"Very good but..."
Very good my only complain the food @ the restaurant, very expensive and no good at all.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Room was updated and clean. Excellent restaurant across the street (Mamma Mia's). Close proximity to the south shore and various seafood restaurants. Only a mile from Islip airport. Easy access to the hotel from Veterans Memorial highway,Genuine Expedia guest review
hotel was very nice, clean, and an excellent place to stayGenuine Expedia guest review
"If you're looking for peace and quiet go elsewhere"
We stayed here for one night during Labor Day weekend as we were in town to attend a wedding. The hotel did appear to be in new condition, yet our bathroom already had some black grout between the tiles. Perhaps it was because the room had not yet been cleaned when we arrived after 4 pm? Hotel was PACKED with drunks already at this time, and they continued […] to wander the halls well after we were in bed. Something to be aware of- McArthur Airport is literally a few doors down from the hotel, so planes can and do take off right over the hotel at all times of the night. Having grown up in the area I was well aware of the airport noise, but unless you stay a few miles away this can be true for all of the nearby hotels. We did not eat here or have time to use the pool, but the Airport Diner right up the road is very decent. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The staff was great under unusual circumstances because of a Wedding.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Close to airport"
Very clean and good overall valueGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The hotel is well maintained, with attentive staff and nice amenities (small swimming pool, but clean--no locker room or shower is a drawback). Only complaint is that it is super air-conditioned, and it is not possible to turn off air conditioning or to raise the temperature in the room. Breakfast is less expensive than other hotels in its rating category […] but just as good as any I've paid $20 for. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Located close to the airport."
I stayed for 2 nights with my children. Beds were comfortable. Rooms and bathrooms were clean. Air conditioning worked well and easy to use. Convenient coffee maker and fridge. Breakfast was good with many choices. Fairly priced. It was located in the middle of where we needed to be however a little bit of a distance to the touristy east end of Long […] Island. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Unlike your website, the hotel didn't allow for a small bed to be placed in a wheel chair accessible room. The hotel concierge had different reasons as to why a small bed was not allowed.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
It was clean, quiet and comfortable and the room was a nice size. The staff was professional and helpful .Genuine Hotels.com guest review
clean, excelent service,,great location good amenitiesGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We just needed a day away from everyday life ..... Kids, animals but didn't want to travel far. This was right in our backyard and we felt like we was away in a whole another state. And only minutes away from home just in case we had an emergency. Room was clean services was great !! Pool was refreshing and the gym outstanding !!! Well worth the money […] !! Can't wait for our next get away !! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Be aware that they have no whirlpool tub. It's on the site but not in the hotel. More important was that everone on the staff was great.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Everything was better than expected. Only one complaint. Water pressure in shower was really low. Otherwise enjoyed my 6 night stay.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Convenient, comfortable and reasonable"
Reservation was for 4 adults & 1 child; had to take an "accessible" room to accommodate cot. Otherwise the one night stay was as expected; except the food. It was above and beyond. Had 5 different dinners. It took a bit of time as it appears there was only one cook/chef. But . . They all came out together and were very well prepared. Two of adults are […] in food service and they were impressed with quality and presentation. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"convenient for business in Suffolk County"
Overall everything was good -- I really only slept there. Nice that they offer breakfast but I wish it wasn't one price fits all -- very expensive if all you are looking for is a yogurt and a cup of coffee.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Nice large room, helpfull staff, coffee to go. Pleasant stay.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice for the price."
Stayed here after a day on Fire Island, where hotel accomodations really don't exist. Very comfortable, room, and pleasant dining area & lounge. Refreshing to have full dining in a small budget hotel. Convenient coffee station right at reception. Pool was a little lame, and the hot tub "spa" they promised on the advertising was covered over (In a semmingly […] permanent manner ). Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"far away of any attractions"
very nice clean hotel ,we really like it and would recommend it lovely country side viewGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"nice and new"
great ....loved it...will stay here again...love that you can do laundry!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
It was wonderful, can't complain of a single thing. Will be booking here in the future from now on. Staff super friendly and hotel was super clean. :). Will recommend to family and friends.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great price for the night!"
Hotel was beautiful, brand new, great lobby. WiFi is free if you are are Hilton Rewards member. Breakfast was $11.95 a person. There was a diner, McDonalds and Applebees a mile or two from hotel. Room was very nice and spacious. Indoor pool was small, good for little kids. Only real complaint was our room was next to side entry and exit door, which […] was constantly opening and closing loudly until almost 1:00 am. Would definetly stay again though. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
The rooms were not as clean as I would like. My mother found a cackroach in her room.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
I booked two rooms for my stay on vacation with my family, I will tell you that I am making this my number one place to stay when I go to long island next yr again. Rooms where spacious and super clean. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Loved it. :)Genuine Hotels.com guest review
clean comfortable rooms-- friendly staff--I would definitely stay here again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Closest Hotel near MacArthr airport"
Very nice stay, very helpful staff at front desk, especially Mike. All went out of their way to make our say pleasant. Only drawback was there were no 'close" eating establishments near by.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Hilton Garden Inn"
Friendly staff very helpfulGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Ms. Picky's opinion"
I was very pleased with our stay at the Hilton Garden Inn Islip because it was clean, new, modern facility & amenities, good location and helpful staff. My family and I will certainly stay there again.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great, Comfortable stay."
I was very pleased with my stay! I would recommend the Hilton Garden.Genuine Expedia guest review
room was clean, rate was 99.00 service was good.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Comfortable, Clean, and Definitely a Place to Revisit!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Wonderful weekend get away"
My stay was wonderful. I just wanted to get away and have a nice quite time by myself. The hotel grounds was spectacular. When I got inside I was amazed at how nice and well cleaned the waiting area was. I would and have recommended this hotel to my friends and familyGenuine Expedia guest review
I thought that the hotel was very nice. The room was very spacy and the staff was very accomodating.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice hotel, location great"
stayed at hotel for weekend wedding. Staff friendly. Clean rooms and large enough for my family of four. Would stay at this hotel again---price was right, the hotel the wedding party booked elsewhere was $20.00--$30.00 a night more.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great for 4 Years!"
First let me say that this hotel has a special place in our hearts. It was where we stayed when our daughter, who was being recruited by Dowling College for volleyball, was brought to campus for her official visit. Needless to stay, she felt Dowling was the place for her so in addition to that first stay, we have enjoyed this hotel over 14 times over […] the past 4 years, including this past weekend for graduation! The staff is awesome and always made us feel welcome. Tim in particular would go out of his way to "remember" us from our previous visit! The lobby area/restaurant is meticulously clean and the rooms are very quite and comfy. The bartenders are excellent and very friendly. There are other choices very nearby but we would not stay anywhere else. I can't say for certain if we will ever be back on Long Island but rest assured if we are, we will be staying at the Hilton Garden Islip. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The hotel was very clean and the staff was very friendly. The room was big and confortable. Very good that we had free access to a great gym a block away. I would stay at this hotel again. Very good rate.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
One of the best hotels I have ever stayed at. Would definately visit again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The hotel is very nicely kept and exceptionally clean. The staff was courteous and respectful; however when checking in the front desk personnel stated "breakfast is served from 6am to 10am" and gestured to an area next to the front desk. I understood that to mean it was complimentary breakfast (it was continental style) so I was surprised the next […] morning when my guest and I got a bill for $9.95 per person after eating breakfast. I just found the communication somewhat misleading. Other than this, the hotel was very nice. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
I thought it was great! Very helpful and had excellent service. I would reccomend this Motel very highly.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This was a pleasant stay and a good value. The fact that they keep bothering me to write a review and then want to tell me how long it must be is making this seem like a place I might avoid in the future.Genuine Expedia guest review
Rooms were tastefully furnished and very clean. Beds were comfortable, and thermostat actually worked! Hotel staff very polite, friendly, and very tuned in to any guest requests. Pool and workout facilities were immaculate. I will definitely stay there again. Had a comfortable business center for guest use 24 hours a day, and was well stocked with printers, […] paper clips, pens, paper, etc. You can't get more for your money than this. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
The hotel was better than expected. Everything was clean, the staff was phenomenal, and the room was fantastic. Definitely staying here again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice place to stay at"
I felt safe here and very comfortable. The room was clean and nice. Wonderful stay and would recommend!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice convenient hotel"
Clean,up to date. Good location.Large well maintained roomsGenuine Expedia guest review
We had a lovely time. The hotel was clean and comfortable. The breakfast was delicious. We used the pool and workout area and both were great ! The staf was very friendly and helpful.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
I really enjoyed our stay at this hotel. We needed to just get away for a little bit from our busy lives and stayed in. The room was huge and clean. They had a lot of TV channels available and room service wasn't difficult. We ordered in a couple times and it was surprising to find a microwave in our room.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We were there just for the night due to flight changes.the housekeeping woke me up early,which was unpleasant:cleaning schedules need to be adjusted.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We stayed at the hotel due to the blizzard so I could be closer to work. I am a RN at a the busiest hospital in Suffolk county. Unfortunately the blizzard was more than we expected. We attempted to get to work that night and were stuck at the first corner by the hotel in my fiance's pick up truck for an hour. Needless to say I never made it in. After […] a good samaratin pulled us out with a chain we circled back to the hotel where we found the entrance had been plowed & we couldn't get back in. I called the front desk and was told the hotel's plow would get there as soon as possible but no ETA at the time. I saw the plow and asked him to help us which he did. My fiance then had to dig out a parking place at the hotel because his spot was gone. Talk about stressed! These were not typical situations for the hotel or anyone. I have to say in spite of all the stress the staff was extremely professional and as helpful as possible. The wait staff in the restaurant were very pleasant and accomadating. We were very pleased all considering and would recommend this hotel to travelers and return ourselves. Thank you for providing a wonderful shelter from the storm. My only suggestion is the menu at the restaurant for dinner needs more choices. Thanks again. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I enjoyed my stay immensely and the price was affordable as well. I was surprised to find a refrigerator and a microwave at my disposal to use. I would just ask that you check the air system I'm not sure it is being filtered properly it triggered my allergies.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Response by Hilton Garden Inn Islip I am very happy to read the comments about your recent stay and glad that you found the location and amenities of our hotel to your satisfaction. Our maintenance staff works diligently to keep our HVAC units in excellent condition and we are sorry to hear you didn't experience that. I will make sure this issues is looked at. Thank you for your business and hope to see you return soon....safe travels.
We were in town for a funeral so were in room only to sleep. The room was large and bedding was comfortable.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )