"Great location. Beautiful views!"
I'm so happy I chose the Harborview for our stay instead of the other hotel I was considering in Vineyard Haven! Edgartown is beautiful and the Harborview with it's inviting front porch, beautiful foyer and lobby area, bar and windowed restaurant are lovely. I booked late and was not able to book an ocean view room but I would recommend it if you can. […] Ours was in the back of the main hotel and was updated and nicely decorated. The only negative was that our bath mat was wet and the carpets in the hallways and stairs need updating.. They're quite stained. That aside it's a lovely hotel and I would definitely stay there again. Oh, the staff was great too! Friendly and helpful. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"BEST HOTEL ON MARTHA'S VINEYARD!"
THIS HOTEL WAS SIMPLY MARVELOUS. BEAUTIFUL, ELEGANT AND EXCELLENT SERVICE!!!!! WE WILL BE GOING BACK......IT WAS WORTH EVERY PENNY!!! NICE POOL AREA AND GREAT RESTAURANTS TOO! SITUATED ACROSS FROM THE HARBOR WHERE SOME OF THE MOVIE "JAWS" WAS FILMED! FREE STARBUCKS COFFEE EVERY MORNING!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Good hotel nothing spectacular"
A nice hotel with good views. More families there than expected and good restaurants and food in hotel and the surrounding area.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"The staff was excellent. Rooms were nice."
Great time at the hotel- no problems. The outdoors were well manicured and even the outside laborers were all very friendly and courteous. I couldn't have asked for more. I am very thankful to all of you.Genuine Expedia guest review
Great experience. Four couples all loved the entire experience. Breakfast could have been a little less costly.Genuine Expedia guest review
The staff was wonderful, very helpful. The view from the hotel was amazing. Location was very convenient to dining and shopping. We dined at both venues in the hotel and both were excellent.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
I was only there for an evening; however, the hotel was perfect. Great location and close to town. I didn't have time to go to the beach so I am not sure how convenient that would have been.Genuine Expedia guest review
"A hotel with character and great location"
The hotel possesses great character, from its white wooden walls and dark floors, one gets the feel of being on a great ship set to sail. Its location at the far end of Edgartown across from the beach and the lighthouse, provide great views of the ocean. Sitting on the veranda facing the ocean, the sea air is brisk and intoxicating. We arrived at the […] end of May for several days, just when the weather began to get warm and the heated swimming pool was most inviting. We were impressed by the size of the rooms and its amenities. The beds were perfect. For the first nights we had a room with a wonderful view of the ocean in the main hotel building, later we moved to a cottage facing the pool which did not have a view but was very satisfactory. (The hotel has besides the main building several annexes, not all with sea views.) The staff everywhere was cheerful and helpful; but at the front desk Emma Gonzales and Donnie Ethier were exceptionally helpful. We would definitely come back to this wonderful hotel and recommend it most highly. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great location and beautiful view of lighthouse"
Was comfortable, rooms nice and clean. We had pool view but if willing to pay more can upgrade to beach andlighthouse view. The only thing was there is no hot tub/jacuzzi and the pool being outdoors was not yet open for the season. Also no air conditioning in May, was told it is not in operation till June even though the room was warm and temp outside […] was hot. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"The hotel is beautiful, grand and amazing"
It has a very luxurious New England feel. The resturant is top notch! Will stay again!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Our recent stay in Edgartown"
I think we caught the Harbor View at a bad time. When we arrived and went to our room we quickly learned upon entering the room that a serious error had been made. A young lady was lying on the bed. She apologized profusely to us as we did to her. I might add a delightful young lady who was heading home from college and was traveling with her dad. The […] front desk was called and in a while after we called again a front desk representative arrived full of apologizes and wisked us off down the hall to our new room. As the clerk began to open the door I said to him, "Stop there are people in the room" as I heard the sounds of children playing. The clerk apologized again and went back to the front desk. Soon he arrived with keys to another room and showed us down the hall explaining that they were providing us a room upgrade for the embarrassment and inconvenience. We held our breath as he opened the door and breathed a sigh of relief as we finally had our own spot. Some sparring finally convinced the front desk manager that a complimentary bottle of wine was not an inappropriate request. In truth they should have offered us dinner. The new room was a fairly spacious suite. The room was not what I would call clean. Not a case of the bathrooms being dirty or the floors not vacuumed but a case of the room needing a deep cleaning to remove mildew that was accumulating. The furniture seemed like a combination of Ikea and Goodwill. Some pieces were very tired. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
This hotel was quiet, clean, and comfortable. Our stay was the week before Memorial Day weekend so the "summer vacationers" had not arrived. Not all the stores or restaurants were open but the ones that were had terrific food and service. In our opinion, we picked the best time to visit.Genuine Expedia guest review
We stayed in one of the cottages that was completely remodeled and wonderful. Including a white picket fence. So lovely and welcoming. The only nuisance was the home being built next door to the hotel and waking up to hammering at 7:30am. Hopefully, that will be completed soon. The food at the restaurant was fabulous. We ate there both nights!Genuine Expedia guest review
Over all we had a great experience at Habor View. Very nice accommodations, clean, friendly, helpful employees. The one negative experience was at the breakfast restaurant. We were seated promptly, but then waited 15 minutes for service. After we ordered our food, it was another 30 minutes to be served. Once our meal was completed, it took another 15minutes […] to get our check...an hour of our time spent waiting. On the plus side, the food was delicious, the servers were friendly. It seemed there was a shortage of help as the restaurant was not half full. As we were leaving, a couple from a nearby table asked where the waitress was...we said it will be awhile. That is truely the only negative comment we have about the Harbor View. We hope that steps can be made to improve the service at the restaurant. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
We stayed one night for Mother's Day. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Room is very spacious and clean with balcony next to pool. Bathroom is very large. Great view of harbor and light house.There were 5 in my family traveling, and taxi charged per person which was very expensive. We had Mother's Day breakfast at Luck Hank's restaurant, and it was […] the best. We were inquiring about the bus to travel to Oak Bluff and Larsen's Fish Market, when the hotel customer service rep next to check in recommended renting a car for $59 for the day. Within 12 mins we got into a Jeep and traveled around the island for half a day, and later dropped off the vehicle at the steamboat dock for our return. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Lovely traditional hotel, nice location."
Hotel is very appealing, beautiful buildings with porches and rocking chairs facing the lighthouse and beach. Nice location with short walk to town center, shops and restaurants. Rooms are very nice and clean. My one complaint is that we were placed on the 3rd floor, rear, with NO elevator. This made our stay a little inconvenient for two seniors. But […] overall, a very nice place to stay. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
We had a good time. Good food at Henry's. Located near the beach. You can walk to town. We wool go againGenuine Expedia guest review
"Old, even though it's newly remodeled"
We came in late and got rooms on the ground level. The view was facing poolside that looked more like a work area. I do not believe the hotel was fully booked but they still placed us in a room without a view towards the sea. Not a good way of making us want to return. Hotel staff was polite enough, but the breakfast server from Moldova was very pleasant […] and made our stay a good one. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Very very nice hotel with an amazing view!!"
Loved everything about it not one bad thing to say, except its a must try!!Genuine Expedia guest review
We stayed at this hotel on April 2014. Great location and nice hotel. Proximity to light house was a bless for our 4 year old. All family enjoyed the porch. The service at restaurant was less than bearable. We waited 35 min for our toast and tea. It might be the off season but they were understaff for both breakfast (Water St Restaurant) and for Dinner […] at Henry's. Hotel is close to shopping and restaurants too. Overall we enjoyed staying at Harbor View. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Nice viewGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great spot, a few I concerns."
The view was incredible. We stayed behind the main building, but it was so easy to get to downtown. Our issues were with the sheets and comforter in our room, they were stained. Even the bathroom needed to be wiped down. Too bad because it is a beautiful hotel in a perfect spot!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Perfect day except that our room was very very hotGenuine Expedia guest review
Overall hotel was very nice. The room was very warm and it was difficult to sleep because of this. We asked for some assistance with planning a tour of the Island but the individual helping us never followed up with our request. It is a beautiful hotel and location and we would certainly stay there again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great hotel with awesome views."
My husband and I celebrated our anniversary at the Harbor View and couldn't be more pleased. Our room was everything we expected and more. Clean and nicely furnished with great view of the Edgartown Lighthouse. The fireplace in the main lobby was a wonderful place to warm up by after being out on a rather chilly day. The front porch was just as nice […] to relax and enjoy the view. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Family event; requested location"
Wonderful staff; warmly welcomed; very relaxed, but since this was slightly "off-season" we were expecting and hoping for this kind of attitude...we weren't disappointed. Nice room; WONDERFUL bathrobes! Great staff! Very pretty entry way. it would have been wonderful to have stayed for one more evening. We really hope we can come backGenuine Expedia guest review
here at low season. so not best position to give review. Clean, manicured, pleasant staff. try black berry cobblerGenuine Expedia guest review
"A New England Beauty"
Beautiful building and surrounding neighborhood. The beach in front of the hotel is a pleasure to walk on a sunny day such as what we had. Great Sunday brunch and extraordinary service.Genuine Expedia guest review
This hotel is charming. No laundry service was surprising, however, given the price.Genuine Expedia guest review
Parking here in the winter is hazardous. They sent me out into the dark with no lights to walk the equivalent of two blocks after I found a space I wasn't sure was legit. The new manager is superb but the reality is that many of their staff members have almost no experience. It's a good hotel -- but don't be caught up in any Edgartown mystique, as the […] staff is untrained. Overall, the stay was "okay". Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
My wife and I made a quick trip to Martha’s Vineyard to visit family. The hotel staff was friendly and helpful. The room was excellent. No complaints or problems. We arrived late in the evening and the woman at the front desk helped us find one of the few restaurants that were open late in January. Yes, I would stay there again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Best spot on the island very friendly employees and a great Sunday brunch not to be missed.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Very cozy, very comfortable with a lovely breakfast to start out the day.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
When we arrived after a stressful day I requested to upgrade and expected to pay more but the front desk staff informed me that she already upgraded us ( we had two room ) for free. The rooms were beautiful and large... THANKSGenuine Expedia guest review
The hotel was excellent . The Holiday festivities were nicely done and well attended.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We had been very curious about life on the Vineyard off-season, after spending a week during the summers for many years. We found an attractive rate thru Expedia, and jumped at the chance to stay at the Harbor View for a weekend. The price was what we would pay at a chain hotel on the mainland, and we found the hotel room and condition warranted that […] rate. We were not able to understand how people could rationalize the rate charged on-season. The room was on the small side, made so by the king-sized bed. The bed was quite comfortable, we must say. There was chipping paint in the bathroom, a light bulb out in the hallway, things that a Five Star Hotel wouldn't allow. The staff was pleasant, but we spent most of our time outside the hotel, enjoying the weather and the serenity of the off-season, so we didn't need to interact with them much. We had a good view of the lighthouse, and even saw a bit of a sunrise. All in all, our stay was pleasant, made so by the pleasant days and cools nights of a quiet island. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Quintessential island hotel"
Great location with beautiful views of the bays and ocean. Classic style Hotel/Inn with large character filled rooms. This is not a cookie-cutter style chain hotel. Friendly staff in both the restaurant, bar and housekeeping. An easy walk to Edgartown attractions. You even have your own private lighthouse.Genuine Expedia guest review
We loved everything about the hotel except the restaurants. the menus were very pretentious including no normal options. The service was great, the rooms were cleaned early and well. We went out of season so it might have more options for food during the summer but not now. I would definitely stay there again and recommend it.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Wonderful Fall Getaway"
Recently returned home from a wonderful stress free vacation in Marthas Vinyard, MA. Had a great stay at the Harbor View Hotel, Edger Town. Would highly recommend it to friends and family. Look forward to going again next year.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This place has a great feel to it. Beautifully decorated and the views can't be beat. Nice amenities, very attentive staff, and our bed was to die for - so comfortable. Plumbing upgrades (shower/tub) wouldn't hurt, but overall this hotel was excellent.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Beautiful place to stay"
One of the best hotel views you will find on Martha's Vineyard. Just a 7 minute walk to downtown. Good parking. The walk across the street to the lighthouse and beach during sunrises and sunsets can't be matched. Water Street restaurant served a good breakfast and I had possibly the best steak I have ever eaten there. It was worth taking our car over […] on the ferry, we were not at the mercy of the transit system. We drove everywhere which enabled us to see everything. Great Great hotel. Highly recommend. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Harbor View Hotel - wonderful"
Great hotel. We really enjoyed the view. The Resturant in the hotel was also wonderful tooGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Best Hotel in Edgartown"
Harbor View Hotel was a beautiful hotel to stay!! We would highly recommend it to anyone! We stayed in the main house in room #306! We had a king bed and a partial ocean view! The room itself was very comfortable and well appointed. Staff was extremely friendly and very helpful. Atmosphere was simple and elegant. We had only one concern and that was […] the restaurant with the beautiful view closes down off season and you have only Henry's Pub for dinner with a very limited menu. Menu is deceiving in that it has two categories Small Plates and Large Plates. My husband ordered the strip steak in the large plates and it came sliced with approximately 8 small pieces of steak much more like an appetizer than a meal. Also it was served with french fries. It was $38 and definitely was not of the quality he was expecting or the portion. Saying all this, he stated his concerns to the waitress and we feel they responded very appropriately by offering another portion which he declined. However when we received our bill they took off his meal and a glass of wine. In the end we were very pleased with how they handled the situation. However the menu is very misleading. Had breakfast the next morning in the larger restaurant with the beautiful view and it was very good. in the end, we loved this hotel and would definitely stay here again!! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
The hotel was awesome! Staff friendly and courteous and the room was very clean. Since it was the off season their was not a whole lot going on on thre other islands however, enjoyed myself dearly. Much needed escape; quiet, comfortable, nearby shops amazing, lobster and sunset on Menemsha to die for. Would recommend for an adult solitude.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Traveling the east coast"
First time ion the island. The hotel has a good location and is within walking distance to the town. Nice leisurely 10 min walk. Loved the ambiance of the area and the hotel. Sat on the front porch and read while enjoying a glass of wine and the view. Really nice. the pool was much larger than we had thought although we didn't use it since we were ther […] in October. The only word of warning I can give id book your ferry in advance.. We were stuck for many hours trying to get back because of the seasonal changes to their schedule. The port authority said no reservations required... Wait lines were unguaranteed so buy a ticket well in advance. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
We took our son, his wife and grandson there with us....we wanted to treat them but we were disappointed in the rooms. The area and setting was nice but the hall and rugs leading to the rooms and inside the rooms were stained badly needing an update. The baths looked like a child caulked around toilet and sink areas. There was lukewarm water and it […] never warmed up to hot after 20 mins. but did get a bit warmer. Only one soap for the shower and sink so you had to make sure you had it where needed. Noise from upstairs room was loud. Slider to the balcony was hard to open ....the lock was not easily understood and could have caused a problem if there was a fire.....it took us a while to firgure out how to unlock it. The fine dinning area was not open the night we were there. There were a few more things that we jotted down but I won't go on. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Excellent service. The consierge deserves special praise for her helpful suggestions and recommendations. She was "spot on". The rooms in the front hotel are the best as they have a water view. No view of the water from the other locationsGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great location but pricey!"
Our room was comfortable and spacious. Upkeep of the outside buildings is laking however. The main hotel was beautiful and has a fantastic view from the porch. Can walk to town and great restaurants from hotel. Very friendly staff.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Beautiful hotel in a beautiful town.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Elegant old style Edgartown waterfront hotel"
Enjoyed our stay in a standard king room with balcony off the outdoor pool.Hotel is large w/ wide variety of room choices.Main building has dining room and wonderful veranda overlooking lighthouse w/ rocking chairs. Breakfast in main dining room is a must...best time to appreciate the view.Genuine Expedia guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )