Very much enjoyed our stay. Hotel so convenient and staff very accommodating.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Had a great timeGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"perfect location to walk to all sights"
The location was perfect, but the street behind the hotel was very busy on Sat. night and noisy. The staff was very friendly and they had you sit for check-in. They also had our room ready for us when we got there at around 9:00 am in the morning .The building was really nice, but unusual.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Location, and quality of staff!"
The facilities were exceptionally beautiful, combining the old world elegance with the contemporary quality of service. We enjoyed several meals in the dining room and were pleased with the variety and staff there as well as the front desk and the concierge service. A genuine plealsure.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Ideally Located Hotel in Old Town Edinburgh"
This 5 star hotel was in the best location possible. We took a bus from the airport to the city center not knowing where the hotel was. How pleased we were to see it from the bus stop, a short walking distance! It is a few yards away from the main road in the Old City- The Royal Mile. If you looked in one direction, you could see the wonderful Edinburgh […] Castle and the other direction lead to the Queen's castle. The Royal Mile was loaded with pubs, restaurants and shops. The location made it so easy to go back to our room whenever we wanted. From our window, we had quite a view of the city. Our room was lovely with all the expected amenities and services. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable and told us all about the city, what we could do... The concierge even spent time with us recommending things to do after we left Edinburgh and headed for Inverness and the Isle of Sky. He marked many spots on the map that we would not have known about on our own. The Scotsman Hotel was excellent in every way! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Exceptionally nice hotel"
We spent three nights sightseeing around Edinburgh and picked this hotel by the ratings, price and location near the train station. We were delighted to find it was a beautiful old building with large lovely rooms, bathrooms and very helpful and pleasant staff. We spent a lot of time in the bar and restaurant area which was reasonable and tasty - GREATdrink […] selection. Besides being across the street from the train station, we were also just a city block from the King's Mile leading to the Edinburgh castle. I give it a perfect rating. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Old world hotel, very comfortable"
As a tourist, I loved this hotel. The room was huge for a standard room, with big wooden doors and felt private from the nearest room. I loved being able to open the windows at night for some fresh air and the sound of sea gulls. When I came in from the chilly rain, I felt cozy in the Scotsman bathrobe and I used the pants press and the iron to dry […] my damp clothes. I even asked if they could turn the towel warmer on, which they did right away. It was an easy walk from the train station, and an even easier walk up the Royal Mile. The place is very welcoming. I did not have time to use the spa facilities during my 2 nights here. I would definitely stay here again if another deal was offered. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
We absolutely loved this beautiful hotel. The staff was first rate, the room was very nice, and the location was perfect.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The staff, especially Ivor, was amazing. They made us feel very welcome and assisted with getting luggage to our room & making recommendations for dinner, etc. We had three rooms booked. One was extremely spacious, and looked out over the city. Large bathroom, too. The other two were more standard, but also comfortable. The only downside was the elevator. […] There are two separate ones, and sometimes you would have to walk through the lobby and toward the restaurant to the other one to get where you were going. With the limited number of lifts, it would sometimes also take awhile to be able to use it. Other than that, it was a wonderful stay! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"The Scotsman Hotel - good in cool weather"
Scotland was experiencing a heat wave when I stayed at The Scotman Hotel. Even with the fan we were given and the window open, it was almost too hot to sleep. As others mentioned, noise from the pubs near the hotel also made it difficult to relax. However, the staff went out of their way to make us comfortable, and the location couldn't be better. The […] next time I go to Edinburgh (in cooler weather), I would stay there again. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
A great place to stay. The staff is extremely helpful and friendly. One only has to ask and the staff will go out of their way to help. We were there during a heat wave and they were quick to bring in fans and open windows. The hotel is old and charming...The room is comfortable and relaxing... the location is perfect. It is close to Old Town and New […] Town. The Waverly Train station is right at their door! Who could ask for more!!!! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
The hotel appears to have been newly remodeled. Our room was beautiful. The location was excellent being just a very short walk from the train station. In fact, they had a special entrance at the lower ground level so you didn't have to walk up to the top of North Bridge where their main entrance was. The location of the hotel was just a couple hundred […] feet from the Royal Mile and a short distance to our tour pickup locations. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Great place to stay and in an excellent location. Overall 4 1/2 stars. The only reason that it would not be a five star is that it is very close to the railroad station and you can hear the noise from below. However if you close the windows and the drapes you cannot hear any noises from below. Does not have in room air conditioning and you will need […] to ask for an international plug for USA equipment. room service was excellent. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Quirky and Historic, and Oh, the View!"
What a nice break from chain hotels! The Scotsman is a historic building, with all the charm and character you might expect. Some little steps here, some odd angles there, no two rooms alike--we love that kind of thing. The service was terrific, from the desk clerk to the bellman. No air-conditioning, but our big, beautiful windows opened with ease, […] and the views of Edinburgh and the Firth of Forth were positively breathtaking from the 7th floor. The location is right in the heart of Edinburgh, with easy walking access from Waverly Station. I would definitely go back to The Scotsman. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great Location and Truly Scottish"
This hotel is in a gorgeous old building you admire as you cross North Bridge. It is the former and longtime home of The Scotsman newspaper. The Scottish staff was very helpful, our room was spacious and clean. This is a very convenient location to all that is on High Street, and we would definitely stay there again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"The Scotsman Hotel, Edinburgh, Scotland"
Very helpful staff. Our room was upgraded. Very good views of city from room.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Charming hotel with superb service"
I only had a day to spend sightseeing in Edinburgh after a business trip . The Scotsman Hotel was a perfect home base. It is close to everything, and the staff go out of their way to be helpful. My room was delightful, with an elevated sitting area and desk/dressing table in its own circular "tower" area. I felt completely pampered and can't wait to […] go back. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Very enjoyable. Andrew was extremely helpful.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Lovely hotel with superb service"
They really did think of everything with this hotel; coffee and tea in the room, a clothes line for drying clothes, bathrobes, a large bottle of drinking water delivered each day to the room, a newspaper left at the door; everything you'd possibly need. There's even a special door through which room service meals can be delivered to the room in perfect […] privacy. The room felt luxurious and meticulously maintained, the service was excellent and the staff were genuinely friendly and eager to help. The location is ideal, right at the edge of the old town but a convenient walk to other parts of town, and there's a lift that takes you right down into Waverly station, where you can easily grab a train, bus, or taxi. Staying in this hotel felt like a vacation, and it was a pleasure just to relax and read, or soak in the bath after a long day. Absolutely lovely; I'd stay there again in a heartbeat. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Drapes for giants but beds for dwarves"
We loved the room and location, were very satisfied with the overall cleanliness of the room and building, and impressed with the very helpful hotel staff... but as a 5'2" woman, I could not pull the tall, heavy wool drapes closed by myself, and my 6" tall husband's feet hung off the end of the bed. Very strange! But we'd probably stay there again anyway. […] Really appreciated, too, the new double pane windows over the old sash windows. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Atmospheric hotel in the heart of Edinburgh's tourist attractions.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Amazing Hotel! 9th Floor if you can get it!"
Amazing stay in wonderful hotel. If you can stay on the 9th floor or any with a view of the city it's amazing! Only one lift so slow to get to your floor or down, but worth it. Tough to get to if you're driving. If you can go ahead and look on their website about where to park and then bring your luggage up rather than try to stop outside the hotel […] and unload. It's really hectic! Wonderful amenities and great service by staff! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Best location; quality hotel"
Very courteous staff, upgraded our room. Everything very clean. Beds a bit soft. Linen and towels exceptional. A renovated old building made into a boutique hotel which really workedGenuine Expedia guest review
Lovely hotel. Especially attentive staff! Great experience.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"GREAT HOTEL AND LOCATION"
Incredible location at Market Street and North Bridge,One block from the Royal Mile and across the street from the Waverley Train Station and a block and a half from the # 100 Airport bus terminal(bus leaves every 10 minutes). You can easily walk to many of the Edinburgh sites. It is in an old but cool building next to a very steep hill so the layout […] is confusing. The lobby is on the 4th floor off North Bridge Street. If you are coming from the airport bus or train station there is a buzzer on Market Street on the 0 floor. They will let you in so you can take the lift up to the 4th floor. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
While I am the type to be a little uncomfortable with doors being opened for me, the use of my last name when being addressed, and having towels only used once, this level of service was performed with style and grace such that you felt they were genuine and sincere. From check-in, questions unrelated to the hotel, all the way through check-out, the […] staff were at 212 degrees! (a wonderful customer service book!) Incredible building, close to everything you would want to see. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Do yourself a favor"
Spend the extra $$ for this hotel. Top notch location and service! Nice sample of whiskey in your room when you arrive! 1 of best i've stayed in and travel 150-200 days a yearGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Very conveniently located to train and sights"
A lovely old hotel with charm. Staff was very helpful and pleasant. The gym was a little difficult to locate. . . Could use better directions or signage.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Scotsman- Top notch all the way"
Everything about the Scotsman was terrific. The room was wonderful and the staff above all was incredible. Would not stay any other place in Edinburgh.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Classy hotel but needs renovation."
This is a top hotel in the historic building with its charm both from exterior and interior but it needs to have some cosmetics already. Carpets in the halls and in thew rooms are dirty. Old TVs and telephones. Also right above the hotel is a night club so leaving and entering the hotel during friday and saturday night can be not dun. The train station […] is right in the front so that's what kind of a view you get there. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great hotel and location"
Would stay at the Scotsman again. It is attached to a public fitness center, so it was one of the best hotel gyms.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Classic Scottish Charm"
Excellent staff and location. Rooms were well appointed and roomy. Only issue we encountered was the temperature of the room (too hot...couldn't get it low enough to comfortably sleep).Genuine Expedia guest review
We were treated very well at the Judd Hotel. The room was beautiful, the service exquisite. It was very well located, just above the train station, on the Royal Mile.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great Historic Hotel"
The Scotsman was great! Customer service was awesome. They show you to your room and orient you and expect nothing in return. Location was perfect and was able to get to everywhere from there. Had a great time and hotel room views is amazing. Thank you to the Scotsman staff for the great service!Genuine Expedia guest review
"Wonderful Edinburgh Hotel"
Wonderful, historically quaint hotel, very centrally located to the Royal Mile and Castle, the rail station, and shops/restaurants of Edinburgh. Can walk to everything! Very nice attached restaurant, with great breakfasts. Staff very accomodating, kind. I really enjoyed my visit and would hightly recommend The Scotsman to others. sjmGenuine Expedia guest review
"Heroic level of service"
This is a beautiful hotel and in the best possible location for seeing Edinburgh. All of this, however, is obvious from a glance at the hotel's website. What the pictures can't show you, however, is the quality of the service. On our first morning a fixture in the bath tub failed, requiring an extensive plumbing repair and rendering the room unusable. […] Unfortunately we couldn't move to another room as the hotel was fully booked. Instead, the resourceful staff moved us to a beautiful room at the Caledonia, with full breakfast, and provided a taxi service for us. When we returned to the Scotsman the next night, they upgraded us to the Penthouse suite (an astonishing set of rooms with a near-panoramic view of the city), with a complimentary bottle of scotch. We were greeted warmly by staff whenever we went out or returned. Everyone was fully briefed about the arrangements that were made (at both Scotsman and Caldeonia) and thihgs could not have been made easier for us. I wouldn't even think about staying anywhere else. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Our stay was exceptional, beautiful hotel, perfect location on the royal mile. Customer service and staff was the best we have ever seen. Thank you.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Absolutely central location across from train station and around corner from shuttle bus to airport which is great bargain. Everything is within short walking distance. Very nice inside and good restaurant for breakfast.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The staff were especially helpful and knowledgeable. We especially loved their concierge, Ivar. The hotel and room were beautiful.Genuine Expedia guest review
I can't say enough good things about this hotel. The staff is super attentive. I was upgraded and my room was unbelievable. It's in a great location. Right in the center of everything. If you are going to Edinburgh, I would highly recommend you book here.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Nice spot in Edinburgh"
Great location nice staff. Ivor the concierge was really greatGenuine Expedia guest review
"Perfect Location and AMAZING staff service"
Stayed seven nights on our Honeymoon trip. Hotel was central to everything, and the Concierges 'The Boys' answered our every request with speed and enthusiasm. As one might expect in a Historical building the plumbing was a bit erratic, but the room was lovely and the bed and linens were super luxurious and cozy. Free snacks and Hot beverages in the […] room as well as a full honor bar and luxurious toiletries. GINORMOUS snuggly towels as well. Front-facing room was a bit noisy from Waverly Station and New-Town weekend Partiers, but the view was well worth it. Would recommend Highly. P.S. Wi-Fi is free but weak and slow so don't bother logging in. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Sleek & Sophisticated"
Beautiful hotel & rooms. Great location. But...lighting very poor in room & bathroom. No lighted make-up mirror. No towel racks. TP holder in awkward place. Tiny closet - had to take out hangars to fit the few things we were able to hang up but the bar was big and bountiful. Staff very nice & helpful. The city is definitely worth visiting.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Wonderful hotel, perfect location"
Loved the roof suites. Staff attentive. Classic but updated. Reception should be improved. Overall wonderful, very well located exactly in front of train stationGenuine Expedia guest review
"Very convenient ."
The staff were very friendly and helpful. The room was spacious and comfortable.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"A bonnie visit to the Scotsman in Edinburgh"
The attentiveness of the staff is one thing that they might work on. We asked for ice which was never delivered, we requested a wake up call - it never happened. They weren't quite as focused as we had hoped. Everyone greeted us warmly, we liked the turn down service. They upgraded our room and it was lovely with a great view. The work out facilities […] and pool lived up to their billing - unbelievable. The location really could not be better - North Bridge is in the middle of the Royal Mile. The elevator dropped us off literally at the entrance to the Waverly train station - and the building is beautiful. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Excellent location, great view from the room on Princess street. Excellent food in the hotel restaurant, one of the best! Hotel could do with some upgrades/renovation Looks a bit worn out. Loved it for location, polite service and gymGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Easy walking to Castle & other sites, restaurants, local shops & bars. Service was excellent.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Family Friendly Hotel"
Very family friendly. Can't compare with hotels in Paris that did not allow a baby for a room for two! The Scotsman staffs really welcomed our two year old very active daughter. We stayed five nights and it was very comfortable throughout. Highly recommendable for families with young kids.Genuine Expedia guest review
Lovely hotel with lovely furnishings! The couch had a cashmere tartan draping over it and the cupboards looked antique but incorporated modern elements which made the whole room feel very warm and comfortable. The hotel is just 5 minutes away from the Waverly Station and a few minutes away from the Royal Mile and tour agencies. My only minor complaint […] is that there are only 2 slow moving lifts so I can take some time to get in and out of the hotel but hey, I didn't mind waiting as the ambience was lovely and the staff were delightlfully friendly! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )