"Need a place close to LI and NJTP"
Very good option. Not a lot nearby, but for a place on the go, it was fine.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"it was nice"
I would stay here again... But for a king size bed the room was very small... I guess I expected bigger... But the bed was super comfortable I loved it... Wish breakfast was longer then just from 6-8am but hey maybe I'll wake up earlier next time... I would recommend this hotel to my friends...Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This hotel worked out great - good location, great price and seemed very new. Front desk was super friendly. Rooms are small, but great value.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Our family of four stayed at the Comfort Inn Staten Island on August 21, 2013 because we were moving our daughter into her Wagner College dorm the next day. The hotel, the room, and the staff were all great. No complaints at all. Will definitely stay here (or at the nearby Holiday Inn Express) on future stays.Genuine Expedia guest review
Nice and clean. The room was small, but it is NY. Beds are very comfy. Would stay here again,Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Would stay again"
Room was clean. Had a king size bed and was very comfortable even though the room was pretty small. Overall had a great stay. Staff was extremely helpful and very kind. I would definitely stay there again. They helped us with directions and even offered to help plan our next trip to New York with things to see and do. Just wonderful.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Nice comfortable place to stay"
Good location friendly and very clean. Great value for the money!Genuine Expedia guest review
Everything was just fine, thank you.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
It was ok. Small room and bad locationGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great experience during our time of bereavement."
Excellent...staff was courteous, professional and helpful from check in to check out. I would recommend this Comfort Inn to anyone and my husband & I would stay here again.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Bug found crawling on a pillow"
In the morning,as we were ready to leave, I have found a bug on my pillow. Possibly a bedbug. We reported this to the front desk.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"very small rooms"
Upon arriving, there were too many people hanging out in the lobby. Some staff, some guests, some unknowns which gave the place a sleazy, SRO quality. Not to mention the staff smoking in front of the doors you use to go into the hotel. The front desk person the first night was very professional and a great sales person. After that our experience with […] the staff wasn't as pleasant. BE WARNED the rooms are miniscule. I mean really really small. Shockingly so. There was hair on the bathroom floor. One of the residents in the lobby told us that their family had been living at the hotel for 9 months. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Close to bridge/road"
I went there for a job interview. The location was great if you need to drive, I don't know about the mass transit though. It smelled a little funny. Make sure your door is closed all the way when you leave. There was no fridge unfortunately.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Will stay again"
We have stayed here 3 times. The rooms are small but very clean. All staff was friendly and helpful.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Clean hotel with reasonable price."
Room was clean, comfortable but small. Complimentary breakfast was good.Genuine Expedia guest review
Convient and good hotel.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
very nice very convenient, good staffGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great Vantage point to Manhattan"
Our stay was great at this Comfort Inn. Located in a quiet neighborhood but still accessible to ferry service to Manhattan. Rooms were clean but a little small for our king-sized bed. Hotel staff was friendly and helpful in getting us over to the major part of the city. The breakfast was great! A shuttle service was provided to save on parking fees. […] I would highly recommend this Comfort Inn to others who want to stay in New York City but not wanting to pay high Manhattan prices! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Clean place for the night"
Staff and facilities very nice but rooms are small and I had an upgraded room. Would be tight for more than 1 person!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
I have been in this hotel twice now, and I would return, it is a nice hotel, and one of the cheapers on NY zone.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Read the Ratings Before Booking"
I made a huge mistake in not reading the ratings this time. The room was so small you could not move in it. My husband fractured his hips and we could not even get his wheelchair in the room. Just two people but there was only 1 1/2 feet of walking space around each side of the bed. The closest was 1 1/2 foot wide. We had no wash clothes in the room […] after checking in when I called down at 10:30 pm and exhausted from our trip to Staten Island and when I called down to ask for them they said I could come down and get them. I said no, I was undressed and could they bring some up. Then they finally said yes. NEVER showed up. Next morning called at 8:30 am and they told me I would have to wait until 9:30 when housekeeping came in. NOT I have a wedding to attend! Now I have to say the staff was REALLY nice but customer service, NOT. Our daughter and her family stayed 2 miles down the road at the Hampton Inn which was nice, clean and large rooms. Just down the road was a very bad neighborhood. Did not feel safe in this area. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"TINY ROOM and CHARGED TWICE"
The room was incredibly small with very minimal walking room. My husband and I could not walk in the room at the same time and we are not big people. I asked hotel about being double charged because I saw an additional charge pending on my credit card. The room was prepaid so after questioning the front desk about the charge I was assured that it would […] be removed. It was not removed and I had to make several phone calls to make certain that the hotel corrected their mistake. Beware of double charges. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I wanted a non-smoking room, but I needed a room with 2 beds. The management said they could only give me a room with 2 beds on a smoking floor. I was in a bind for a room and had to take it, but I would have preferred a non-smoking room. Also when I checked out all my clothes smelled of smoke just from being in the room.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Good Location and Value for the price."
This hotel provides a clean and affordable stay to the passing or overnight traveler. I had a business appointment close-by and needed an hotel just for an overnight stay. While the room was small, it was clean and offered the same amenities in a compact format. Hotel staff was friendly. Location met my needs and comparable hotels with similar comfort […] was easily $25-$50 more minimum per night. Breakfast was a standard continental fare and met expectations. New York is an expensive market and you get what you pay for, I think in relative terms, this hotel is giving you good accommodations for the price. Would stay again if needed. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Good place for a night's rest"
Spouse said this room reminded one of a large walk-in closet as seen on HG TV . . . Slight exaggeration, but you get the idea. King bed took up most of the room but was comfortable and provided good night's sleep. Room was clean and quiet with no disturbances despite the hotel being fully booked. Hotel should have direct access from Rt 440 north rather […] than having to drive through very modest neighborhood off exit 7 of Rt 440.P Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great NY Deal"
Overall better than I expectedGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great hotel, small rooms"
Very small rooms, but EXTREMELY helpful staff, who was very willing to print out directions for me. Also, exceptionally clean.Genuine Expedia guest review
I thought it was the worst motel room i have ever stood at..The parking lot was under renovations so being handicap like i am, i had to walk from the end of the street to the motel...And as for the room it was so small we couldn't even move around. And after we called for a little fridge it was worse..As for the elevator (there was a wedding party at […] your motel ) and it was so slow and so small that we had to wait almost 15 min for it to go from the lobby to the 5th floor and back down for us....Terrible Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great place to stay"
Clean, comfortable, friendly, and for a great price!Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Everything is smaller up North"
I've always heard, everything's bigger in Texas but my goodness, the room was very "tight" in Staten Island. Just wide enough to walk into the room and hit the bed, especially for the price. Priced about the same as any other area with half the room. You couldn't open the bathroom door and the door to the room at the same time, one or the other HAD […] to be closed. Not a negative experience, just not used to such small rooms. I am a little claustrophobic. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
This hotel clean and staff was helpful- we had trouble with our car and they were very nice and helpful. It is what is is- basic but clean, bed short, rooms small but expected that. Close to highway. My biggest issue- I could hear doors closing in hall all night. But, I am noise sensitive Not the quietest hotel I've stayed in.Genuine Expedia guest review
"parent of college student"
Clean, a beat off the beaten path, nice staff, and with breakfast included a decent bargain.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Great Value for the price"
Only stayed one night while visiting my family who lives near by. The room was clean. The staff was very friendly and the breakfast was filling.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Clean and comfortable..."
Clean and comfortable. Room somewhat cramped. Mini fridge and microwave in the room would be nice. The room and common area was clean.The breakfast was ample and kept well stocked and cleaned. Surprised in the AM to have a view of a landfill. Overall, it served as a good overnight stay.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Very nice and clean hotel."
Very nice and clean hotel. Decent breakfast. A little bit noisy from highway.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Rooms are small, but clean"
Positives: Location was convenient, price was right, rooms were clean and well maintained... Could be betters: Rooms are small for a king, Shower activation was strange, Elevator is small and not incredibly fast... Out of their control: Some people were very noisy when they came back to their rooms at 2 or 3 a.m.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Clean inexpensive NYC alternative"
The staff was very polite. Rooms were small but to be expected in city. The staff was great arranging shuttle service to the ferry and great with directions.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Stayed over night"
The desk clerks were very accommodating and helpful.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great for what I needed"
If you are looking for an inexpensive, neat, friendly, no frills stay for a night or two, this is the place. The room was small with only a walking path around the bed. The bed was comfortable and the room was clean. Staff was very nice and helpful. My only real complaint was the running toilet and peeling wallpaper.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
over all it s good. room was small. no fridg. breakfast was good. it s comford but nothing beyond that.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"great place to lay your head"
Staff was great. Hotel is good. Its a little out of the way for a tourist without a car. Rooms are small, small, small.Its the perfect hotel if you don't plan to spend a lot of time in the room.Prices are good. .Genuine Expedia guest review
"very basic hotel"
The room was very small but clean. The remote control for the tv wasnt working but that wasn't a big deal. If the phone was working I could have called to let the front desk know. At around 12:00a.m. a child was screaming in the lobby. I attempted to let the front desk know but no one was at the desk and people were waiting. I called the manager and […] let her know about my experience. She was apologetic and assured me the situation would be dealt with. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
not 2 bad, not 2 great.. poor room location, nice room decorGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Room was very small. Hotel was ok. If you are coming to town to visit family and won't be needing room to do anything besides sleep and shower than this hotel is great for that. No major complaints just not overly impressed.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Cheap clean hotel with small room!"
Overall a clean hotel with good service. Only bad things were a very small room. Just enough room to walk in and walk around my bed though it had a big bathroom. Also wifi was free but not good at all! And no on demand movies and no restaurant on site or next door at holiday in. Was a great bar/restaurant 1/4 mile a way though. Would stay there aga […] in. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The hotel was clean and nice and reasonably priced. Good breakfast every morning. We enjoyed our stay there!Genuine Expedia guest review
Never came to clean the room had to go to the lobby 3 times for towels they wouldn't bring them up. Room extremely smallGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Shuttle to ferry not all it seems"
Came to hotel beause of a New York package. Disappointing that the shuttle to the Staten Island ferry did not "run" on Monday and Tuesday which was not on web and is not really acceptable. While the bus system can be an option from the ferry to the hotel, got caught in the rain twice just trying to make it from bus stop to hotel. Bad plan for the shuttle […] to "fill" up so quickly, one family of 5 makes it virtually impossible for anyone else to use at that time due to the sharing of two hotels with the shuttle. Every two hours on the hour can be improved since most are actually trying to make the ferry. The 10 am shuttle missed the 1030 ferry twice. Really! why can't they be scheduled for 945? It is bad enough that it take 2 hours from midtown to make it to hotel but all this makes it kind of a "stretch" to recommend it as a great option. The room was quite small. A king must have been assembled in the room. Staff was nice and breakfast a great perk! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"great price but must have a car"
We booked this hotel because it was the cheapest hotel in the NYC area in such proximity to downtown Manhattan. it is very convenient if you have a car. It takes 20 min driving to get to the Manhattan ferry by car and then less than 30 minutes on the free ferry. The ferry runs 24/7. The hotel was very clean and the breakfast was good.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Simple property with no services."
Hotel staf was very helpful. Room extremely small no room for suitecase. Good breakfast.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )