"The three rooms"
Everything was great about the hotel. The only problem we had is that the three rooms that face the front street on the second floor, and they are great during the day for sight seeing, are very noisy at night. The partying goes on till 2:30 to 3:00 am. There is nothing the hotel or police can or will do to quite it down. Hey, it's revenue! So put in […] your ear plugs and turn on the white noise machine that's by the bed. Or just go down to the bar and party with them! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"New Sheridan Old West Feeling"
The New Sheridan West was a delightfully refurbished old west hotel. Located right in the heart of Telluride, it is a great place to take in the town. The rooms and bath have been nicely updated and the staff is friendly.. Athough this isn't usually a problem, be aware that rooms aren't air conditioned. They have ceiling fans and it cools down at night […] in the mountains, but with the windows open it can be noisy since the hotel faces the main street.. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"A great place to stay in Telluride"
We stayed for three nights in a second-story outside room. The room was really nicely decorated, spacious for an old building, and quite charming. The location is perfect and in the middle of everything. We were right over the restaurant and could hear noises below on Saturday night but they make that clear in the description of the rooms. It was not […] bad and did not affect our ability to sleep. I would definitely stay at the hotel again but would not eat at their restaurant (disappointing and expensive). Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great Old Towne Feel"
The New Sheridan Hotel in Telluride sit right in the center of town and is perfect to experience the town. However, in summer be warned that the hotel has no air conditioning but does have an excellent portable swamp cooler in the closet. The swamp cooler works great but you have to remember to get some ice (ice machine on lower floor) and set it up. […] The bartender is one of the best for drinks and advise on restaurants. Restaurant Manager is a little rude to hotel guests going to the elevator (Elevator is just inside the corridor between the reservation stand and the restaurant). Front desk staff is excellent. Only issue, don't plan on getting any sleep until after 2 pm because the nightlife (even on weekdays) has yelling in the street and dj's on mics until 2 pm. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Hotel staff was exceptionally helpful.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We did enjoy the room and amenities (hot tub on the roof) a bit pricey for dinner.. We did not really understood the "concept" of having a huge mirror facing the toilet bowl .. I do not know many people who enjoy watching themselves taking a load off ( if I may say this like that) Other than that It was purrfectGenuine Hotels.com guest review
It was wonderful!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Good hotel option in Telluride"
Really well done updates in keeping with the character of the hotel. Great location and bar next door. Friendly staff. Would have liked a room with a bit more of a view - it does get noisy at night.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great historic hotel on Main Street"
We truly enjoyed our stay at the New Sheridan. There is a great bar and restaurant in the hotel and it is convenient to everything in town. I do know it can be loud on Friday and Saturday although we did not experience it. They are also kind enough to provide ear plugs if it does get loud.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Perfect Telluride Experience"
Felt like a rockstar! Amazing service, pristine and chic rooms, delicious food and drinks.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Comfortable and convenient"
Nice, historic hotel with a great location on the main street of Telluride. Easy access to shops and restaurants. About three blocks from the free gondola up the mountain. My room was large, clean, and very comfortable. The hotel provides a white noise machine to cancel out street and/or bar noise which I used every night and had no problems. The upholstery […] covering the room furniture was a little stained and could use a re-do but that is the only constructive criticism I have. The employees were very friendly and I thoroughly enjoyed my stay. I will absolutely stay here again and highly recommend the New Sheridan to others. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
GoodGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Amazing hotel amazing staffGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great room, amazing view, lots of charm."
My wife and I spent three nights here as part of our honeymoon. Was a fantastic stay. The staff was friendly and helpful. The food was good. Free coffee in the mornings in the parlor. Hot tub on the roof. Amazing views from our room. Would definitely recommend.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great hotel in walking distance of Telluride."
It was beyond our expectations. The room was decorated so beautifully and so was the bathroom. The bed and pillows were so very comfortable and it smelled of clean linens when you walked into the room. The restaurant and bar that are in the Sheraton are wonderful. The best part was the hot tubs on the roof, what a great experience. My wife and I agree […] that this is the best hotel we have stayed at in years! Bravo Sheraton! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
We needed a room last minute, and were able to get one at the New Sheridan. They had just opened for the winter season, and upgraded us to a beautiful room with an amazing view because they could (he even placed us as close to the rooftop hot tubs as possible). So awesome. The room was lovely, clean, and so much nicer than we expected for the very affordable […] price. The water in the bathroom took about ten minutes to heat up. The walls are old and thin so you can hear what's going on next door very easily, but they include a sound machine and ear plugs to deal with any sort of sound disturbance. The experience was a great, dreamy surprise! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great Stay in Telluride"
Recently refurbished hotel in downtown Telluride. The room was very clean, everything appeared new. We had a great stay. We traveled from Durango and stayed in the Strater Hotel. The rooms at the New Sheridan were HUGE in comparison. We had a great stay and would come back.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"New Sheridan Hotel"
Perfect location right in downtown Telluride. Beautiful job with recent remodel of the hotel. Rooms had a lot of amenities, bed extremely comfortable.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel This seems to be bed month! All our guests are commenting on them. Many thanks, Ray and Mike, GMs
"Autumn Mountain Drive"
Stayed one night while driving in mountains. Fall colors were great. Terrific hotel on main street, old building but updated. Took the free gondola ride over the mountain, and then came back and ate at the chop house restaurant. It snowed for the first time of the season and the next morning the surrounding mountains were snow covered. Very beautif […] ul. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Yes. The snow is coming. Many thanks for choosing us, Mike, Hotel Manager
"Charming hotel with wonderful ammenities"
The staff was laid back but excited about their community and property. Lovely dinner in the restaurant. Would definitely come back.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Yes, we are a mountain town and we are indeed "laid back" - - but we hope in all the good ways. Warm regards, Mike Hotel Manager
Main Street smells of smokers and exhaust. Get room with windows to the sideGenuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Yes, we are in the mountains with lots of younger folks who still smoke. We do have side and back rooms. Best wishes, Ray - GM
"A Great Hoel in Downtown Telluride"
I've stayed at other old, Victorian-style hotels (The General Palmer Hotel, Durango, CO and the Brown Palace, Denver, CO) and was really impressed with how nice the New Sheridan is. If anything, it's nicer than the Brown Palace. The room was very, very nice and there were no issues at all. The staff was courteous and very professional. About the only […] quibble I can come up with is the parking situation, which isn't all that great anywhere in Telluride. There isn't a dedicated parking lot for the New Sheridan (or a parking garage), so all parking is on side streets. Fortunately, the New Sheridan provided a free parking pass and I never felt that security was a problem. All in all, I highly recommend the New Sheridan although it is a bit pricey. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments. Yes, we do have parking passes and many of our guests just park and leave the car until they are ready to depart. Best wishes, Ray
"Great hotel in the most beautiful place in CO"
Hotel staff was great! Room was clean and very comfortable! Sheridan Chophouse food was excellent. Will stay here again no doubt.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments about our restaurant and hotel in Telluride's downtown. Best care, Ray - GM
"Great place to stay"
The hotel is in an ideal part of town where you can walk to restaurants, shops and bars. The service is great! Also, the rooms are fabulous.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Your comments are kind. Many thanks, Ray - GM
"THE place to stay in Telluride!"
I did not know much about the area, but I am so glad that I happened to book a room at the New Sheridan! We only stayed one night, but the room was clean and comfortable and the staff were extremely friendly. The location right on the main drag in Telluride was ideal. We had almost chosen to stay at one of the mountain village resort hotels, but I am […] so glad we didn't. The Mountain Village is something of a ghost town in the summer, and the Main Street in the town of Telluride was definitely the happening location to be for a summer stay. We also enjoyed a nice glass of good scotch at the adjoining bar one evening and really liked the atmosphere there. There's also a good cafe on the same block for breakfast and a nice little chocolate & ice cream shop around the corner. Only 2 blocks walk from the public gondola and the hotel desk clerk gave us some great advice on some good local hikes. I will definitely stay here again the next time we are in town and will definitely recommend this hotel to anyone visiting the area. Very satisfied! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments and brief tour of the area. The "happening location" is also true at other times of the year - in the "real" town. Best wishes, Ray - GM
"In the heart of Telluride"
This place is perfect. We walked in the front door and were warmly welcomed by the staff and patrons. Everyone was happy, totally relaxed and enjoying themselves around the bar and waiting area. The guy at the front desk was pproachable, hospitable and super friendly making the check in experience short and sweet. It is a beautiful hotel, restaurant […] and bar with an upscale decor and a very welcoming feel. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel I am so pleased that you sensed our "welcome" as that is what we are, in the end, all about. Travel well, Ray - GM
"Right in the middle of town"
The hotel itself was beautiful but there was not any air conditioning. We has an interior room and they told us to keep the window open and the bathroom fan on. Unfortunely or window was up against another building so very little airflow. At 8 am we heard tons of glass breaking brought it up to the hotel and they said that they has brought it up to […] the city about recycling so early. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your comments about the city recycling collection. All care, Ray - GM
Lovely room with vintage charm! Will stay again!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comment about our small hotel in Telluride. Ray Farnsworth, General Manager
"Great Find! Will come again"
Beautiful hotel. Wonderful amenities. Rooftop hot tub. Gorgeous bathrooms.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel I am so glad that you did find us! We look forward to your return and being able to extend your $s with our 20% discount on breakfast and lunch. Thanks, Ray Farnsworth, GM
"New Sheridan, new favorite"
I've stayed in Telluride several times, but this was my first stay here. Room was small, but that's to be expected for an old hotel. The room itself was beautiful, as was the rest of the hotel. This will be my go-to place from now on.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments. Your smaller room that you chose - the "Cozy" room is one of five different room types and all the others are quite large. If you felt that the Cozy was too cozy, please try a larger one when you return. Thanks, Ray - GM
"Really nice historic hotel"
Really nice, historic boutique hotel. Only drawback is the street noise from late night partiers, and they do provide a white noise machine to help with that. Restaurant was superior.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thanks for your kind comments about our downtown Telluride hotel. As we are the "hub" of the life of the locals, the spill out from the bar does get noisy at times. The Chophouse restaurant team thanks you for your "superior" comment. That is their goal (when not on the trails!). Best thank yous to you, Ray, GM
The hotel was charming and comfortable. Then entire staff were gracious and helpful to a person. Thanks!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you. I will pass on your glowing comments about our team. They will themselves "glow" that their care is recognized. Thanks, Ray, GM
"Great place to stay"
Pleasant and enjoyable.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel And "5 Stars", thank you for your care of us! Yours, Ray, GM
"Old world charm with high quality design"
My husband and I came to this hotel for our anniversary, and both is have never been so impressed. The service was friendly and sincere, not over the top and fake. The whole building was obviously designed by a highly skilled interior designer, and our room took my breath away. We got the 2nd floor with a view, and we couldn't of been happier. Perfect […] place for romantic getaway, we are DEFINATELY coming here again, except for a longer amount of time. :) Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel You are kind. Yes, our designer for our renovations and continuing updates is Nina Campbell from the UK. She specializes in British country mansions. We are grateful that she could take our project on. We look forward to your return to Telluride. Best wishes, Ray, GM
"Jewel of Telluride"
We have stayed at the New Sheridan many times and we are never disappointed. The rooms are spacious and clean. The restaurant is one of the best in Telluride.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Dear Pat and Darryl, Greetings. Thanks for taking the time to post your kind comments. Wee all look forward to having you stay with us for many more trips. As you well know we are family here. Best to you, Ray, GM
"Excellent for ski vacation"
The most helpful staff I have seen in a long time!Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thanks for your kind comment. I will pass it on to the staff.
We had an awesome time in Telluride and staying at the New Sheridan Hotel was just perfect!! The staff, especially Karl, was professional, courteous and kind, very down to earth, made us feel right at home, just really awesome people! Would absolutely recommend this hotel, the room was spotless, we stayed in the 2nd floor facing the courthouse, the […] hot tub awesome and definitely needed after a day on the mountain! You could hear some street noise but it didn't continue very late and never interfered with our sleep. Ear plugs and a white noise machine are provided for you just in case. We had dinner at the hotel one night and breakfast also, the food and service were excellent! A little pricey but it is a ski/tourist town afterall and prices were comparable to other restaurants in town. Would absolutely recommend this hotel! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thanks for your kind reflections on your stay at our small Telluride hotel in the downtown on main street. I will pass on your comments to Karl and the team. You know that they will appreciate it.
"Best place to stay in downtown Telluride"
Great location, outstanding service, divine rooms!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments about our small Telluride hotel.and its service and design.
Everything was great, only issue was heater in room made loud noises. They do provide a sleep machine and earplugs.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind endorsement. I am perplexed by the heat sound as we have hot water radiators with individual controls,
Very spacious, comfortable room. The staff is friendly and helpful. The restaurant is superb. I will be staying there next time I am in Telluride.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind words about our Telluride hotel and restaurants. We look forward ti seeing you again. We are all likely to still be here,
"Nice hotel, great location"
Room was a little noisy but great location for the priceGenuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your comment about the location and the price. We are the social hub of Telluride - in our bars and restaurants - and we do have some noise issues while the town celebrates.
Great stay. Great Value, really nice roms, and a terrific breakfast. I would stay here again for sure.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your kind comments about the rooms and your breakfast in the Parlor.
In the heart of Telluride, in the middle restaurants and shopping, this quaint hotel has it all.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thanks for your kind comments.
"Hotel needs shuttle service or parking"
Nice place no a/c--no parking unless on the streetGenuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you fro your comment. The town is exceptionally small. As you might have experienced, it is a 3 block walk to the trails, 2 blocks to the ski gondola. We have not previously seen the need for a shuttle, preferring to keep such an added cost off of our guest room rates. And as parking on the street is typically just half a block away and at no cost, we have heretofore felt this to be a cost effective solution for our guests. I will bring your points up at our next meeting.
"Nice place to clean up."
Very nice large quiet room with comfortable bed. Bathroom was large and had nice shower and heated floor.Genuine Expedia guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your valued comments about your hotel stay here in Telluride, downtown.
"Great renovated historic hotel"
The hotel has been beautifully renovated. The deluxe room was spacious and very clean, with seating area and coffee table. The service was great, and a nice touch was the rooftop spas. Location is within walking distance to dining, shopping and ski lift. Although, it doesn't have a.c. in summer, it does cool down at night, even on hot days .Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for taking the time to post your feedback. We appreciate the kind comments about our renovation, guestrooms, service and location. We look forward to welcoming you back to the historic New Sheridan.
We loved the hotel with the exception of the very loud dumping of the liquor bottles day and night. We did love the hotel and it's history. The room was large and lovely and clean. We were not able to get onto wifi there. It was convenient to shopping and town.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for providing valuable feedback on your stay. We're happy to hear you enjoyed your room, our history, and location. The latter is one of our greatest assets, but we are challenged with occasional noise issues. We do have interior rooms that are very quiet, and if you call us directly we will help to make arrangements for a future visit in a quieter room at a discount. I also wanted to apologize for the wi-fi. We had intermittent access during your stay, but the issue has been resolved. We look forward to welcoming you back to the historic New Sheridan.
Everything was fine except the wireless connection that does not work.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel We want to thank you for your feedback and apologize for any inconvenience. There have been many power outages recently that have caused trouble with our networks. The issue is resolved now. Sorry again for the intermittent wireless access. We look forward to welcoming you back to the historic New Sheridan.
"best spot in Telluride"
great spot but be prepared for noiseGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great place to stay in Telluride"
We unfortunately had only one night in Telluride as a quick side-trip on our way home from family events in the midwest. We loved the atmosphere of the hotel and the great dining room. Wish we had had more time to explore, but really liked the hotel and its location in the town.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by New Sheridan Hotel Thank you for your feedback. We're happy to hear you enjoyed your stay with us. We look forward to welcoming you back so that you can explore all that Telluride has to offer.
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )