"A solid pit stop"
PROS: Room was clean, extremely quiet, very convenient to interstate, nice front desk people. CONS: Musty smell when first entering, couldn't get the room cool even on a very chilly night, had to go an exit farther to find a dinner place. Overall, not bad for just a room. If it ever gets full Red Roof upgrade it will probably be much better. Rooms don't […] really look like rest of chain yet. Feels like an old road motel that was once nice but outdated now. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
The room was clean and had clean sheets, towels, however the hotel itself was in poor shap, the plants were dying in the hallways, the walls were dirty and the carpet needed cleaning terribly, the grounds looked like the facility was left to decay. The breakfast offered was simple but adequate however the counter was dirty and not tidy. This was not […] acceptable. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Very Satisfied, Would stay in the Carlise location"
Clean, Staff cordial, room cleanGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Odd and uncomfortable experience"
Was told that all 1st flr rms were fullc. Parked in a nearly empty lot, & entered (@ 11:15 pm) through a door that was supposed to be locked @ 11 p.m. (and wasn't), saw a note on the door to the 1st flr, asking for patience during remodeling--from all appearances, both inside & out, there were NO rms occupied on the 1st flr. On 2nd flr found stairwell […] door--bearing a note saying that, for fire safety, door was to remain closed @ all times--open w/a doorstop, & so it remained thru my checkout the next day. Room was nice & clean, w/ a comfortable chair/ottoman, but the bed was so unbearably hard that I considered sleeping on the floor instead. When I entered the room, phone was blinking w/ a message, which turned out to be a very old one, & impossible to erase (& stop the big red light from blinking). In addition, the alarm clock would not set; the auto message system finally took my wakeup request, but seemed to think the month was May (it was January) -- & so never went off; a call to the front desk to request a wakeup call was unanswered. Thank goodness for the alarm on my cell phone, or I might have missed the barebones free breakfast: cold cereal, lukewarm coffee, orange juice, & waffles. No yogurt, no fruit, no healthful baked goods or way to toast/warm anything. Truly awful. Even the vending machine was devoid of anything healthful to eat -- hoped for, @ least, some trail mix or a granola bar. This place was not the cheapest room I considered, but it should have been. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
I typically associate the Red Roof as the 2 story inn with the red roof. Everything was clean but worn. If new wall coverings were in place it would help(open seems) The old Quality Inn carpets need to go but iff the common areas didn't smell old it would improve things a lot. I rrealize families, investors need to try and make these old inns work but […] it didn't seem up to Red Roof I know from traveling. If I knew the dining room old cooking and food smells were gone as well as other common areas I would stay again. Our room was clean and bed was good. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"good for truck drivers"
old hotel needed updating, dark parking lot back entrancesGenuine Expedia guest review
For a 1 night stay it was adequate. Hallways could be kept up nice.Genuine Expedia guest review
very goodGenuine Hotels.com guest review
It was ok. Tv was broken when we came in. Only found one bug. Hotel was pretty clean, bathroom clean. Average hotel.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
This is a very old dirty un-kept property Stay awayGenuine Expedia guest review
"Great hotel for the price!!!!!!"
Very nice hotel. Staff at desk very friendly. Hotel does need to be updated. Also windows need to be cleaned at front door and rooms. But over all very nice and good waffles. I would go back again. Very good price!!!!!Genuine Expedia guest review
bed, tv, shower. No HBO.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"convenient to Dickinson College at reasonable pric"
worked for our needsGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"Great rooms for Corvettes at Carlisle."
Two dayer for Corvette show this August. Good. Nights sleep. Good distance from traffic with easy drive to fairgrounds. Recommended for Corvettes at Carlisle.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Near Carlisle fairgrounds & available rooms"
I usually prefer to stay in a nicer hotel, however I needed a place to stay for the "Corvettes at Carlisle" event at the fairgrounds and the Red Roof was the only hotels I found that still had rooms available. This looks like an older hotel, possibly used to be a Holiday Inn or other but has seen better days. The carpets, furnishings, etc were old & […] well used although everything looked fairly clean. The continental breakfast was OK was but missed the usual yoghourt & oatmeal. The management and staff were very nice. If I go again next year, I will try to book earlier at better hotel, further away if needed. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Room clean, rest of motel filthy. First room, air conditioner didn't work, second had a stuck shower knob. Continental breakfast was a joke, featured a total of walmart orange juice, and corn flakes or fruit loops. Do they pay their trash pick up bill? Dumpster was piled high with trash, and then stacked next to it in the parking lot. One member of […] staff tried to help with air conditioner, but could not speak English. A couple of signs saying "pardon the renovations" don't excuse filthy stained hallway carpets and dirty paint chipped hand rails that I was afraid to touch. The exterior door locks didn't work, allowing anyone to roam the hallways. Wow! This is the worst ever! Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"overall in very poor condition"
It was the worst Hotel stay ever! The hotel was in extremely poor condition; the a/c stopped working about 10PM and we had to ask to be moved to another room. That room was not prepped for guests, the bathroom was filthy, the ceiling tiles in the BR were covered in mold and mildew; that a/c unit did not work well; the smell in the room was moldy; the […] toilet had a mold/mildew ring around the inside of the bowl, and the toilet kept "running" and was very noisy all night. Please do not recommend this type of accommodation again or to another traveler! Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"good only for a cheap place to crash for the night"
HEADS UP, THE POOL IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION! It doubt it will be fixed this summer (12) but you can call or check the chain's website. This is perfect if you just need to lay your head for the night and want someplace cheap but clean. There wasn't any cobwebs or stray hairs. However, the hallway was VERY musty smelling. The room had a faint smell when […] the air wasn't running and it got stuffy. If you have severe allergies you may want to stay away. My son was fine in the room, but when in the hallway and at breakfast, his allergies were set off (this is not typical for him) Breakfast was just ok....cereal, bagels, and a waffle maker. Great TV selection. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
Kind of dirty and smelly, but I would rather pay this price than a ton more since we were just in and out.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Hotel was not clean,pool had no water.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
We had a very nice experience at the Red Roof. We were greeted by a friendly front desk person, who explained all the details of the hotel to us. Our room was nice, very clean. The hotel is aging but if is kept very nice. My only grip was that the plug in the bath tub didn't stay in so I couldn't have a long soak. But other than that it was very nice. […] I would highly recommend it. Price was awesome... Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
This hotel is in a nice location approximately 1/2 hour away from either Hershey or Gettysburg. I used the free Wifi and it worked perfectly. Basic accommodations, but were clean and adequate. Is located right beside a Bob Evans restaurant and across from a Duncan Donuts. If you want to save money on eating out, a Truck Stop/Denny's/convenience store […] is also right across the street so you can buy some groceries and use the in-room microwave and refridgerator. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
room was alright, had a non-smokeing room that reaked of smoke. wi-fi kept going in and out. great otherwiseGenuine Hotels.com guest review
Everything was OK. No problems but perhaps a bit pricey for the conditions.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Good for sone night stop over"
We stopped on our way to Gettysburg and were satisfied with the condition of the hotel. Our room was clean and in good shape.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"my little girl disappointed"
suppose to have pool but no water and it was 90 degrees out. exercise equipment were broken and old. air conditioner kept shutting off. wouldnt go back again.Genuine Expedia guest review
Bathroom was a little dirty, hallways and room smelled a bit musty. AC so loud as to prevent sleep (but cooled room quickly). Staff was helpful if slow. Breakfast too basic....no yogurt or pastries or toast or fruit or juice (Tang type beverage only alternative to coffee -- and no decaf).Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"Not a very appealing atmosphere"
Hotel did not appear to be maintained at all. Outside was very trashed with papers, plastic,. The trash bin was open with discusting looking "stuff" in and around it. Motel did not smell clean at all inside. Would certainly not stay there again.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Bogus non-smoking room signs and inaccessible Wifi"
We reserved a non-smoking room and it had a no smoking sign by the door but the hallway (particularly the end where we were) and the room both had an overwhelming stale smoke smell. We complained and were given keys to another room, which was even worse. We didn't have time to find another hotel, so we stayed in the first room but it wasn't pleasant. […] My 15-year-old son was amused to find that the smoking/non-smoking signs are removable and could easily be placed on different rooms as needed. Read moreGenuine Expedia guest review
"Comfortable and clean"
This was a nice, nothing fancy, room to spend a night. Reasonable rate. Staff was very polite and friendly. Breakfast was enough, again nothing fancy. Room was very clean, smelled good. Fan in bathroom was very noisy and didn't work well.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Red Roof Carlisle"
Helpful, friendly staff; comfortable bed and quiet location, away from the truck traffic.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Maybe I just got a bad room"
The staff was welcoming and pleasant, the price was right on budget, and the location is very convenient. The room I got, however, is a different story. I was enveloped in mustiness as soon as walked in, and awoke the next morning congested from recycled hotel air. The shower still had the previous guest's used bar of soap in it. The wallpaper was peeling […] off and discolored in some places (though the lighting in the room could have caused the dicolorations). The wallpaper was actually held up by push pins in one place. There was also another safety issue concerning a broken outlet cover. Thankfully, it was just me, just one night, and I wasn't paying for it. I've seen good reviews, so I suspect I just got a raw deal. The only reason I don't give it a 1 star is because the location was nice, and the staff were very nice, too. Read moreGenuine Hotels.com guest review
the whole motel was dirty, the hallways, staircases and the room. i would not recommend this motel to anyone.Genuine Expedia guest review
"Okay place for the one night traveller"
Average accommodations. Hallways were dusty. It looked like some of the rooms were undergoing renovations. Staff were very polite. Breakfast was plain, but reasonable for the price.Genuine Expedia guest review
Room was spacious, clean and very quiet for the price. Even had a continental breakfast. Would definitely stay again and recommend.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"no continental breakfast as advertised"
Overall ok, staff member at desk had no personality and seemed to be bothered by anything we asked him. Room was comfortable and clean.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
Terrible experience. No continental breakfast. Dirty bed. Dirty bathroom.Genuine Expedia guest review
What an awful place! In need of extreme renos. Very dirty hallways. The sheets had cigarette burns and the blankets and pillow cases were stained. The breakfast that was advertised was not available as the dining room was closed. Bad smell of mildew as well. Quite a let down and not recommended to anyone.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
The rooms were just ok, rugs dirty in the halls, seems to be very cold- little heat, no extra blankets. Good contenental breakfast included- good sized room.Genuine Hotels.com guest review
"what a dump"
not to clean have to get your toilet paper glass needs to be renovated not to much for breakfast very very poorGenuine Hotels.com guest review
"L HOTEL RED ROOF ETAIT TRES BIEN POUR DORMIR"
BONNE PLACE POUR PAS ETRE TROP LOIN DU SITE DU FAIRGROUN CETTE HOTEL EST OKGenuine Expedia guest review
Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect Hotels.com’s position. Neither Hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews
We are now watching this hotel on your travel dates
( - )