"Decent hotel if you are looking for a party"
We stayed at PCI and expected a nice relaxing place is the keys. The location was amazing, but the hotel was overpriced (over $300 a night with all the taxes!) for the quality of the rooms and environment. We will be staying somewhere else with a more local keys vibe next time.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Big difference from 20 years ago"
Very family friendly. Had a great time with my 5 year old son and wife. Met other families there enjoying what I used to know as a big teenage watering hole.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This hotel is very nice and has all amenities you need to enjoy a family vacation. Two things did bother me, was the acumulation of sea weed on the beach but cant blame the hotel for that. Yhey did tried to clean up every day unfortunatelly the two days we were there it was hard to enjoy the water but the pool was great. Second item I think its the […] price, too high. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Great place to stay! Great views and four bars/restaurant all in walking distance from the hotel. Only bad part was they stop serving food at 10pm so if your looking for a late night snack you have to go out to find it.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great stay here"
The hotel is in the perfect location, fun activities there, awesome tiki bars, and lots of restaurants nearby.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Fun little getaway. Not the best rooms I've ever stayed in but they're fine for the price. We had fun with all the activities offered. We had a great time!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The hotel has a great location, beautiful views and makes it easy to not have to leave with the restaurants and bar on the property. The room on the otherhand needs alot of work. It smelled, the bathrooms were rusted and cracking everywhere. The shower curtain had stains on it, the bed was VERY hard and the AC didnt exactly work. The staff at the front […] desk was very polite. I honestly wouldnt go back, plenty of hotels near by for maybe $20 more the night. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We arrived a day early, the first room we got was room #430 with a queen bed it was old and in dire need of updating, the shower leaked so bad and that is what your heard all night. the room was very small and the air conditioner either did not work or was so loud and blowing on us while we slept. The second night we stayed in a two queen bed room #535, […] so much better, this was facing the marina, we loved this one, The pool was fabulous and the grounds to this hotel was excellent. Loved the bars at this hotel, they made the best tropical drinks which were so refreshing on those hot days by the pool. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Room # 329"
bathroom in poor condition, broken curtains, bad smell in the hallwaysGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Everything you need in one spot"
The Postcard Inn was perfect for our group because we didn't have to leave the resort. The only thing the place doesn't have is a spa, but they have everything else you need for a great vacation like two restaurants, two bars, a marina, dock store, and access to jet ski, paddle board, kayak rentals, etc. all on site. The hotel location was great, staff […] was super friendly, the room was clean but the sofa/chair could use a steam clean. The bedroom windows needed some maintenance because even though we were at the opposite end of the main building from the Tiki Bar, it sounded like they were in bed with us. I will never forget that chick singing "Hit Me With Your Best Shot" with the pillow over my head. Note: Pets allowed in certain rooms up to 45lbs limit $50 per room per stay. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We got an ocean front room in the tower on thr fourth floor. Newly remodeled with a great view. Lot going on during the day and a band that played till 11 or so that night. I had read some negative reviews and just worked with the front desk staff to ensure we got a good room. I suggest you do the same.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Don't overpay for low a quality hotel"
I stayed only one night at this resort and I'm happy I didn't stay longer. Even the hotel went under renovation 2 years ago, it looks old and cheap. Bathroom is the deal breaker: rusty parts by the door, painting peeling off, bad calking all around the tube and sink area and the door just don't close. Plus you must pay for the internet. Good feature: […] the staff is friendly. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great Job on new remodel ."
I have been staying at this hotel for over 25 years when it was Holiday Isles and I was impressed with the new rooms and the complete makeover . I did have one small problem with room I was given but the working manager Joe quickly took care of that and my mother in law and my mother had a great time for mother day. I did not have to leave the hotels […] grounds at all as the hotel has good food and there is a Shulas's 2 restaurant on the property. I would recommend this hotel to anyone and again the Manager Joe went above and beyond and made the difference . Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
It was a great experience and will definitely be visiting again in the future.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
overall was a great stay. pricing at some of the places for drinks are high but overall good.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"wish we could of stayed longer"
majority of the rooms are updated now. The bathroom tub could use some work but not a really big deal. I definitely want to go back and enjoy a longer stay. Hated to leave and staff was so nice and made me feel welcomed.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
While the hotel itself is beautiful, as well as the beach area, I was less than satisfied with the quality of service. I had to call two times before I finally received towels and washcloths, and then still only received one washcloth. I would also have expected more than one small bar of soap in my room, and a somewhat larger coffee maker. The add […] for the hotel led me to believe that it was more of a serene atmosphere rather than a party beach. Which is fine if that's what you're looking for, but I would have rather not had to listen to the band that was playing late on a Thursday evening. With the price that I had to pay for the room, amenities such as snorkeling equipment, kayaks, etc. should be available for no extra charge. The Postcard Inn is a beautiful hotel as far as appearance, but I won't stay again. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Dirty bathrooms and lack of customer service"
We've stayed here before but this is our last time at this hotel. The rooms have been nicely updated but the bathrooms still have doors that are rotting on the bottom, tubs that are chipped, vent fans that don't work ect. That wouldn't be so bad if the bathrooms were actually clean. It was obvious that the bathroom and tub had not been fully cleaned. […] After a long day in the keys we were disappointed to find it so dirty. We called down to the front office and they stated they had a full house but would make a note of it and move us in the morning. In the morning, of course they knew nothing about it and did not have another room for us to move into. So we went about our day assuming we'd move later. We got a call from reception stating that our new room was ready but we had to move into it now. We were 20 mins away from the hotel. The woman stated that if we couldn't move now, then they could move our stuff for us or not move us at all......that is just terrible customer service. They moved us into a bigger room, which still had a bathroom floor that was dirty and had little black curly hairs all over. I cleaned the floor and toilet before my husband saw and decided we wouldn't return. They charge WAY too much to have dirty bathrooms. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Promised a second floor room or higher with an email, got a first floor room with parking lot view. Safe didn't work, patio door didn't lock. Sheila's 2 was terrific.Genuine Expedia guest review
"great view of the ocean from our room"
The check in was very easy, the room and the bathroom were very clean restaurant was on site, great to sit on the deck an have dinner/etc right on the water boat rentals were on site as well, very convenient for us to explore and snorkel by boatGenuine Expedia guest review
"Nice outdoor activities, but the hotel rooms??"
Overall, the outside grounds were great and the view was breath taking. The Tiki-bar and Rum Runners bar were great open air bars to relax at. My biggest concern about the place, which would prevent me from returning, is the condition of the bathrooms. The place was opened in 1954 and I think they were remodeled maybe once since than. Tub had paint […] flaking off of it. The tile was dirty. No exhaust fan. Not even a hook on the door to hang your clothes while you changed, so they did not touch the ground. For the price of the hotel, they could afford to do some remodeling of the rooms. Unless, I received a promotional email from the hotel telling me that the rooms and bathrooms were remodeled, I will not stay there again. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
First off the prices for this hotel are off the wall high! So we found better one next door to it called pelican cove & marina resort, highly recommend that one. There very similar just pelican one is better. We had called cancel the postcard inn before cancel date & still got charge a night! Which I don't understand why!? I called complain & they told […] me it wasn't there fault & not refunding me. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Felt very comfortable with the staff and amenities that were available .Genuine Expedia guest review
For those that love the ocean and aquatic life. This is it!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"The hotel was comfortable and a good location."
The hotel was comfortable and a good location. Our first room with a king size bed was an EXTREAMLLY small room. We met the Hotel Hostess (Rachel); she is a delightful person and made our stay wonderful. She quickly contacted her manager (Joe) and was moved to another room which was much larger. The only drawback to the hotel was on Thursday, Friday […] and Saturday night they have a live band which is heard in the rooms. Given that drawback the stay was great (except for the 40 and 50 year old people that act like high school teen agers). If you stay here you must contact Rachel, she is very knowledgeable on the local restaurants and shops and activities. She makes you feel as you have a friend to go to for any help you need. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great for a long weekend escape"
Ideally situated in Islamorada, close to great dining and outdoor activities. Not a 4 star facility, but the rooms are decent, clean and comfortable. The view from the hotel, towards the ocean is mesmerizing .... and for this reason alone I would definitely return. The security staff at the hotel do not look or behave professionally, however this may […] be a positive given the amount of "outsiders" we saw using the hotel facilities such as the pool and beach. Shula's 2 is a great dining experience (on-site). Bitton Bistro, not too far by car on Islamorada is a must for breakfast, lunch, early dinner .... or simply coffee and pastries. Theater of the Sea is next door (walking distance), Robbie's Marina a 10 minute drive, fishing charters for offshore or backwater are on-site. Also on-site are jetski and boat rentals. All in all, it was a great fun vacation at the Postcard. Looking forward to our next visit. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Perfect place to stay and relax."
Nice beach and great eats. Very nice staff at Hotel, bars and restaurant. Can't wait to go back!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Not My Taste"
The scenery is beautiful but the resort is lacking. No major upgrades since the new owners took over. The pool is okay and the beaches need to be cleaned.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great vacation escape"
It's a great place to get away and relax! I'm very satisfied with it.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Don't waste your time or money!!"
Not a very nice resort, not well maintained. Rooms are not cozy and not very clean. Bathroom tiles were cracked and stained and gross. We were in building 400. Pool isn't heated. Totally not worth what they charge for a night. Very disappointed!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Details in the bathroom they need to fixGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice property. Nice room except for bathroom."
After reading other reviews, I knew what to expect. Bathrooms from the 70's I guess. Gross. The balcony had no privacy. Otherwise the room was very nicely upgraded and clean. And very comfortable bed. The staff was great. Friendly and Fast if needed. Pricey, but it is paradise.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Funky hotel that tries hard"
Nice people, decent facility, some wear and tear but overall a good location helped by the effort of the staff.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Best vacation so far!!!"
Our entire family went and had a wonderfu time. Absolutely beautiful scenery.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Bathrooms needs updating, more storage"
Our room had a nice view,of palms but many of the others in our party looked at the parking lot. The bathroom was really outdated and just a few hooks and a plug repair would have been such an improvement. We had a coffee pot, but no plug unless we moved it and used an already overwhelmed multi-plug. Don't get me wrong, beaches here great, so was the […] heated pool. They even had a bar poolside, but not on Mon. our last day. Staff was very nice, and always helpful. Still loved our vacation but it could have been better. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"A stop in the Keys"
We stayed here several years ago and the place has been upgraded significantly. The rooms wremuch nicer and seemed to be kept up better.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Nice beach area"
The beach area was great! The rooms need work, the bathtub could have cut my foot because the tub had been repainted so many times. No water one day and no hot water the next. The manager took money off of our bill, but this shouldn't happen at what is to be a great hotel. There is not an elevator I'm the 400 building I had to carry a 50 pound suitcase […] up three flights of stairs. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Nice hotel, a little too family oriented."
Went here with a group of friends in early March. Mid twenties. The hotel is very nice, room was clean and well decorated. Only problem is they're a little strict. No coolers, drinks or anything on the beach unless you buy it from their Tiki Bar. The tiki bar on site served good drinks, staff was friendly and helpful. Not as lively as we expected though. […] I do think they're focusing a little too hard on not being the old 'Holiday Isle'. Nice stay for couples though. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great location on the water"
Good pool, heated. Nice view all day long.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Comfortable hotel with beach access"
If you stay, try to get a room in buildings 1 or 2, overlooking the beach. It's on the Atlantic side of HWY 1 so you'll see the sunrise rather than the sunset. Staff very helpful. There was a mistake in my internet reservation, but Janie in reservations was very easy to work with in straightening it out.Genuine Expedia guest review
Nice time at Postcard Inn. The check in girls were not very friendly or helpful and the bartender at Rumrunner was not very friendly. Room was very clean. There was some kind of road construction so it was difficult to enter the Inn. We could not drink the water due to construction so they gave us 2 small bottles of water.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This hotel was clean. It is located right on the water. The staff is friendly and courteous. BUT, the hotel room has never been updated. The bathtub enamel was peeling off on the tub and on the tub surround. It's very 1950. Very overpriced for what is offered, but I guess you're paying for the water. Will not stay here again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Room was dark, dingy. As dark as it was, there were some lights but the bulbs were burn't out in 1/2 of them. The outside of the room was littered in trash! Very disgusting. 3 steps going up into the room with handrails. One of the handrails was broken and not attached to the cement! Entry door was filthy dirty inside and out. We will not be staying […] here again. This is the 2nd time we have given it a "whirl" since it became the Postcard Inn. Good Bye! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Beautiful setting, right on the beach. Little too much noise from jet ski rentals and not a huge swimming area. Nice staff, very clean. Overall a good stay.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We booked a last minute trip to Islamaroda this week. The hotel we wanted was full so we thought we would try The Post Card. It turned out to be a great visit. The room was very comfy and the linens crisp and fresh. The front desk was very friendly but a bit slow. Check out was the same but the managers were there to greet and chat while we waited. […] Fishing boats are right next door, water sports on premises and several pools. Enjoy! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Nice hotel no complaints"
My family and I loved it! Would definitely go back.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Staff, Beach, Grill - great. Rooms, not so."
Everyone at the PostCard was pleasant and helpful. Beach was large and very well kept. Their Beach Bar/Grille was nice with good food, as was Schula 2 (their restaurant). But the rooms were poorly done, Very old, Furnished poorly, and poor lighting in the Bathroom and closet. We were in the building #4 - away from the beach (read economical rooms). […] Perhaps the buildings on the beach (#1 and #2) might be better, but I didn't get to check that out. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
New remodel a year or so ago. Trying to be hip. Nice ambience. Comfortable bed. No breakfast included. Small bathroom, not much clothes storage in bedroom. Great views and beach area. Wonderful restaurants close by. We would come again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great resort! More than just a hotel"
The food was overpriced and not great but available at convenient times. The warm pool with a view of the ocean, the fire pits, lovely beachfront were all a great surprise. Definitely caters to families so is not quiet, if that's what you're looking for.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Vacation in Paradise"
An amazing place to stay while in the Florida Keys.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )