All hotels in Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States of America
1 room, 2 adults
You can collect Hotels.com® Rewards nights here
23 Kelly Street, Martha's Vineyard, Edgartown, MA, 02539, United States of America, ‏‎800-491-6126
Best Price GuaranteeBest Price Guarantee on hotel bookings. If you find a better price on exactly the same stay elsewhere we’ll match it
4.4 / 5Excellent

Score breakdown (from 188 reviews)

Average rating for:

  • Cleanliness
    4.4
  • Service
    4.5
  • Comfort
    4.4
  • Condition
    4.1
  • Neighborhood
    4.9
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great homey friendly hotel"
I stayed at Kelley House two nights on great end-of-summer days, with my teenage children. Could not have been more satisfied. Clean, homey, friendly staff; having the pool for before and after beach and being right in Edgartown, were perfect.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Aug 24, 2014
A Traveler
US
3.0 / 5Good
The hotel was adequate, but for the price I would have expected a few more amenities, like ice on each floor, better finishes in the bathrooms. A little dated with respect to the interiors. Bed was very comfortable and we were lucky to have a corner room with a view of the dock.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
4 night trip Aug 20, 2014
A Traveler
US
2.0 / 5Fair
The hotel has a wonderful location in Edgartown, however, the common areas were dirty. The hotel was outdated and needed some level of modernization.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Aug 16, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
Very nice, able to walk down to shops, restaurants, right near the pier. Like the pool & bar. Great muffins & coffee!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Jul 25, 2014
Kathy & Bob
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Quaint and High End"
While we were only there one night, would definitely stay again. Close to restaurants and shopping, taxi service right outside the hotel and only a 5 minute walk to the bus for easy access all over the island. We loved sitting outside when we got back from dinner after a busy day of sightseeing. The staff were all friendly, helpful, and seemed to genuinely enjoy being there.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip Jul 27, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
Lovely staff. comfortable hotel. Great yoga in the morning. Fun pool bar. Though pool itself is rundown. Would be a nice family destination as they have arts and crafts, milk and cookies and other child friendly activities. Great location right in center of Edgartown.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 30, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
Love MV, first time staying in The Kelly House. It's a great location and met our needs.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 30, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"GREAT stay :)"
The place was perfect...the quality of the hotel was perfect, the location was perfect and the customer service was perfect. I definitely recommend the Kelley House. The only minor compliant that I have is we had breakfast there on a Sunday morning and it was extremely SLOW, so I'm not sure eating at the associated restaurant would get my vote but it certainly did not take away from the overall experience. I'm a happy customer and would absolutely return.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip with friends Jul 25, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Very nice place!"
Very happy with the accommodations.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
4 night trip Jul 14, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
We liked it so much that we are planning a return trip. Excellent location, very forthcoming staff, we spent the day at the pool even though we checked out at noon. Our luagage was stored for us and we were welcome.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night family trip Jul 17, 2014
Rene
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Website oversells hotel"
the photos make this place look spectacular. didn't realize our room was part of such a large building...and on the 3rd floor with no elevator. Expedia rooms always seem to have view of the back of the hotel/parking lot! We travel a great deal as retired banker and school teacher - US and Europe.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 12, 2014
Mark
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"A great week at the Kelley House"
We stayed 5 days and 4 nights at the Kelley House on the first floor in the main hotel. The location is perfect, close to all the shopping, the harbor, restaurants and bus stops. The staff is friendly and provides warm popovers and lemonade in the afternoon and warm cookies and milk in the evenings. Delicious! The pool was nice and the outdoor seating area next to the pool was great for eating a take out lunch when you want to "push the easy button". They were in the process of building what looked like an outdoor bar next to the outdoor seating when we were there. Our room was large and easily accommodated our family of 5. Fresh linens for the comforter rather than one that has been used by 100's of people was a nice touch as well as daily housekeeping service. The bathroom is a bit dated and there were some stains on the carpeting in the hallway, but this is an old hotel after all. This is not a fancy hotel, it's more like an old home that has been renovated, but a perfect option for a wonderful stay in the Vineyard. The staff was fantastic and made you feel welcomed. I would go back to the Kelley House in a heart beat and would recommend it to any and all of my friends. You can't go wrong here.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
4 night family trip Jul 6, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Quaint, comfortable and very convenient!"
We enjoyed our stay very much.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night family trip Jul 5, 2014
Steve
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Great Location. Needs updating"
We had a very good stay at the Kelley House the week of the Fourth of July. This place has the best location!! You roll out of your room and you have your pick of great shopping and food. You can walk to everything. They have 3 parking locations so parking wasn't an issue. BUT, this place is in need of a major renovation. The rooms smell and rugs have water stains. The bathroom we were had mold issues and the bathroom door was warped. Pool is in need of TLC. The staff were incredible. Everytime I walked through the door I was greeted with a friendly hello. They couldn't be nicer and helped with all our needs. I'm torn with this place. Because of location and staff I give it a 3. If they update the hotel I would give it 5 stars!!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 7, 2014
John
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"A pleasant surprise"
Once we arrived on the island, we stopped at the information booth. When asked where we were staying, the man they said, oh, that is a nice hotel. Same when with our taxi driver. It is an old building so there were some uneven floors and maybe the sound proofing could have been better but I have not complaints. The hotel is in a very convenient part of town. We walked to dinner, drinking, live music and even the ferry to Chappaquiddick Island was right out the back door. The staff was very nice and the cookies and milk in the evening and the muffins in the morning was a nice touch. I am sure we will be back.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night romance trip May 24, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Historic Edgartown with a pool and bikes"
Our family of two parents and two teens really enjoyed our stay at the Kelley House. The staff was very attentive and helpful, ready with suggestions if things to do and places to eat. Morning coffee and muffins or popovers in the lobby, and afternoon fresh baked cookies and lemonade really hit the spot. Lots of fresh towels, damask linens, plenty of pillows as you'd expect from a nice inn.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jul 3, 2014
Lee
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"It's the little things that make a stay memorable!"
Although I was upgraded and had a lovely suite it's a pity the service isn't quite up to speed. I stayed 3 nights but toiletries were never replenished, the cutting board in the room was used by the previous guest but never cleaned in the 3 days, it's the little things!! Otherwise position of the hotel can not be bettered and the room was very comfortable. They staff could have been a little more helpful and like a previous comment, there is no hotel information supplied and had to ask where my room was as I had no idea where the other accommodation houses were. The pub staff were a bit unhappy too!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night trip Jun 23, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Right Price / Right Place"
Kelly House is overall a GREAT choice for Edgartown. Best location, great pub, great price (got our room for $205 in June which is not yet "the season" But why come in July and August when the Island is mobbed? Wonderful pool and the only very slightly neg. is the Hotel is old and thus a 4 not a 5, but dah-... It has antiqued class and the bathroom was very basic. But I'd go back in a heartbeat.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Jun 15, 2014
bf
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
My husband and I had a lovely stay at the Kelley House. The bathrooms were less than average, vinyl floors and we were missing our hand towel holder. But the hospitality of the staff, and overall experience was lovely.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jun 19, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Excellent!"
Great place! Great location right in the middle of downtown and just a 45 second walk to the Chappy ferry. Will stay here again when we go back.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night family trip Jun 15, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Friendly, close to everything"
The hotel staff were very friendly and helpful. Every morning they offered coffee, tea and muffins and the coffee was very good. The hotel itself is right in the heart of everything and close to the beach and restaurants. The rooms were very comfortable.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jun 10, 2014
cm
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"great location"
courteous helpful staff -great corner room with 4 windows overlooking the water/pool/garden area and the street - great muffins in a.m. and warm chocolate chip cookies in the p.m.- loved The Newes bar and restaurant atmosphere and bartenders, the entire trip was just awesome!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jun 7, 2014
Shirley & Chris
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Nice hotel in the middle of town."
Perfectly situated to walk around Edgartown and be close to the beach, the harbor and restaurants. Pleasant staff who helped organize tours and answer questions.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jun 6, 2014
Jan
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Nice hotel"
The only thing I would suggest, take off the breakfast.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Jun 4, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Perfect hotel for your weekend getaway!!"
We arrived to the hotel a little early and they were able to provide us with our room right away. I was quite surprised to be handed 2 actual room keys!! No electronic card readers. The room was spacious and the bed very comfy. It had its standard mini fridge, hair dryer and iron. Plenty of dresser space and hangers in the closet. Our room faced the street and there was a chair and ottoman by the window. It was nice to sit there with the window open and smell the ocean and people watch from above. There is some car traffic but I'm from the city and it didn't bother me. The hotel pool looked clean and inviting but the weather was just a bit to chilly for a swim. The location of the hotel could not be any better. Everything we needed was in walking distance. There are several seafood restaurants in the area as well as a little breakfast joint nearby. We ate a small lunch at the colonial pub attached to the hotel. We ordered a couple of apps and they were average tasting. They have several local craft beers on tap which I liked. It was nice to sit outside and enjoy the sunny weather. The hotel sits across from Memorial Pier which has a roof deck with benches so you can look out into the harbor and watch the Chappy Ferry take cars across to Chappaquiddick. In the evening the hotel provides cookies for its guest and coffee and muffins in the morning. Overall I give the Kelley-House a 5/5. We will definitely be returning to the Kelly House this summer!!!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night romance trip May 30, 2014
Jimmy
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Nice Historic Hotel in downtown Edgartown."
Great friendly staff, in heart of Edgartown, comfy beds, free am muffins and coffee, pm cookies in lobby.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 30, 2014
A Traveler
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Nice but not worth the money."
It was unremarkable. The hotel was nice but not overly impressive. Stains on the carpet in our room and hallways. Staff was friendly but not unique in anyway. For the money, quite frankly, I expected more. If you're looking for a nice hotel this is fine. If you're looking for a special getaway, this isn't it. BTW, they must have run out of hot water the last morning we were there because I had to take a cold shower.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night family trip May 24, 2014
DM
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Wonderful!!!"
Wonderful!!! Perfect location, room and staff. Loved the coffee, muffins and cookies.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 23, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
Great time. Beautiful, old building. Great location in the center of town- placed right along the strip of shops and restaurants.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 23, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great hotel in the middle of downtown Edgartown"
Had a wonderful time. I would definitely stay there again.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 21, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"GREAT LOCATION--GREAT STAFF"
Wonderful stay. Clean room. The staff at the front desk were helpful. Extra bonus is the morning muffins with coffee and evening hot chocolate cookies and milk..Nice pub next door that has good food. They provided hot water for tea downstairs/and in room Krups machine for your enjoyment.Will definitely stay again. Easy walking distance around the town of Edgartown. Even walked to the local market Stop and Shop!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
4 night family trip May 10, 2014
shy6t
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Maybe after some more training?"
It's early season..but we had tough time getting into hotel..only to find serious smoking odor, desk folks had difficult time with desk system..but first busy weekend...Ok by now perhaps.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 16, 2014
A Traveler
US
3.0 / 5Good
The lobby, restaurant and downstairs was closed for repairs. The floors were being sanded and stained so very strong fumes. On site restaurant was closed. Would have liked to have known this propr to booking and at least been give a discounted rate for the overall conditions.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip with friends May 6, 2014
Victoria
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Great location. Not ready for guests in May."
The hotel was under significant renovation during our stay which was not disclosed before we booked. The attached restaurant was closed as well as the lobby. The staff was very nice and the location is excellent. Otherwise, I thought the hotel was mediocre and I assume that during the high season people go there for the location and not the hotel.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 9, 2014
Joe
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Pre-season trip"
Went on a bicycling trip. The hotel is quite clean and tidy. Support staff is very courteous and helpful. Will definitely stay here again.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 6, 2014
Ram
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Going to get the updating that it desperately need"
Great location and a wonderful staff. Very nice inn keeper. Very helpful, patient and very accommodating.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip May 4, 2014
rick
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Early Spring Getaway"
The Kelley House is clean and comfortable. The coffee served in the morning in the common room was delicious but the same banana muffins each day were not at all appealing, the cookies were all gone by 8pm when advertised as cookies from 7-9pm. The one really annoying aspect of our weekend was that our room was finally cleaned and fresh towels provided after we went looking for housekeeping at 5pm!!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Apr 28, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great location"
Very nice hotel -great location for stay in April during school vacation week. The staff was very helpful and the muffins in the morning and cookies in the evening were great.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night family trip Apr 23, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Great stay !"
Great location, close to bus stop, right next to the water, shops and restaurants. The room was very large and the bed was incredibly comfortable.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Apr 27, 2014
Sam
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Good time"
Love the history of the building. Location was great!! Friendly staff and loved cookies and milk! Hotel is noisy and many guests were quite loud! Coffee machines in room didn't work well! Food at News Cafe was not good!!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Apr 15, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Great location"
We stayed in the off season when prices were very low. That said, despite most stores being closed, our location was still pretty good. It's right next to all of those cute little shops, again - 90% of which were closed for the off season. It was also right next to the Chappy Ferry. The customer service was impeccable and we loved the complementary cookies and milk at 7PM and the complementary coffee and muffins at 7AM. Well played Kelley House, Well played.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Apr 18, 2014
Eric
US
3.0 / 5Good
"Heat Or Air (No in between)"
The free coffee & muffins in the morning were a wonderful way to start the day. With April's temperatures, the lack of having either air or heat controlled by the hotel not by the room meant a warmer than usual hotel room. With a room on the third floor the heat rising didn't help. Friday night leaving the windows open to get some cooler air helped. But on Saturday night the noise from the parking lot below until 2 am and the warm room made for poor sleeping and really rough on a person with an early ferry time and 10 hour drive the next day. Regarding cleanliness, found last guest's half used shampoo bottle in the bath tub and discovered some other "trash" items in the room under bed and in two drawers.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Apr 21, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Close to Everything"
Peaceful. After getting coffee in the morning, we could walk to the wharf and enjoy the harbor.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Apr 16, 2014
A Traveler
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Historic Krlly House"
We are returning visitors to the Kelly House. Older building...well maintained. Furnishings homey...king size bed with cozy quilt and plenty of pillows . I really enjoy the breakfast...coffee and muffins...just enough....would have likes OJ ...we will return!
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
1 night trip Mar 1, 2014
PatriciacKilcullen
US
4.0 / 5Excellent
"Quiet Get-AWAY"
It was a quiet and restful getaway. With no distractions from the rest of the world I was able to fully rest and relax. The hotel was clean, super quiet and staff were all pleasant. Only negative was no microwave in the room.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Feb 20, 2014
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Nice, clean comfortable place to stay"
The Kelley House had very welcoming, informative people at the front desk. The lobby was clean and comfortable. The rooms were great. The free milk and cookies at night and muffins andd coffee/tea in the AM were very much welcomed!
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Feb 24, 2014
Melissa
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Full of charm and hospitality."
I had an extremely pleasant stay at the Kelley House. I would stay again in a heartbeat! The staff were pleasant, friendly and very gracious. The accommodations were excellent. My only wish is that there was a mini microwave in the room. The location is right in downtown Egartown and a short walking distance to shops, library, wharf, beach and lighthouse. It is the most quaint area to spend time on MV. I will come again before the summer rush comes again!!! I hated to leave and come back to the real world duties again even though I extended my stay by two more days for business reasons.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
3 night business trip Feb 17, 2014
PJT
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"yes i would recommend this hotel"
had a great time at the kelley house sitting next to the fireplace on that brisk night was very relaxing
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Oct 26, 2013
A Traveler
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Heart of Martha's Vineyard"
Everything in Edgetown is very close to Kelly house even the ocean view. Friendly staff and prompt service in this classic old-home/hotel. Restaurants and shops all around the area within walking distance.
Genuine Hotels.com guest review
2 night trip Oct 11, 2013
Larry Oltmanns
US
5.0 / 5Outstanding
"Nice Hotel that we will definitely return to."
We especially liked the warm cookies and cold milk put out every night.
Genuine Expedia guest review
Other trip Oct 15, 2013
Gregg and Debbi
US
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews