All hotels in Montreal, Quebec, Canada
1 room, 2 adults
Best Price GuaranteeBest Price Guarantee on hotel bookings. If you find a better price on exactly the same stay elsewhere we’ll match it
4.1 / 5Excellent

Score breakdown (from 293 reviews)

Average rating for:

  • Cleanliness
    4.4
  • Service
    4.4
  • Comfort
    4.1
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great Hotel for anyone new to Montreal"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Great customer service, parking is $20 a night which is standard everywhere! Everything is in walking distance. The suits are awesome with pull out couch, stove, fridge, kitchen, coffee, tea etc. All Great!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Mar 18, 2013
TBEEEZY
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"already planning a return"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
The hotel was very nice-we loved our room. The staff went out of there way to be helpful; one woman in particular sending a card and a small gift to our room upon learning of my fiance's birthday. it was a short walk to plenty of food and shops. Thanks for everything...
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip Mar 2, 2013
Tony and Renee
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great hotel"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    3.0
I really enjoyed my experience there. The personal is very nice especially miss Karine. The rooms are clean and nice. The beds are very comfortable as well as the pillows and the sheets. The breakfast buffet is amazing. I loved it.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night romance trip Feb 15, 2013
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"excellent location"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
We all enjoyed the cleanliness of the hotel and the breakfast spread was phenomenal for the price. Underground parking but not for SUV's Overall great experience. Had a lot of services I will stay there again.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Feb 1, 2013
Gloria
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great hotel, Service not so much."
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    2.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
I checked in with my fiancee with 5 pieces of suitcase, and did not receive any help with my bags at that time ,or at the time of the checkout. The hotel was nice and comfortable, but it does not have a restaurant, just a buffet area where breakfast(complimentary) is served. Other than that the stay was great, the hotel was clean and the pool quite lovely in the middle of winter hehehe.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Dec 24, 2012
Ricardo
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great location"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
I really loved this Hotel, my only problem was the extra $20 dollars a day for parking, a bit stif which makes the overall price not so great, however the staf was really friendly and helpful and the Hotel is in a great location.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night trip Nov 9, 2012
Roseli
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Very, Very good for an residence hotel"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Excelent quality and price.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night trip Oct 25, 2012
J. B
US

The following English reviews were posted by hotels.com guests from other countries:

4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great choice for families"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Great location and the 2 bedroom layout is perfect for families. We had a nice view of downtown Montreal. The kids enjoyed the pool, I enjoyed the fitness centre and the breakfast was better than we expected. The front desk staff were very helpful too. The only complaint really is that the parking lot has a very low ceiling and the spots are tight and the elevators were slow to come. Otherwise a great stay.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night family trip Apr 3, 2015
Shoshana
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Nice Hotel, Service Excellent !"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    3.0
Staff excellent service, they are exceptionnal hotle is nice, clean, brkst more than acceptable I really recommend this Hotel anyway as Marriott miles member it seems I cannot cumulate the miles bcz I did not booked via Marriott website
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night business trip Mar 26, 2015
DJEBBARI
GB
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Le visit"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Great location, good breakfast nice rooms(bathroom needs updating) Fantastic staff! Would stay there again
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
6 night family trip Mar 7, 2015
A Traveler
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"One night trip..."
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    3.0
The hotel was good. The room was exactly what we wanted. Some downfalls: the pool was a bit cold and no towels, we were woken up by someone else taking a shower at 6 am, the parking is short, so our car didnt fit, we had to park at the school couple streets from the hotel. But breakfast was great, good selection and good service. The hotel was what we wanted for a short trip!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night family trip Mar 19, 2015
Valerie
CA
2.0 / 5Fair
"Great service... Shame about the room."
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    1.0
  • Condition
    2.0
  • Neighborhood
    3.0
The service and staff was great but the taps in the tub did not work well - the water drained very slowly, meaning the tub was full up to my ankles by the time I was done my hot/cold shower. The heater was loud, and did not work well meaning whomever was sleeping the bedroom of our family suite was freezing while the person sleeping on the pull out couch was boiling.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night family trip Mar 16, 2015
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great service and location"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Staff were friendly and helpful. The front desk staff were amazing and always went above and beyond to answer our questions about touring Montreal. The breakfast was a bonus, much more variety than we anticipated. Breakfast included onsite was so convenient when traveling with children. The location was close to the metro - important because it was -40 every day we were there. This also made the room harder to keep warm but they have us a small heater to help. The kitchenette was great for evenings we didn't want to venture to a restaurant again and the grocery store was close. Would stay there again!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
5 night family trip Feb 12, 2015
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"nice"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Staff was very nice and helpful. The bed was quite hard and the comforter was a very thin white linen just a little thicker than a sheet ! we would have liked a real one..
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night romance trip Feb 17, 2015
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Very nice room but noisy due to the airconditioner"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
The air conditioner was noisy. It wake me up numbers of time during the night. This was the main inconviniant. The appartment was nice, two room, a fridge we were 5 so there was plenty of space for all of us.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip with friends Jan 17, 2015
Jean-Denis
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great breakfast & good price"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Free breakfast was delicious! The hotel room itself was nice & neat, but the one spoon in the drawer had a huge waxy white gunk on it, so it obviously wasnt cleaned or inspected - & when I saw huge i mean huge
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night romance trip Jan 3, 2015
justin
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great hotel"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
My husband and I have stayed at this location several times in Montreal. The staff are friendly and helpful, the service is great, the breakfast is amazing and the location is perfect..
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Nov 20, 2014
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Don't judge a hotel by the outside of the building"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
It was an excellent location for us to drive up from Toronto , right off the 720. We parked the car( not at hotel as the van was too big to go into spot). I was happy not to have parked on the street because some kids ripped off car mirrors the Saturday night. We parked at college de Montreal for 20$ a night. We walked everywhere. From the outside hotel looks old and unpleasant but it was fine on the inside. Staff were very pleasant . Breakfast included was good. I would go back.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night family trip Nov 14, 2014
kate
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"good for family"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Our room was cold. The location perfect easy access. Breakfast very good and room was clean. Only two elevator one of them out of order!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night family trip Nov 1, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Nice clean place!"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Nice place to stay for the price it is really clean and close to everything (downtown). Service was great, the only thing was 1 of the 2 elevator was out of service for the duration of our stay. Although pleased that our room was on the 5th floor and not the 19th (the stairs were very accessible and in excellent condition.)!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night romance trip Nov 1, 2014
Etienne
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Hockey night in Montreal"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Excellent for larger groups, very spacious. Hotel is clean,service was excellent and breakfast was great.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip with friends Oct 25, 2014
Tammy
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great location"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Absolutely the best location. Handy little kitchen too. Clean comfortable room. Only a little problem of the housekeeper being rude
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Oct 27, 2014
ex-Montrealer
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Nice hotel, good value for the money paid, the service was excellent and the staff were very kind and helpful. Very good breakfast.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night business trip Oct 21, 2014
A Traveler
IL
4.0 / 5Excellent
"visit to city"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Reception should be Extended. Anyhow, staff available did his best. Room could be larger.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Oct 3, 2014
Gerd
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"A nice place to stay"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
The staff were polite and welcoming. The room was clean and pleasant. The hotel is in a nice location. I would definitely go there again. Breakfast was very good. Many thanks.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Oct 2, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great breakfast ,room with stove to cook perfect."
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Very nice. If you want reviews you need to make them short and sweet otherwise I pass.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Sep 27, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"LOVED the balcony view of old towering buildings"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
really enjoyed the trip, our first time to MONTREAL, we were EXCITED to be there as our son was having a ceremony for completing basic training the following weekend in St.Jean sur Richilieu, so we decided to make a week of it and take some time in Montreal, spend some time with him the weekend before the basic training ceremony, and see some of the things he had seen during his time in Montreal the staff was friendly and helpful, and the breakfast staff very courteous it was wonderful experience that so many staff spoke English so well we may have left a book behind? "duck dynasty"
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Sep 21, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"A great time"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
We had a last minute travel and We booked this Hotel. We had a very good sojourn and the buffet breakfast was very good.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Sep 20, 2014
Bambi Haynes
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Excellent base of operations"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Very friendly reception personnel who made checking in and checking out a pleasure. Room was excellent, clean and the internet wifi worked perfectly. The location is superb, close to relatives in Westmount and within walking distance of downtown. Highly recommended.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Sep 18, 2014
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great Value - great location"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Our suite was large, well outfitted with the necessities and the breakfast was good with any choices provided. The rooms were clean and the hotel well maintained. Nice clean pool on the PH floor. The staff was excellent - very helpful. I would stay here again.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Aug 19, 2014
A Traveler
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"your romm is goof but not all"
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    1.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Once you get there, it is disaponting, the space of rooms and apartments are good. The staff are welcoming. But the building and the other service you get is not worted your hars working money. Just it is good for sleep.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Aug 30, 2014
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Close to art museum and restaurants"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
The location was very convenient, the hotel parking was a plus. My only complaint (minor) would be the very small, slow elevators. We had a 12th floor room with a lovely view, but next time I will ask for a room on the 2nd or 3rd floor so we can take the stairs. The breakfast was very good.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip Aug 22, 2014
CK
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Walking distance to downtown"
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Great location near downtown, supermarkets, restaurants and attractions Great staff service. my son has wonderful time at indoor swimming pool.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Aug 26, 2014
tram
CA
2.0 / 5Fair
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    2.0
Too many hiden charges. How room listed for $203.00 per night has the final charge $264.58?
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Aug 15, 2014
Andrew
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Loved the hotel, hated the breakfast"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Let me be clear, when we come back as a family, this is the place we will stay as the positives clearly outweigh the (very) few negatives. Do not hope for a great breakfast, more like functional, and do not come with a large 4x4 or you will need to walk 200m to an perfectly safe outdoor parking (but expensive !). All in all, a great time there and the staff was very helpful. Almost perfect.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night family trip Aug 4, 2014
Fernando
GB
4.0 / 5Excellent
"aaa"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
it was good enough for the price. building is old but inside is fine
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Aug 16, 2014
A Traveler
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great balcony nice room perfect little kitchen"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
great hotel staff were very helpful breakfast was good the view of the mountain was really nice
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Aug 12, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great Stay in Great City"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Stay at Residence Inn Marriott was tops. Service excellent; Front desk staff friendly and accommodating. Location was ideal.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night trip Aug 1, 2014
Edvard II
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Nice hotel close to downtown district , nice area."
  • Cleanliness
    4.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
it is gd for family or business trip stay over . But parking lots is limited .
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Aug 2, 2014
jackie
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Good place to stay"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
My family and I stayed 3 nights in Residence Inn and were very happy with the hotel. Great hotel with very helpful staff. Very good service and very clean. Good location close to everything in downtown.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night trip Jul 25, 2014
A Traveler
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Centrally located"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Well equipped room to look after yourself (kitchen)
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 28, 2014
A Traveler
CA
1.0 / 5Poor
"Very old building"
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    2.0
  • Condition
    1.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Very old building with very slow elevators. Breakfast was great but building has to be updated it's too old No parking garage can fit no SUV
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 26, 2014
traveller wirh
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Good location to start your visit."
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    5.0
Overall the experience was great. The staff was very friendly, and helpful. Indoor parking can be a bit tight if you have a full size car.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip Jul 19, 2014
Peter
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"Ok but not for the price"
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Its really unfortunate that I'm giving a not great review here, but I must, for a couple of reasons. 1- the room features were dated and falling apart (mirror ready to come off the wall, bathroom glass shelf railing fell off) 2- the ac was so loud when it turned on throughout the night that it woke us up every time and 3- the room doors have nothing to stop them from slamming shut, which happened 3 or more times during the course of the night when our neighbours across the hall kept leaving their room (for unknown reasons). The staff were excellent and went out of their way to make our stay good, and have a full breakfast included was really nice too. My other issue is the pool was really quite small, so when you get a bunch of people looking for a dip on a hot summer afternoon it gets a little crowded. Considering the price, and the fact that it isn't located in downtown, I wouldn't recommend to someone else. There are other hotels closer to downtown for a better price with most or all of the same features.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 22, 2014
K
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Very nice hotel"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    3.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Everything was great except the internet which was very slow...even though i contacted the support team...
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 18, 2014
Michel
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"Montreal - expected more"
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    3.0
  • Condition
    2.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
hotel isn't worthy of its star rating. really old and run down ... pool was green and couldn't seem to get hot water in the shower. Breakfast was OK which was a positive and in terms of location it is central which are probably the only positives ... parking in garage is dark, dingy and very tight for any vehicle larger than a mini really expensive!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 16, 2014
Hutch
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"OK in Montreal"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    3.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Hotel was nice enough but disappointed with parking. We had to park our minivan 3 blocks away for the same price as underground parking.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 6, 2014
Serena
CA
3.0 / 5Good
"Hit or miss"
  • Cleanliness
    3.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    1.0
  • Condition
    1.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
We were there over the canada day long holiday. We booked a 2 bedroom apt. It was spacious, clean, and had a wonderful view. Staff were prompt, courteous and super friendly. However, the hotel amenities themselves are not so great. The bed mattresses were terribly uncomfortable. Also, be advised that One bedroom had an a/c unit, the other didn't. The room with the a/c had issues with the unit's cooling system. When we notified staff they changed it immediately- howver the new one was so noisy we couldn't get a goodnights sleep for the rest of our stay. Also, the bathtub was clogged all the time so u really couldnt wait to get out of it. Breakfast is generous but tasteless. You can always buy ur own food though. U will need to factor in 20$ per day if u have a big car/ truck for parking. Location is perfect though- walking distance to everything in downtown. I also have to reiterate that the staff were really wonderful. Oh, and the comments about the elevator are true. It does take forever. I would not return to this particular hotel primarily due to the a/c room/ bed experience.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 4, 2014
family of 5
CA
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great location good value"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    4.0
  • Comfort
    4.0
  • Condition
    5.0
  • Neighborhood
    -
Pleasantly surprised by the quality of our room. Decent breakfast. Bit of a line at the waffle machine for my kids.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 2, 2014
mom of 2 boys
CA
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Business trips"
  • Cleanliness
    5.0
  • Service
    5.0
  • Comfort
    5.0
  • Condition
    4.0
  • Neighborhood
    4.0
Fantastic room. Great breakfast.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Jun 19, 2014
A Traveler
CA
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews