overall comfort was that the room and furnishings were a bit damp. The air conditioner thermostat was hidden in a closet and therefore our first day was chilly until we had to ask if there was an individual thermostat for the room. Our room was on the ground floor, and therefore had a small outside porch that opened onto a public space / walkway. We […] found our porch sliding doors unlocked two times after maid service - not cool. The hotel was notified of this dangerous security issue. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I found most of the staff was not familiar with the hotel at all. I think this speaks to the fact that they were mostly college students and new to the property. When you asked a question, such as, how late is breakfast, they'd go through a chain of people to find out. This one stands out for me. There was a mini fridge in my room....empty. I called […] the concierge for 30 minutes. No answer. Finally front desk said it was because I wasn't in the main house. Then why the fridge? Subpar service for a big price. The bartender at the pool wasn't even a bartender. Had to walk her thru the pina collada. Not worth the price. One day housekeeping didn't do my room till 4 pm. You get the idea. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I love this hotel! The decor is beautiful. The view is fantastic. The location is gorgeous on a lane with breathtaking homes and scenery. Its a short walk to all the shops and restaurants, has a beach right across the street and an outdoor heated pool. We enjoyed the pub and the restaurant is lovely too. I wasn't in love with the menu, would have liked […] to see a few "less fully" options but the room and its panoramic view was still great. I paid for a queen room and got a king room that was also pretty, serene and comfortable with a nice view. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Have stayed before and will go back again! Only complaint was the carpet needed cleaning and also Cloth chair Staff was great, location great!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great Getaway hotel"
We stayed at the Harbor View for our Honeymoon! The hotel was beautiful and the staff was very nice. However the one negative about our stay was that the walls are super thin and you can hear the people next to you. We had to call the front desk and complain about the noise. If you stay here ask for a "quiet" secluded room, don't stay near the pool […] either. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Best Hotel in Edgartown!"
Absolutely the best experience in Martha's Vineyard. We recently had our wedding there. Everyone was absolutely amazing! Will definitely be back!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Perfection in Edgartown, MA"
The Harbor View is a stunning hotel situated in the most ideal location in Edgartown. It is close enough to all of the shops and restaurants (5 mins walking) but far enough that you can escape. It sits at the top of the town overlooking the ocean with the a pristine view of the light house. The hotel staff is so helpful and kind and the hotel itself […] is beautiful. I wish I never had to leave! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Loved the location of the hotel and all of the surrrounding beauty.Genuine Expedia guest review
We had a wonderful time here! Great location, quick walk to town (10 minutes), beautiful view. Wish they didn't start the lawn mowers up first thing in the morning but otherwise it was perfect! Rooms were new and very clean, similar to a Hilton type room. Restaurant was very nice downstairs. Love the front porch looking out on the lighthouse. Can't […] wait to go again! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Very nice retreat, about a 5 min walk to downtownGenuine Hotels.com guest review
If anything, the staff is over-zealous. They took our luggage and said our room would be ready shortly. Our camera and jackets were packed and we were without those for the following 5 hours. We were promised rooms on the first floor but were given 3rd floor rooms although when I mentioned the e-mail I had received from them, the room situation was […] remedied. Grounds are beautiful and well-kept. A lovely hotel! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Nice hotel with a great view"
Great deal on Expedia. That means the room does not have a view. But you can sit on the porch in front of the hotel for the view. We also enjoyed sitting at the fire place at the reception area. The pool site building is perfect for a solar system.Genuine Expedia guest review
"beautiful location but not view from room"
did not like the view from the room and not worth the moneyGenuine Expedia guest review
"Really enjoyed staying here..."
Romantic getaway on MV, excellent location to town.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Last minute stay on the vineyard"
Charming, clean hotel, beautiful location, friendly staff.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great Marthas Vineyard experience"
Stayed there in April, wonderful experience. Great views and ambience. Staff very nice, food was excellent. Love their coffee!!Genuine Expedia guest review
Charm of inn with big hotel services. Room was too warm. Opened windows but kept awake by rain on rooftop. Will come back.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
A gorgeous view, very quite, true four star.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Excellent experience. Beautiful place with friendly professional staff. Upgraded to a room with view of lighthouse. Can't say enough. Clean and quaint!!! Best way to spend my 50th birthday. I would go back again and again!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Wonderful Place to Stay!"
The Harbor View Hotel was a wonderful place to stay! We were there in early Spring so it was quiet in the towns but there was more than enough to do. The staff at the HarborView couldn't have been more helpful and courteous! The view from the porch is fabulous and the room was lovely. We hope to go back again soon!Genuine Expedia guest review
"The Beckwith-Hoyo stay."
First stay at the Harbor View, and the hotel and staff were wonderful. Highly recommend.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Perfect spring getaway!"
This is the second time we stayed at this hotel. All the staff we encountered were extremely helpful and very courteous. Beautiful property! The location is perfect and is just a walking distance to shops and restaurants at main street. This is one of the historic hotels of America, ladies and gents. Rooms are kept clean and in order and the hotel lobby […] is warm and welcoming. You will fall in love with this place. Restaurant in the hotel is a must. Wrap around porch with rocking chairs is just perfect for relaxing and with a priceless view of the lighthouse by the bay. We are definitely looking forward to the next visit! Thanks Harbor View Hotel and Resort! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"great for a quiet get away"
The view was exceptional and the staff were very welcoming. The hotel had easy access to all local shopping, restaraunts and public transportation.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great retreat from the everyday grind"
What I loved about my stay was the helpfulness of the employees and the feeling like u were taking back in time. The hotel had all the amenitys you come to expect in a hotel, but it also had old world charm too. I recommend this hotel to everyone and will be planning another trip soon In the summer.Genuine Expedia guest review
greatGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Relaxing in winter"
Enjoyed my stay tremendously The front desk staff took care of me and even let me check in early. Room staff was very friendly and helpful as well. Only problem was the "do not disturb" signs were not honored but overall stay was excellent.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Had an awesome stay here"
We had a great time at the Habor View Hotel. The room was huge and beautifully decorated. We had a ball here. We had nibbles at their bar and the food was delicious. All the staff were very welcoming. We would definitely stay here again and this hotel is highly recommended.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
very goodGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Beautiful older hotel with all the new amenities"
Beautiful room, large and linens very high end. Had table with bay window. Comfortable chairs. Staff were helpful when we asked for more coffee and cream---quick response. THis is great older hotel with style and the location can't be beat. Gorgeous view from the porch and many of the common rooms. Would go back again. Thank youGenuine Expedia guest review
"beautiful spot right in Edgartown"
Beautiful spot right on the water Porch is terrific as is the staff...only hitch is that we could hear the people above us...we stayed in the building behind the main building...breakfast was very good served by the waterGenuine Expedia guest review
"Safe and sound."
Location was great. Room and bed were comfortable. I should have told the staff: The television was set to the screen view so that the score of the football game was off the screen, something that can only be set with the original television set's remote, not the cable remote, so that was a little disappointing.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Top drawer affair all 'round, pip, pip!"
Very comfortable room in one of several "houses" that make up the property. Great location and the eponymous harbor view is authentic. Right by the water and close to several good restaurants. All round a fine spot for a brief getaway.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great holiday spot"
Beautiful hotel in a great spot. Easy walk into town. Had a nice breakfast at a reasonable cost in a lovely setting.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great in the off season"
I went to Harbor View for a business trip, it was a great trip and a great rate for the off season. It was my first trip to the area. Upon arrival we were upgraded to rooms in the main building. Once in my room , which was awesome, I discovered dirty wet towels in items in the trash in the bathroom. I called front desk and they quickly sent someone […] up to assist with moving to another room. It was just a fluke, but the next room wasn't as nice, it was much smaller. The temperatures were much higher than normal, so when I tried to turn the AC on for the evening when sleeping it was only putting out heat, as the AC was turned off for the season. This made is very hot and uncomfortable for sleeping. over all it was a nice place and I would visit again, but bring my own portable fan! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great place to stay. Always."
We come here at least once or twice a year, and everything is always first class.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Beautiful Stay in MV"
This was a lovely stay at the Harbor View Inn. The rooms weren't what I had imagined from the website. But we stayed in the General House which does not seem as luxurious. Nevertheless the rooms were clean and comfortable. The staff was very accommodating, especially Darlene the concierge. Location was great in Edgartown. Would recommend to others.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Martha's Vineyard Finest"
Very friendly and helpful staff. Handled every request immediately. Very comfortable environment. This is a must return.Genuine Expedia guest review
"can't beat the location and property"
Great room and the staff was the best! We enjoyed the week we stayed We will come back here againGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Our stay at the Harbor View couldn't have been more perfect. Everything about this hotel was fantastic. We loved every minute of it!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great start, less great finish"
Hotel is beautiful and beautifully located. The room appeared really clean on first inspection,, however, under the coffee maker and cups, it was unbelievably dusty. The walls are paper thin and a group who had come for a wedding were partying late into the night.....we were unable to sleep. the desk said they would take care of it, but little happened […] to solve the problem. In the morning I discovered the in room coffee maker (the one over the dust) didn't work properly and I went down to the desk. I was told one would be sent up. Two hours later, nothing had happened. There was no other complimentary coffee in the hotel. so it made what started out as a great experience turn into a disappointment. I would, however, be willing to give them another try, based on the really good location. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"So so nice."
Great. They asked why we were visiting and I told her we were celebrating our retirements. Later we received complimentary wonderful chocolate candies on a beautiful tray from the dining. We also received a congratulatory card. So sweet. ThanksGenuine Expedia guest review
I stayed in this hotel as a solo female traveler. I was there for a wedding and extended my trip. The overall experience was great. The best feature is the location. The scenery is stunning and it's walking distance to restaurants, shopping, and the bus system. The restaurant on site is really delicious as well. I also thought the pool was great! The […] staff was very accommodating and friendly overall. A few minor annoyances: they frequently forgot to check to see if I was out of conditioner, creamer, coffee etc. but brought it promptly on request. There was one manager (with a bow tie) that was a little rude one night because I think he thought we were not guests of the hotel and were drinking a private bottle of wine on the porch. Overall, the room was great. I was in a first floor room with a small porch area. There wasn't a view but still nice to sit outside. I was outside of the pool entrance which was noisy the few times I was getting ready and there was a janitor closet that was slammed frequently in the morning. I would request to stay on either end to avoid the noise. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
The hotel was nice, but our sunset cruise was cancelled due to engine trouble on the boat and they stated they did not have another. I made reservations in the hotel restaurant early in the morning for our birthdays; I asked for a window seat and they stated they would try. Our reservations were for 8 p.m. and we arrived at 7 p.m. We sat on the front […] porch waiting to be called noticing a table by the window at 7 not occupied. this same table was unoccupied from 7 until 9:30. We were seated in the middle of the restaurant, it was noisy and after complaining to an employee after having our dinner he stated he would move us then; to late. I would not eat there again, the water street restaurant in the hotel. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Everything about our stay was wonderful...the food...the staff...the view. I couldn't have been happier.Genuine Expedia guest review
Lovely hotel with very friendly and helpful employees. Main house is outstanding. All common areas very well kept and in excellent taste. Rooms in section in which we stayed, just behind the main house, could use new carpeting. It was motel style. Noisy guests above us and noisy exit outside our room was annoying.. Linens were nice. Restaurant, Water […] Street, was pleasant and good. I would return but would want to stay in main house. Loved the whole MV experience. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"R & R on the Vineyard!!"
Our stay was excellent! Definetly would come back.Genuine Expedia guest review
Everyone was very nice and place was comfortable and clean. Only thing is that beds were too high.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Awesome hotel in martha's vineyard"
Everyone was so pleasant and went out of their way to help. There was no nickel and dining you once you were there. Would definitely stay here again and recommend it to friends and family.Genuine Expedia guest review
"June 2012 on the Vineyard"
The location in Edgartown is excellent. There are so many shops and restaurants within walking distance of the hotel. The hotel has a cozy, homey feel. I really enjoyed staying there.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Beautiful venue, cutomer oriented staff"
Very, very nice venue. I'd welcome the chance to stay here again. Edgartown is the nicest locale on the Vineyard as well.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )