was cordial and accommodating. The pool was awesome and the property, which overlooks the Gulf was beautiful. We've stayed in a lot of hotels in KW over the years. Not any more. This has […] quickly became our favorite "go to." Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We chose this motel due to it's location and the marina for the boat. The proximity of the room to the boat was critical. The room was dated but functional. The sofa bed was good to sit on, but the 4" mattress was not (the frame was all to close to my body for comfort).Genuine Expedia guest review
After the third night your mattress is uncomfortable. Needs new mattresses.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Not a bad hotel for the price. I would stay again, but saw much better options while out and about on the island.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Liked banana bay resort"
The room was very clean and large. It was great to be able to take our dogs out and about on the grounds. We were able to leave them unattended in the room when we went out which was a great selling feature for us. The staff were very nice. We will definitely stay there again and recommend the resort to our friendsGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Friendly staff just a few minutes from Duval Str"
The staff was very pleasant and it was well located. Anything you want is only minutes away. They also have a partnership with a rental company for great deals on mopeds.Genuine Expedia guest review
we loved that there is no one under 16 allowed at this hotel. It was a quick taxi ride to Mallory square and duval st. The staff was nice and friendly. The room was clean but it did have a weird smell. We used the kitchette and then went to the pool, when we got back all the dishes were washed!! loved that!Genuine Expedia guest review
Clean rooms, great staff. Very quiet. A little road construction goin on but experience was just fineGenuine Expedia guest review
"Loved this hotel"
Have been coming to the Keys yearly since 1999-we typically stay at a different place each time. We are planning on going to the is hotel from now on. The pool area is beautiful, tropical foliage. This is an older hotel and could benefit from an update but the atmosphere was so great that it made up for this. Pool was immaculate as was our room (not […] even one bug!) and the king bed sheets were CHANGED daily, not just made up. Continental breakfast fine, just basic waffles, bagels coffee (fruit was just apples). Staff was fine, out of site and mind just the way I like it! Pool was cleaned each morning. Great seating on the Bay. It is not a swimming beach from there but some people did snorkel directly from the hotel and saw some good sized fish. Best part is location (they currently have road construction on the main road in front of hotel so this could be pain if you are driving). If you are on bicycle (can rent from this hotel) you are in the middle of the island and can easily go either direction to either take the coastline around the island or head directly downtown. Also easy pedal to Stock Island to head to the the Hog Bar for best hogfish tacos ever. Plan of splitting my time next time between this hotel and their sister hotel in Marathan. Car rental kittycorner from hotel in Key West also. We actually walked to the airport pulling our luggage when we left. I would request an upstairs room overlooking the pool area-can see the Bay too. No kids under 16. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great pool and water front area"
Room was very dated, AC did not work at all and squealed all nightGenuine Expedia guest review
"Very enjoyable would reccomend"
Because of road works entry is difficult at present. Staff were all very friendly. We stayed on Marina and loved it. All facilities were goodGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Romantic and quiet setting"
My wife and I spent our honeymoon in Key West and stayed at the Banana Bay. We loved it from the moment we opened our room door and saw the beautiful room with the king size canopy bed and the view from our private balcony that faced the pool with its lush landscape and palm trees. Behind the pool is a nice private beach with secluded corners for lovers […] and a nice view. We were somewhat disappointed that the tiki bar by the pool was closed and that they had no hammocks on the private beach. Also no wifi in the room and had to lug my laptop to the lobby to get Internet. Otherwise the hotel was perfect. There was some topless swimming at the pool, as it bid an adults only resort and that was cool. I recommend this hotel for couples wishing to spend a romantic time. The bars and restaurants are a short drive away and there are plenty of water sports all around. So go and have a blast. We sure did! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Budget hotel in Key West.."
This is about 1.2 miles from Duval street.. so thats a negative... hotel is good.. i will rate it 3.. its a resort and you have personal beach, swimming pool, sun bathing place, garden dining but i guess the facility is very old and needs a up lift.. front desk is not that co-operative.. Violet received us when we reached and she was only informative […] to what i asked.. very specific answers.. that kinda disappointed me.. Rooms are big and clean.. but again, looks old.. so kinda dull feeling.. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
It's okay. Nothing to write home about. Just a place to sleep.Genuine Expedia guest review
Nice and clean hotel, close to the river, and have plenty of beach chairs next to the rive for people to relax. However, the breakfast is not really good.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Nice view of bay"
Was satisfied with the hotel, nice balcony and very quiet areaGenuine Expedia guest review
had a great week. staff was excellent.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"nice place for the price."
Nice pool area. Nice staff. Rooms were clean, they just need a bit of a facelift. Bar never opened. Construction was a little inconvenient but that is not the hotels fault. It's a nice place to stay for the price compared to most right on Key West. Short bike ride to Duval Street and great beaches.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice place to stay for a few days."
This was a nice hotel with a cute little beach area, and a nice pool. It was close to the things we wanted to see but not within walking distance. The rooms were big, a little outdated, but overall comfortable.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The room smelled very mildewy. We were looking forward to getting drinks at the tiki bar that is advertised on the website but that is gone, and according to the staff has been for a couple of years. There is no elevator so if you are on the second floor you have to drag your luggage up the stairs.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
rooms did not have WiFi. had to go to conference/ business room. The rest was very good.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This place is excellent for its price. Room was clean, bed was comfortable, breakfast was good, property in good condition. If you are frugal and don't need a 5 starhotel, this is a great place. Kitchenette with 2 burners if you want to cook (since Key West food can be out of sight). We would not hesitate to stay here again and feel like we got a really […] good deal. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"A very nice hotel not far from the city"
First we were in the city for a hotel but the prices are enormus. After that we had a look in the internet and found that nice hotel. We had a nice room with a canopy bed. The best in that hotel is that it is only for adults. Breakfast was included with coffee, waffles and sweets. We borrowed us bikes and went to the city in 10 minutes.Genuine Expedia guest review
"VERY NICE STAY C LOSE TO EVERYTHING"
WE HAD A GREAT TIME AND WILL BE STAYING HERE AGAIN.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice hotel no beach at all"
The hotel is very good. The room is clean but the beds are not confortable they are a little hard for my taste. The pool is excellent but the jacqusy basically you can't used the water is hot but very hot.Genuine Expedia guest review
"There is no Tiki Bar"
The description tells of a tiki bar and an adult only setting. Well the adults in the pool with us all commented on the disappointment we had in arriving to find no tiki bar, well there's a bar but no drinks. so if you want to go out, purchase and bring back make sure its not glass and you are out by 10 pm, cause those are the rules. Wouldn't go back […] for the regular price and now I don't think the discounted price was that great. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
enjoyableGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"You can't call this hotel"
As soon as I did the check in the front desk advice us to call a cab to move around because parking was $10 per hour at the downtown, for which provided the number. When we went to downtown we even found free parking just in front of Hemingway house and private parking was $20 , I guess the front desk just wanted to make commission with the taxi company. […] The shower had a little mold, the air condition was old and didn't cool enough. The refrigator just looking at it you think that you will never put your water in there ........ But what really get me mad is that when I call to make the reservation they lied saying there was just one room left. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Our Stay at Banana Bay Resort was wonderful, we stayed for 2 full nights and would do it again. The breakfast should have more hot foods like bacon and scrambled eggs. Clean rooms, with Tiki bar very nicely done. Very comfortable beds. Service was excellent. Need transportation to get to Duval St, which is no problem if you have your own car, heard […] by others there even a bus or other sorts of transports to center of town which were cheap. Enjoy and have fun, pool was relaxing and clean. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The only thing I didn't like was the resort didn't offer a shuttle to Duval street. There is also a lot of contruction going on. Roosevelt for now is only a one way street.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"This hotel is a perfect place for adults"
It was wonderful from begining to end. The staff was delighful and helped us get taxi information. I will be glad, and I am sure, so will they, when the highway construction is done so there is easier access to the rooms. We can't wait to go down again and stay there. The ice machine worked great and just everything about the place was wonderful.Genuine Expedia guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )